Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

~Rita A. Widiadana

~Rita A. Widiadana
and I Wayan Juniartha
The Jakarta Post
Denpasar, Bali

Nothing cuts deeper than the loss of image and a
shattered peace, especially when the victim is not to blame. It
is what happened to the once tranquil island of Bali, a venerated
paradise for the world's tourists.
Overnight, the bombings of Oct. 12, 2002, exacted a
tremendous toll on the lives of the Balinese people, the island's
lucrative tourism industry and, most of all, its sense of
security, the very factor which led to it becoming one of the
world's favorite tourist destinations.
Long before the Bali bombing incident rocked its image,
the island's cultural charms and natural beauty were tainted due
to overexploitation of cultural and natural resources and the
frenzied commercialization of tourism.
Arthur Gillette, a cultural expert formerly with the
United Nations Education and Cultural Organization (Unesco),
lamented that Bali was taking the wrong direction in its
development.
"If I visit Bali, I don't want to see McDonald's outlets
or luxury boutiques lining the resort areas of Kuta or Nusa Dua.
I want to see the real Bali with its unique culture and
religion," he explained on the sidelines of the recent conference
of the Pacific Asia Travel Association at the Nusa Dua resort
complex.
Legendary travel writer P.F. Kluge revealed in National
Geographic Traveler the real beauty of the island.
"Beyond the celebrated surf and beaches, the rice
terraces and volcanoes, and nowadays, beyond the white-water
rafting, bungee jumping, and swimming with dolphins, the island
has spiritual depth, a version of Hinduism that defines and
orders life at every level, creating a tight weave of ritual and
offerings," he wrote.
That was Bali a few decades ago. Now, it has been transformed
into what renowned landscape architect and writer Made Wijaya, a
self-confessed lover of the island, terms "a high-density
paradise theme park."
Today Bali is desperately trying to repair its sorry
image and lure back tourists - and their precious revenue.
Since tourism has been the island's most lucrative
resource, threats to the industry strike fear into the entire
population of Bali. An estimated 80 percent of its 3 million
population rely on tourism for their livelihood, either directly
or indirectly.
For Indonesia, Bali is crucial since it generates 30
percent of the country's estimated US$5 billion in average
foreign exchange revenue from tourism.
People base their decisions regarding holiday travel and
destinations on a range of factors, the most important being rest
and relaxation, opportunities to have a good time, value for
money, facilities and packages that cater to families and the
chance to experience a different culture.
For foreign tourists, Bali met all the criteria as a charmed,
exotic destination.
It had something for everybody, from sparklingly clean luxury
resorts to cheap backpackers haunts, from its notorious girlie
bars and clubs to sacred cultural draws. On the downside, purists
derided it as a prime example of the ugly side of mass tourism,
with prostitution and ubiquitous hawkers at the ready for the
planeloads of Western tourists hunting for sun, surf and sex.
Its image problem worsened in the aftermath of the bombings, when
it became glaringly clear that the push for tourism development
was not matched by a commensurate concern for infrastructure.
Photos of severely injured tourists receiving the most basic
medical assistance in the island's hospitals did not instill a
sense of confidence in prospective visitors.
Immediately after the bombings, UNDP conducted a comprehensive
assessment on the impact of the Bali bombing on people in Bali,
as well as those from neighboring East Java and Lombok.
UNDP expert Nick Mawdsley described the far-reaching
effects of the bombing on tourism and tourist-related businesses,
such as insecurity about community livelihood, reduced consumer
spending, increased poverty and growing tensions.
In the wake of the bombings, almost two-thirds of hotels
could not cover operational costs or debt repayment, with 54
percent of establishments reporting a drop in both international
and domestic tourists. About 30 percent of hotels operated on
reduced hours and 10 percent of tourism-related businesses were
forced to make temporary layoffs.
Also hard hit were small-scale and medium scale (SMEs)
enterprises, including vendors of garments, furniture and
handicrafts,
In December 2002, 40 percent of SMEs admitted problems paying
suppliers and staff, with 14 percent laying off workers. The
wider impact was evident when 30 percent of the island's villages
reported people returning home because of lost jobs and
insufficient income in the tourist centers.
Bearing the brunt was Kuta, the traditional hub for
tourists, especially those from Australia, and the site of the
bombings. Beach traders suffered significant reductions in daily
income of 78 percent. One in four now earns less than Rp 15,000
per day, with 30 percent planning to give up their work.
East Java and Lombok have not gone unscathed. About 60 percent of
handicraft products sold in Bali were from other provinces,
particularly East Java and Lombok, which are reporting 40 percent
and 70 percent reduction in sales for traders and producers.
About 62 percent of hotels in Lombok, which endured its own
public relations nightmare after a riot several years ago, cannot
cover operational costs.
"Local security, social security, social protection for the poor,
support to SMEs, as well as reorienting tourism to benefit the
poor and promote Bali tourism have been our main priorities,"
Mawdsley said.
Foreign tourists have turned instead to Fiji, Vanuatu, Thailand,
New Zealand as well as the Gold Coast and Broome in Australia as
substitutes for the enchanted island. Even so, very few places
are able to offer the same value for money as Bali, according to
a recent survey by the Australian tourist promotion and public
relations agency Gavin Anderson and Co.
The survey, made under the auspices of the Indonesian
Ministry of Culture and Tourism, was carried out soon after the
Bali bombings to gauge international consumers' views. Targeted
for interviews were travel agent federations, key airlines
servicing Bali, foreign officials, editors of mainstream
newspapers, as well as travel media in the United Kingdom,
Australia, United States, Germany and the Netherlands.
The overall sentiment was that tourism in Bali would eventually
return to normal, although the expected timeframe differed
between countries, from six months to five years.
"Political instability was cited by all surveyed countries as a
deterrent for travel to Bali and Indonesia, with safety and
security being raised as prominent issues," said John King, a
public relations and tourism expert from Australia.
Despite its woes, Bali still has reason to count its blessings.
The island has received international morale support and, more
importantly, funds to put its tourism industry back on its feet.
Prominent donor agencies including the World Bank, the
United Nations Development Program (UNDP), USAID, AUSAid and many
foreign governments would not let the island's economy sink
without trace.
For short-term social and economic recovery, USAID Bali
Recovery pledged more than US$1 million, AusAId Health Sector
Support (A$10.5 million), UNDP Community Recovery Program
($300,000 from DFID-UK) and AusAid Bali Rehabilitation Fund
(A$750,000).
For the longer term economic recovery program, the World Bank is
providing US$28 million for all subdistricts, while the Japanese
government allotted US$20 million for economic recovery and
social protection.
More recent events, including the war in Iraq and the outbreak of
Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome (SARS), have shown the
vulnerability of tourism to forces beyond its control.
"It would be important for the government, donors and other
sectors to work together to help Bali retain its image as a
potential economic source. However, it should consider thinking
of alternative sources other than tourism," Mawdsley said.
Balinese scholar Anak Agung Gede Rai insisted that tourism is a
necessity to the island.
"It is our lifeblood. Without tourism, the Balinese would only
subsist as poor farmers," he said.
He admitted that tourism development on the island had become
uncontrolled, with almost no regulation of projects.
"The tragedy in Bali and in the whole world must be perceived as
a turning point to implement a new legacy. It must be done
through reevaluating our past tourism development and improving
it to achieve balance and a sustainable tourism industry, "he
said.
1

More from 23 April 2003 โ†’

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/rita-a-widiadana-1447893297-1363865)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post
Print