Rupiah Exchange Rate and the High Price of Trust
Currency is ultimately not just an economic issue; it is a matter of trust. When the public believes the economy will grow, they dare to invest, start businesses, buy homes, and plan for the future.
When market players are confident that the government has a clear policy direction and public institutions operate credibly, capital will flow and economic activity will move with optimism. Conversely, when trust begins to weaken, caution turns into anxiety, optimism turns into speculation, and the market moves under the shadow of uncertainty.
Nobel laureate Kenneth Arrow explained that trust is one of the foundations that allows economic and social systems to function effectively. In an increasingly complex modern world, trust is not merely a moral value, but a decisive economic asset.
Perhaps this is something we should reflect upon when the Rupiah breaches the psychological level of Rp18,000 per US Dollar. That figure is not merely a statistical record; it is a signal conveying a deeper message about how the market perceives Indonesia’s current economic condition and how they assess Indonesia’s future.
Of course, the weakening of the Rupiah does not occur in a vacuum. Global uncertainty continues to shadow the world economy. Prolonged geopolitical conflicts are driving up energy prices and disrupting international supply chains. At the same time, relatively tight monetary policies in the United States ensure the US Dollar remains a primary destination for global investors. International capital flows are moving towards assets considered safer, thereby exerting pressure on various developing nation currencies, including Indonesia’s.
However, the question remains: is the weakening of the Rupiah solely a result of external factors?
I do not believe it is that simple. In recent months, the market has not only been discussing the Federal Reserve’s interest rates or global oil prices. Investors have also begun to scrutinise the direction of national economic policy, the quality of public institution governance, and the government’s ability to maintain stability amidst global uncertainty. In other words, what is being assessed is not just Indonesia’s current economic condition, but also the confidence in Indonesia’s future.
This is where we must understand that an exchange rate is truly more than just a number moving on a trading screen. An exchange rate is a reflection of trust.
The market never punishes a country simply because it faces problems. No country is entirely free from issues. What concerns the market is whether the country possesses the capacity, credibility, and consistency to resolve the problems it faces.
This view aligns with the rational expectations theory developed by Robert Lucas (1972). According to Lucas, economic actors do not make decisions based solely on current conditions. They form expectations regarding the future and act based on those expectations. Investors do not merely buy assets; they buy hope for the future.
Therefore, currency depreciation is often a psychological phenomenon before it becomes an economic one. When confidence in the future begins to weaken, the market reacts even before economic indicators show significant changes.
This perspective explains why two countries with relatively similar economic indicators can receive different market responses. The difference often lies not in macroeconomic figures, but in the level of trust held in their respective public institutions.
In modern economics, trust is no longer a supplementary factor; it has become a strategic asset. Michael Spence (1973), through signalling theory, explains that when information is not perfectly available, society and the market use various signals to assess the quality of an institution. In a national context, these signals can include economic policy, the quality of government governance, the independence of state institutions, and the consistency of public communication.
The market does not have access to all available information. Therefore, they read signals. When the signals received indicate a certain direction and policy consistency, the level of trust will increase. Conversely, when signals appear ambiguous or even contradictory, uncertainty will grow.
Fixing Policy Communication
For years, communication has often been viewed merely as a means of conveying information to the public. This view is no longer adequate. In contemporary economic practice, communication has evolved into an instrument of policy itself.
Recent studies show that central bank communication plays a vital role in shaping expectations and reducing market uncertainty. The effectiveness of monetary policy is determined not only by the decisions made but also by the ability to explain those decisions clearly, consistently, and credibly to the public.
This means that good policy may not necessarily produce good results if it fails to be communicated convincingly. Conversely, credible communication can strengthen the effectiveness of a policy even when economic conditions are facing pressure.
Therefore, Indonesia’s current economic challenge is not merely maintaining exchange rate stability or controlling inflation. An equally important challenge is maintaining credibility.
Douglass North (1990) reminds us that institutions are the primary foundation for economic activity. Credible institutions create certainty, lower transaction costs, and increase trust. Conversely, institutions that lose credibility…
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/rupiah-exchange-rate-and-the-high-price-of-trust-1782787927)
Originally published by Republika (https://analisis.republika.co.id/berita/thfa2o393/nilai-tukar-rupiah-dan-harga-mahal-kepercayaan), translated from Indonesian