Safeguarding the Digital Public Sphere: Seeking a Middle Path for Podcast Content Supervision in the Social Media Era
The development of digital technology has fundamentally altered the landscape of public communication. While television and radio were once the primary media for information and entertainment, the public now increasingly consumes content through digital platforms such as YouTube, Spotify, TikTok, and various other social media.
One format experiencing rapid growth is the podcast, in both audio and video forms. This format offers freedom of expression, production flexibility, and a sense of intimacy between creators and audiences. However, behind these advantages, new issues have emerged regarding the supervision of broadcast content.
In Indonesia, conventional broadcasting is regulated through the Broadcasting Law and supervised by the Indonesian Broadcasting Commission (KPI) under the primary guidelines of the Broadcasting Code of Conduct and Program Standards (P3SPS). Through these instruments, KPI can issue warnings, sanctions, or even the suspension of programmes deemed to violate norms of decency, ethics, child protection, or the social values living within Indonesian society.
The problem is that many podcast programmes broadcast via social media platforms do not fall into the category of broadcasting institutions as intended by current regulations. Consequently, this content remains outside the direct oversight of KPI. A significant number of podcasts feature vulgar discussions, coarse language, the glorification of deviant behaviour, and the spread of unverified information. In many cases, such content gains high popularity precisely because it is perceived as more free, controversial, and attention-grabbing. This phenomenon raises an important question: how can we maintain the quality of the digital public space without hindering freedom of expression?
Some parties propose a solution through regulatory revision, specifically the Broadcasting Law, so that the scope of supervision can be expanded to digital platforms. Theoretically, this approach is possible. The state could update the definition of broadcasting to include audiovisual content distributed via the internet. Thus, guidelines such as P3SPS could be applied more broadly to digital content providers with large public reaches.
However, a purely regulatory approach is not always the most effective solution. The character of digital media differs from conventional broadcasting. The number of creators is vast, content production occurs massively every day, and distribution crosses national jurisdictions. Overly strict supervision also risks triggering allegations of restricting freedom of expression and hindering the growing digital economic creativity. Therefore, a more adaptive middle ground is required while waiting for more comprehensive regulatory developments.
Firstly, a mechanism of co-regulation must be developed between the government, digital platforms, creator communities, and the public. In this model, the state does not act as the sole supervisor but rather as a facilitator in drafting digital content ethical standards. These guidelines could adopt the core values of P3SPS, such as respect for decency, child protection, respect for diversity, and the prohibition of hate speech and violence.
Secondly, podcast creator associations should be encouraged to develop their own professional codes of ethics. Just as the journalism profession has a respected code of ethics, the podcaster and content creator community can build mutually agreed standards of behaviour. Creators who violate these could face moral sanctions, such as revocation of membership, loss of reputation, or limitations on professional collaborations. This mechanism is more flexible than state sanctions yet remains capable of shaping a culture of responsible content production.
Thirdly, digital platforms must take a more active role. While YouTube and other platforms already have community guidelines, these standards are generally global. However, every country possesses different cultural values. Therefore, platforms need to strengthen cooperation with national stakeholders to develop moderation systems that are more sensitive to the Indonesian social and cultural context. Content containing elements of pornography, hate speech, bullying, or child exploitation must be handled more swiftly and effectively.
Fourthly, age classification systems need to be applied more consistently. Many podcasts intended for adult audiences are easily accessible to children and teenagers. Age labelling, access restrictions, and parental control features must be strengthened to optimise the protection of vulnerable groups. The principle of child protection is a core value of P3SPS that remains relevant in the digital era. Through the Ministry of Communication and Digital, the government has implemented Government Regulation Number 17 of 2025 regarding the Management and Protection of Children in the Digital Space.
This regulation, often referred to as the ‘PP Tunas’, has been welcomed by the public, as it mandates digital platforms to deactivate or restrict access to social media accounts and games for children under the age of 16. This regulation has also been adopted by the Malaysian government, where platforms face fines of up to 10 million Malaysian Ringgit, equivalent to approximately Rp 45 billion, for violations.
Fifthly, public digital literacy must become a top priority. The best form of supervision does not only come from regulators but from a critical and intelligent audience. The public needs to be equipped with the ability to assess the quality of information, understand the risks of negative content, and choose viewing material that aligns with their needs and social values. The higher the literacy…
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/safeguarding-the-digital-public-sphere-seeking-a-middle-path-for-podcast-content-supervision-in-the-social-1781765537)
Originally published by Republika (https://analisis.republika.co.id/berita/tgtd5p472/menjaga-ruang-publik-digital-mencari-jalan-tengah-pengawasan-konten-siniar-di-era-media-sosial), translated from Indonesian