S&P Retains Indonesia's Market Status, but Downgrade Looms If Issues Persist
Global index provider S&P Dow Jones Indices (S&P DJI) has maintained the Indonesian Stock Exchange’s (BEI) classification as an Emerging Market, but has issued a stern warning that its status could be downgraded if persistent structural issues are not resolved. In its Country Classification Watchlist for 2026-2027, released on 7 July 2026, S&P DJI placed Indonesia on the watchlist for 2027, indicating a potential reclassification from Emerging Market to Special Measures or Frontier Market status. Turkey was also placed on the watchlist under a similar scenario, whilst Nigeria was flagged for a possible upgrade from Standalone to Frontier.
The core concern driving S&P DJI’s decision is the lack of transparency in shareholding structures and its impact on liquidity and reliable price formation. Global institutional investors have long complained about the opacity of ownership structures on the Indonesian bourse, coupled with concerns over suspected coordinated trading patterns. These factors make it difficult for foreign investors to gauge the true free float and raise doubts about whether market prices genuinely reflect fair mechanisms.
S&P DJI acknowledged that Indonesian authorities, including the Financial Services Authority (OJK) and the Indonesia Stock Exchange (BEI), have taken regulatory steps to address these issues. However, the index provider cautioned that if the problems are not fully resolved, Indonesia could face Special Measures or a downgrade to Frontier Market status during the 2027 annual review. Conversely, improvements in transparency and liquidity could bolster positive sentiment and secure the country’s Emerging Market classification.
This warning follows similar pressure from MSCI, which in its 2026 Market Classification Review downgraded Indonesia’s Information Flow criterion from no major issues to requiring improvement. MSCI highlighted the same structural problems: opaque shareholding structures, indications of coordinated trading that disrupt price discovery, and a lack of timely English-language disclosures for foreign investors. MSCI warned that without adequate progress by its November 2026 Index Review, it would consider reclassifying Indonesia from Emerging to Frontier Market.
The stakes are high, as foreign outflows from the Indonesian stock market have already reached approximately US$3.6 billion this year. A downgrade by either S&P or MSCI could trigger even larger capital flight, given that passive global funds track indices tied to specific market classifications.
In response, Indonesian regulators have launched a series of reforms. The Financial Services Authority (OJK), together with the BEI and the Indonesian Central Securities Depository (KSEI), has lowered the threshold for mandatory shareholder identity disclosure from 5% to 1% to enhance transparency. They have also implemented a High Shareholding Concentration (HSC) framework to monitor concentrated ownership, raised the minimum free-float requirement gradually from 7.5% to 15% with sanctions including potential delisting for non-compliance, and aligned Ultimate Beneficial Owner (UBO) guidelines with global investor expectations. The OJK has stressed that transparency is the top priority in overhauling the capital market and has requested that the BEI hold regular technical meetings with MSCI to resolve outstanding issues, particularly the timely availability of English-language disclosures for foreign investors.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/s-p-retains-indonesias-market-status-but-downgrade-looms-if-issues-persist-1783479071)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/market/20260708090720-17-749005/sp-pertahankan-status-bursa-ri-tapi-terancam-turun-kelas-jika), translated from Indonesian