Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Said Abdullah Questions MSCI’s Stance on Indonesia’s Stock Market

| Source: detikcom Translated from Indonesian | Finance
Said Abdullah Questions MSCI’s Stance on Indonesia’s Stock Market
Image: detikcom

Said Abdullah, chair of the Indonesian House of Representatives’ Budget Committee, has spoken out about Morgan Stanley Capital International’s (MSCI) announcement concerning the Indonesia Stock Exchange (IDX). MSCI said Indonesia’s stock market could be downgraded from Emerging Market to Standalone Market.

The announcement weakened shares on the IDX. The Jakarta Composite Index (JCI) plunged 11.57% by the close of trading on Friday (16 October 2026). On the same day, a number of large-cap and blue-chip stocks also came under heavy pressure.

“Is the IDX really deserving of this treatment? Is MSCI acting solely with the noble aim of improving governance in Indonesia’s stock market? I hope MSCI is entirely acting in that spirit. Whatever the case, we should still accept MSCI’s criticism as a serious evaluation,” Said Abdullah said in a statement received by detikcom on Sunday (18 October 2026).

“MSCI is not a religious institution in which essential truth is inherent, and its officials are not prophets with exclusive and infallible authority. We are therefore entitled to scrutinise it too. I think this reciprocal, critical relationship is good for both sides,” he added.

Said questioned MSCI’s intention to place the IDX in quarantine in the Standalone Market category, noting that several Indonesian state institutions had implemented a number of its recommendations.

“To my knowledge, and without intending to defend the IDX or the Financial Services Authority (OJK), both institutions have told the House in their performance reports that they are gradually implementing MSCI’s policy recommendations. The IDX, the Indonesian Central Securities Depository (KSEI) and the OJK have also been proactive in communicating with MSCI,” he said.

“We know that the OJK has raised the free-float requirement on a tiered basis according to market capitalisation, to 15%, 20% and 25%. It has also imposed hundreds of sanctions on market participants. The question is: why has MSCI not given even the slightest recognition to these steps?” he added.

Said nevertheless said domestic institutions remained slow in some areas, a matter that he said required attention.

“We cannot turn a blind eye to practices of ‘price manipulation’ in Indonesia’s stock trading. We must also acknowledge that KSEI and the OJK have tended to be slow in disclosing share-ownership information. KSEI and the OJK should be urged to further improve the granularity of investor data and provide the broadest possible access to information about parties’ shareholdings. I think these are reasonable demands from MSCI as a ratings organisation,” he said.

“I fully understand that MSCI, as a guide for investors, has an interest in providing complete information so that investors can make sound and accurate investment decisions, supported by adequate risk analysis. Accurate share-ownership data is one way to achieve this. There are still gaps, but gradual progress has been made. Unfortunately, all the authorities’ efforts to improve the market seem to count for nothing in MSCI’s eyes,” he added.

Said said he did not reject MSCI’s criticism. If anything remained unclear, he said, MSCI could communicate directly with the relevant authorities. He noted that another index provider, FTSE Russell, had recognised Indonesia’s efforts to improve investor classification and tighten market oversight.

“Compared with another ratings organisation, FTSE Russell, Indonesia remains in the Secondary Emerging Market group alongside 13 other countries, including China, India, the Philippines, Vietnam and Saudi Arabia. FTSE Russell made this decision after seeing efforts to improve investor classification, increase free float and tighten market oversight,” Said said.

“Why has FTSE Russell recognised the IDX’s reform efforts while MSCI has not? If something is unclear, could it not be discussed with the authorities? Once again, I do not reject MSCI’s criticism, provided it is fully intended to improve the capital market. I do not think MSCI would want to put its credibility at stake over this,” he added.

Said described MSCI’s announcement as ironic, saying that some foreign investors had taken advantage of the market slump to buy shares that had fallen sharply.

“Ironically, while share prices fell following the announcement, foreign investors also returned to buy shares traded on the IDX that MSCI considers poor. On 16 October 2026, when MSCI placed the IDX in the Standalone Market category and the JCI fell, some investors made gains. Foreign investors bought shares worth Rp9.18 trillion,” he said.

“Of course, I am not accusing an organisation of MSCI’s stature of conspiring to drive down the JCI and give foreign investors an opportunity to take profits. But it is difficult to deny that, knowingly or otherwise, MSCI’s policy benefits hedge funds,” he added.

Said said he would continue to push for and support improvements to Indonesia’s capital market.

“MSCI officials are not prophets delivering sacred words or apostles writing holy books, able to monopolise flawless truth. I hope MSCI is not acting as a proxy for a superpower,” Said said.

“There is a wise saying I think we should reflect on together: improving Indonesia’s capital market is like searching for a needle in a rice field when the rice is golden and ready for harvest. Let us find the needle, but not damage the ripening rice by trampling it as we search,” he concluded.

More from 18 October 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/said-abdullah-questions-mscis-stance-on-indonesias-stock-market-1792299037)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/berita/d-8712241/said-abdullah-pertanyakan-sikap-msci-terhadap-pasar-saham-ri), translated from Indonesian
Print