Roy Suryo's Legal Team Claims Police Expert Only Presented Normative Statements in Pretrial Hearing
Roy Suryo’s legal counsel has taken the view that the criminal law expert presented by Jakarta Metro Police in the evidentiary session of the pre-trial hearing at the South Jakarta District Court on Wednesday (15/7) only gave explanations of a normative nature and had yet to answer the substance of the issues raised in their petition.
Roy Suryo’s lawyer, Refly Harun, said his side actually felt more confident about the arguments put forward after hearing the testimony of the expert presented by the respondent.
“The respondent has been unable to show that there is a witness, an expert or a document of a particular quality such that Article 32 Paragraph 1 could be applied,” Refly told journalists after the hearing.
According to Refly, the expert brought by Jakarta Metro Police explained more about the general provisions of criminal procedure law than the core of the case being contested by the petitioner.
“What the criminal law expert explained was purely normative in nature. That means the expert’s testimony could equally have been delivered at another pre-trial hearing, or in another court, because he only explained the norms relating to how the Criminal Procedure Code operates,” he said.
He said that when the discussion turned to the application of Article 32 paragraph (1) of the Electronic Information and Transactions Law (UU ITE), the expert was judged not to have given any explanation that answered the issues raised by the petitioner.
“When it came down to Article 32 Paragraph 1, he himself acknowledged that there were in fact several contradictions which, unfortunately, we could not explore further,” said Refly.
Refly cited one of the unanswered matters as the question of the object used as the basis for the suspicion under Article 32 paragraph (1). He noted that the article concerns electronic documents or information, whereas investigators had previously also shown a physical diploma.
“So the question now is: what exactly is to be used as the key evidence? Is it Dian Sandi’s diploma uploaded to the internet, or the analogue or physical diploma of Jokowi which was said to be brought in and shown at Jakarta Metro Police on 15 December 2025?” he said.
Earlier in the hearing, the criminal law expert presented by Jakarta Metro Police, Prof. Dr. Erdianto Effendi, had indeed devoted much of his explanation to the limits of a pre-trial judge’s authority in examining whether a suspect designation is lawful or not.
According to Erdianto, a person may be designated a suspect if investigators have obtained at least two valid pieces of evidence.
“As long as there is a minimum of two pieces of evidence, that is sufficient for investigators to designate someone as a suspect,” Erdianto told the sole judge.
He also affirmed that a pre-trial hearing is not tasked with assessing the quality or the evidentiary strength of a case.
“As for the strength of the evidence? That is not an object of pre-trial proceedings, because the strength of the evidence will be tested later in the main case,” he said.
Erdianto reiterated that the scope of pre-trial proceedings is limited solely to examining formal aspects.
“Pre-trial review stops only at examining whether evidence exists or not, whether the evidence is sufficient or not,” he said.
In addition, Erdianto took the view that the Criminal Procedure Code does not regulate any order of priority among pieces of evidence. According to him, investigators need not first obtain witness testimony before designating someone as a suspect.
“Not every case has witnesses among its evidence. Sometimes there are no witnesses, yet the case must still proceed,” he said.
Nevertheless, Roy Suryo’s camp maintained that the principal issue in this pre-trial hearing is not merely the quantity of evidence, but the quality of the evidence used by investigators to apply Article 32 paragraph (1) of the ITE Law.
According to Refly, by the close of the evidentiary session, the respondent had still not explained the concrete pieces of evidence considered capable of fulfilling the elements of the article.
“Our challenge has gone unanswered, or could not be answered, by the respondent,” said Refly.
The hearing, presided over by sole judge I Ketut Darpawan, has reached the evidentiary stage. The next session will be held on Thursday (16/7).
“Tomorrow, the concluding statements will be at 2pm,” said sole judge I Ketut Darpawan after the hearing.
This pre-trial case stems from a lawsuit filed by Roy Suryo against his designation as a suspect by Jakarta Metro Police in a case concerning the alleged dissemination of false diploma claims implicating Indonesia’s seventh President, Joko Widodo.
Through the pre-trial petition, Roy Suryo has asked the sole judge to declare his designation as a suspect unlawful. He has also requested that the judge annul three Investigation Warrants (Sprindik) issued by Jakarta Metro Police between 2025 and 2026.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/roy-suryos-legal-team-claims-police-expert-only-presented-normative-statements-in-pretrial-hearing-1784119890)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/politik-dan-hukum/911268/kuasa-hukum-roy-suryo-sebut-ahli-polda-hanya-sampaikan-hal-normatif-di-sidang-praperadilan), translated from Indonesian