Saying Bismillah or Bismillahirrahmanirrahim Before Eating: Ulama's Explanation and the Evidence
In practising daily dining etiquette, Muslims are often faced with a simple yet fundamental question: is it sufficient to say ‘Bismillah’, or is it more virtuous to complete it as ‘Bismillahirrahmanirrahim’? This question arises because in several versions of Hadith, Prophet Muhammad SAW textually mentions a concise phrase.
The discussion regarding tasmiah (mentioning the name of Allah) before eating is not merely a linguistic debate, but concerns a deep understanding of the Sunnah and how great scholars interpret the Prophet’s instructions. Let us examine this thoroughly based on authoritative books, as explained by Ustaz Ajir Ubaidillah on his YouTube channel.
The primary basis for this etiquette is the Hadith narrated by Imam Tirmidzi (No. 1858). The Messenger of Allah SAW said: “If one of you eats a meal, then say ‘Bismillah’. If he forgets at the beginning, then say ‘Bismillah fi awalihi wa akhinihi’ (In the name of Allah at the beginning and at the end).”
Textually, this Hadith does indeed stop at the phrase ‘Bismillah’. However, does this mean that adding ‘Bismillahirrahmanirrahim’ constitutes an error or even bid’ah (innovation)? Scholars across various schools of thought have provided very detailed explanations regarding this matter.
Al-Imam Abu Zakaria Yahya bin Syaraf an-Nawawi, a great scholar whose works are global references, discusses this issue in his book Al-Adzkar min Kalami Sayyidil Abrar. He explains: “One important thing to know is the nature of tasmiah. The most afdal (virtuous) is for someone to utter ‘Bismillahirrahmanirrahim’. However, if they only utter ‘Bismillah’, it is sufficient and they have attained the Sunnah.”
Imam Nawawi’s view confirms that adding ‘Ar-Rahman’ and ‘Ar-Rahim’ is a form of perfection in performing dhikr (remembrance) to Allah before eating, even though the minimum requirement is met with ‘Bismillah’.
On the other hand, Al-Imam Ibnu Hajar Al-Asqalani, in his commentary on Sahih Bukhari, provides a critical yet harmonious note. He mentioned, “I have not seen specific evidence regarding the excellence of this (the addition of the phrase).” It should be noted that Ibn Hajar does not forbid or label the addition as bid’ah.
He merely states that specifically, he has not found evidence that commands the addition. However, in general, both methods are considered good and in accordance with the spirit of the Sunnah.
In the modern era, there often arises an attitude of being meddlesome or easily condemning others’ practices with accusations of bid’ah or non-conformity to the Sunnah simply due to differences in phrasing. In reality, scholars of the calibre of Imam Nawawi, whose books such as Riyadhus Shalihin and Arba’in Nawawiyah are studied by many, permit or even prefer the complete phrase.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/saying-bismillah-or-bismillahirrahmanirrahim-before-eating-ulamas-explanation-and-the-evidence-1783014699)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/humaniora/906945/baca-bismillah-atau-bismillahirrahmanirrahim-sebelum-makan-penjelasan-ulama-dan-dalilnya), translated from Indonesian