Saudi-Houthi Conflict Escalates; Indonesia Should Consider Pausing Umrah Departures, Analyst Says
JAKARTA — Geopolitical tensions on the Arabian Peninsula are escalating, particularly the armed confrontation between the Saudi-led Arab coalition and Yemen’s Houthi faction. Imas Damayanti, an Islamic economics analyst at Paramadina University, said the conflict is not only disrupting security but also acting as a disruptive variable in the global economic landscape. She therefore recommended that the Indonesian Government stop or temporarily postpone Umrah departures to Saudi Arabia.
Imas said the Saudi-Houthi conflict affects the organisation of Umrah in Saudi Arabia, with security concerns and the prospect of pilgrims being unable to worship comfortably weighing on them. As the world’s most populous Muslim-majority country, Indonesia plays a crucial role in the global Umrah ecosystem. From an Islamic economics perspective, she said, the situation calls not only for macroeconomic analysis of material losses but also for a reassessment of fiqh al-awlawiyyat (the jurisprudence of priorities), guided by the framework of Maqashid al-Shariah, to formulate mitigating public-interest policies.
“Indonesia’s Government should postpone our pilgrims’ Umrah departures to Saudi Arabia until the conflict subsides,” Imas said, as quoted by Indonesia Alyoum on Tuesday (13 October 2026).
Imas acknowledged that under Saudi Vision 2030, religious tourism, including Hajj and Umrah, is projected to be a key pillar of the kingdom’s non-oil economic diversification. A lack of Indonesian Umrah pilgrims, she said, could affect security and trigger a significant supply-and-demand shock to Saudi Arabia’s external balance of payments. In Indonesia, the volume of Umrah departures is also considered highly influential to the viability of the domestic Umrah travel industry.
According to her figures, Indonesia consistently ranks as the world’s second-largest source of Umrah visitors, averaging between 1.2 million and 1.5 million pilgrims a year. Based on a macroeconomic calculation of average spending on accommodation, domestic transport, food and land arrangements, she estimated that each Umrah pilgrim spends about US$1,000–1,200 in Saudi Arabia.
“Are the economic impacts on both Saudi Arabia and Indonesia worth the risk to pilgrims’ safety? I don’t think so. Pilgrims’ safety must come first,” she said.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/saudi-houthi-conflict-escalates-indonesia-should-consider-pausing-umrah-departures-analyst-says-1791867090)
Originally published by Republika (https://khazanah.republika.co.id/berita/tmtvb6430/konflik-saudihouthi-memanas-pengamat-indonesia-sebaiknya-tunda-mengirim-jamaah-umrah), translated from Indonesian