Robust Dispute Resolution Governance Seen as a Driver of Investment
Indonesia’s score of 64 out of 100 for Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) in the Business Ready (B-READY) report indicates that several aspects need strengthening. This was stated by Adhyaksa University academic Rudi Pradisetia Sudirja at an academic engagement event held by the Attorney General’s Office Deputy Attorney General for Civil and Administrative Matters (Jamdatun) in partnership with the University of Indonesia’s Faculty of Law (FHUI) on Monday (2 November).
“An assessment of alternative dispute resolution mechanisms found several areas that still need improvement. The indicators for mediator independence and impartiality scored 0 out of 4.17, mediation transparency scored 0 out of 4.17, while the digitalisation of mediation scored 2.78 out of 4.17,” Rudi said.
Rudi added that these figures do not mean ADR is being implemented poorly in Indonesia, but rather that existing practices have yet to be standardised. This, he said, can make it appear that ADR is recognised only in law but ineffective in practice. “Out-of-court dispute resolution mechanisms have legal recognition. However, institutional governance, independence and transparency need to be strengthened to build the confidence of the parties,” he explained.
Legal recognition also leaves issues unresolved, given the variety of ADR formats. Rudi noted that mediation, conciliation and arbitration are not connected within a shared ecosystem. Governance of supporting tools, including the use of technology and documentation, is also inconsistent.
Rudi said this lack of uniformity in supporting arrangements may stem from the absence of dedicated, standardised venues for ADR. “There are no dedicated hearing facilities for public-sector disputes. As a result, proceedings often take place in hotels, restaurants or public spaces,” he added.
Procedural and facility shortcomings help explain Indonesia’s low B-READY score for ADR. Rudi said robust ADR governance could encourage investment, as investors consider how quickly, safely and predictably disputes can be resolved. “Ease of doing business needs to be matched by ease of resolving disputes. Singapore has an arbitration and mediation ecosystem through SIAC, SIMC and Maxwell Chambers. Another example is Dubai, which supports confidence in cross-border transactions through the DIFC as an integrated dispute-resolution institution. In other words, global business centres always grow alongside dispute-resolution centres,” Rudi said.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/robust-dispute-resolution-governance-seen-as-a-driver-of-investment-1794070222)
Originally published by hukumonline.com (https://www.hukumonline.com/berita/a/tata-kelola-penyelesaian-sengketa-yang-kokoh-dinilai-dapat-mendorong-investasi-lt6aeee7edbed85/), translated from Indonesian