Schizophrenic Man Who Killed Indonesian National in Germany Avoids Prison Sentence
A court in Koblenz, Germany, has ruled that the defendant in the killing of Indonesian national Isaac Hansen Averino, 24, cannot be held criminally responsible because he has a mental disorder. The defendant, who was diagnosed with paranoid schizophrenia, will be placed in a forensic psychiatric facility for treatment.
CNA reported on Sunday (25 October 2026) that the panel of judges found the defendant, who shared accommodation with the victim, not criminally responsible (Schuldunfähigkeit) under Article 20 of Germany’s Criminal Code.
In its reasoning, the court said the 27-year-old could not be allowed to return to society because his condition could recur, potentially endangering others given his unpredictable behaviour.
The German national was therefore not sentenced to prison, but was ordered to receive treatment at a psychiatric hospital under special supervision.
The treatment has no fixed time limit. The defendant’s release will depend on the progress of his mental health and assessments of the risk he may pose to the public.
Defence lawyer Wolfgang Stahl said his client could be released only after his condition improved and he had undergone the necessary therapy. It is not yet possible to say when that might happen.
“Justice in a case involving someone’s death is always difficult to achieve. However, the ruling is consistent with the applicable law,” Stahl said, as quoted by DW Indonesia on Thursday (22 October).
Before the verdict was delivered, the defendant was given the opportunity to address the court. He apologised and expressed remorse for his actions.
“That was never anything I wanted in my life. Today I want to say that I deeply regret what I did. I wish the best for the family and those left behind by the victim. I hope they can overcome their grief and carry on with their lives,” he said.
Meanwhile, Isaac’s family, represented by lawyer Dagmar Schorn as a supplementary plaintiff (Nebenkläger), said they were dissatisfied with the ruling. Schorn acknowledged that the decision was consistent with German law, but said it could not erase the family’s suffering after losing their son.
“From a legal point of view, the ruling is correct. But my clients will not be satisfied, because when a child has been killed, no verdict can truly satisfy a family,” Schorn said.
The court also ruled that the defendant would not have to pay compensation to the victim’s family, taking his mental condition into account.
Isaac graduated in mechanical engineering, specialising in mechatronics, from Swiss German University (SGU) in Indonesia. He was employed as an automation engineer at the German private company HF Mixing.
The Stabbing Was Reportedly Preceded by an Argument
Isaac died after being stabbed at his home in Kirchen (Sieg), in the German state of Rhineland-Palatinate, on 18 March 2026.
According to Tagesschau, Isaac and the defendant lived in the same apartment building and shared a kitchen. The stabbing is believed to have taken place in the kitchen after the two argued.
Isaac was found dead with multiple sharp-force injuries. He had 39 wounds inflicted with a kitchen knife and an open wound to the skull.
Isaac’s mother, Sri Yuliawati, said she had last communicated with her son shortly before the stabbing.
Yulia said that before 7pm local time, Isaac had told his girlfriend he was going to eat and cook.
A few minutes after that conversation, Isaac’s phone still appeared to be active. However, contact with those close to him in Indonesia was subsequently lost.
The following day, the family received news that Isaac had died and was believed to have been stabbed. For Yulia, a doctor, the incident was difficult to comprehend because she knew her son as someone who did not seek trouble.
Yulia said Isaac tended to distance himself when faced with conflict and had never argued with his younger sibling or friends. She also said he would usually wait until the shared kitchen was empty before going down to cook.
Isaac’s father, Herryanto, spoke of the profound loss the family had suffered following his son’s death.
“This is an enormous loss for us. Isaac was a good child, and we had such high hopes for his future. But this is what happened: he suffered a tragic incident, which could even be called an incomprehensible murder,” Herryanto said during the trial.
“This has, of course, shaken our family life, our emotions, and brought us pain and suffering. We have experienced it all so intensely, and we still feel it today—perhaps for the rest of our lives,” he added.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/schizophrenic-man-who-killed-indonesian-national-in-germany-avoids-prison-sentence-1792932739)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/internasional/d-8723606/alami-skizofrenia-pembunuh-wni-di-jerman-lolos-dari-hukuman-penjara), translated from Indonesian