Save our democracy
Save our democracy
The Oct. 12 bomb attacks in Bali have posed a serious
challenge for Indonesia's commitment to the values and principles
of democracy.
How we, as a nation, respond to this tragedy will determine
whether or not we will survive the litmus test of democracy. At
stake are not only our newfound democracy, but also the future of
Indonesia and, of course, our own lives.
While we need to act collectively to deal with the threat of
terrorism in the wake of Bali, we seem to be far from being in
agreement about the particular details of our response.
A case in point is the raging debate about the latest move by
the government to enact a new set of legislations that supposedly
will empower the state to tackle terrorism. However, the fact
that we are debating at all -- rather than having these
legislations forced down our throat -- is a testament to
democracy itself. This is heartening, if not encouraging.
The proposed anti-terrorism bill, like many legal instruments,
is a double-edged sword. Laws and legislations can protect
people, but they can also harm, or even kill, people. In the
wrong hands, they are a potent weapon that could undermine
democracy itself.
This is why many in the civil society camp hold strong
reservations about the bill, especially having just dumped the
1963 anti-subversion law, which was not all that different from
the set of anti-terrorism bill the government has just submitted
for deliberation.
It has been four years since Indonesia emerged from nearly 40
years of living under two successive tyrants. That era has left a
deep scar on the nation, so much so that it is only natural for
people to be suspicious or wary about unnecessarily granting too
much power to the state, even in the name of counter-terrorism.
The anti-subversion law was intended to protect the nation and
the state from acts of terrorism, as is proposed by the anti-
terrorism bill. But both president Sukarno, who enacted the law
in 1963, and later Soeharto, used the legislation so effectively,
if not cunningly, to quell their opponents. By invoking the need
to protect the state, Sukarno and Soeharto used the law to jail,
torture, and even kill anyone who was seen as even a remote
threat to their power.
Today, many in the civil society in this country feel that
they simply cannot trust the government, now or in the future,
with the extra powers that the bill seeks to give.
They have rejected the idea of having the legislations at all,
even without so much as discussing the substance or any
particular details of the law. They fear, justifiably perhaps,
that the counter-terrorism bill would only pave the way for the
return of state-sponsored terrorism. Civil liberty, the very
thing we have been fighting for all these years, will simply go
out the window.
In the wake of the Bali bombing tragedy, however, there is an
equally compelling argument that Indonesia needs an anti-
terrorism law. The Oct. 12 bombings have exposed weaknesses in
our legal system in dealing with such attacks and threats. The
penal code only empowers the state to deal with terrorism after
an attack, and even then, only within a limited function.
The government was legally handicapped to deal with, or even
to anticipate, the threat of terrorism. As a result, although the
writing had been on the wall weeks before Oct. 12, the government
literally sat and waited for the Bali tragedy to strike.
The government's reluctance or rather, lack of political will,
probably accounted for its failure to act, aside from its legal
constraints. Some might even argue that the terrorist attack
would still have happened even if the government had been in a
position to deal with the threat. The United States, with all its
money and intelligence-gathering capability, still failed to
anticipate the terrorist attacks of Sept. 11 last year.
Nevertheless, a deal has been made between the democratically
elected administration of President Megawati Soekarnoputri and
the equally democratically elected House of Representatives, that
Indonesia needs a new set of anti-terrorism legislations.
The government claims that the anti-terrorism bill has taken
into account those concerns regarding potential abuses of power.
Some articles have ensured that the new legislations would not
lead to the loss of civil liberties guaranteed under the
constitution.
Now that a decision has been made, the best thing the nation
can do is to deliberate them thoroughly. We should give democracy
itself a chance to resolve our differences.
Those in the civil society camp who oppose the legislations
altogether would do well to join in the deliberation, and argue
particular articles in the legislations. If their chief concerns
are civil liberty and democracy, then they themselves should
ensure that those guarantees are written in the legislations.
In short, they would serve the nation much better by taking an
active part in the process. Boycotting or staying away from the
debate would only play into the hands of those who hope to abuse
the powers granted by the legislations.
More from 14 November 2002 โ
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/save-our-democracy-1447893297-1220786)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post