Rieke Diah Pitaloka: Legal Reform Success Cannot Be Measured by Budget Absorption Alone
Member of Commission XIII of the House of Representatives (DPR), Rieke Diah Pitaloka, has stated that the Ministry of Law’s achievements in the 2025 fiscal year State Budget (APBN) Central Government Financial Report (LKPP) should not be assessed solely on the size of budget absorption or the level of Non-Tax State Revenue (PNBP).
According to her, measures of success must also reflect the quality of legal reform, legal certainty, and the protection of citizens’ constitutional rights.
Rieke made these remarks during a working meeting of Commission XIII of the DPR with the Minister of Law to discuss the Ministry of Law’s LKPP for the 2025 fiscal year, on Wednesday (15 July).
In her presentation, she commended the Ministry of Law’s fiscal performance amid institutional restructuring following the separation of the Ministry of Law and Human Rights.
Based on the 2025 fiscal year LKPP, the Ministry of Law’s budget ceiling was adjusted from Rp5.066 trillion to Rp4.505 trillion. The budget was subsequently reduced further through an efficiency policy involving a block of Rp1.427 trillion, leaving an effective ceiling of Rp3.078 trillion.
Of that total effective budget, spending realisation reached Rp2.784 trillion, or 90.46 percent. Meanwhile, PNBP collection exceeded its target at Rp2.192 trillion, equivalent to 107.79 percent. On the other hand, the government was still completing the restructuring of 1,167 work units, the transfer of State-Owned Assets, and organisational reorganisation as a consequence of the ministry’s separation.
Despite these positive administrative and fiscal results, Rieke considered that they cannot be the sole benchmark of the Ministry of Law’s success.
“The Ministry of Law’s success must not be measured only by high budget absorption or large PNBP figures. Far more important is whether the constitutional mandate to build a state based on law has truly been fulfilled through quality regulation, strong legal certainty, and protection of citizens’ rights,” said Rieke.
She explained that Presidential Regulation Number 155 of 2024 had given the Ministry of Law a strategic mandate, ranging from the drafting of legislation, general legal administration, and the development of national law, to formulating legal policy strategy, developing human resources in the legal field, and providing intellectual property services.
According to Rieke, all of these tasks are essential instruments for realising Indonesia as a state based on law, as mandated by Article 1 paragraph (3) of the 1945 Constitution of the Republic of Indonesia.
Therefore, she said, the deliberation of the LKPP should not focus solely on evaluating financial reports, but should also serve as a means of assessing how effectively this mandate has been carried out.
“Legal reform is not enough if it merely produces a large volume of regulations. Far more important is ensuring that every regulation is mutually harmonious, provides legal certainty, and effectively responds to the needs of society and the development of the national legal system,” she said.
As an example, Rieke highlighted the continued use of Government Regulation Number 11 of 1947 read together with Government Regulation Number 43 of 1948 as the legal basis for managing confiscated state assets.
According to her, these regulations are no longer fully consistent with the development of the national legal system following the enactment of Law Number 1 of 2004 on State Treasury, Law Number 13 of 2022 on the Formation of Legislation, and Law Number 1 of 2023 on the Criminal Code.
She judged that this situation reveals a legal gap that could give rise to disharmony in the regulation of seizure, confiscation, auction, and the return of assets derived from criminal offences to the state.
“The continued use of regulations dating from 1947 and 1948 demonstrates the need for faster legal renewal. Regulatory disharmony has the potential to hinder legal certainty in the management of confiscated state assets and the proceeds of criminal acts,” said Rieke.
According to her, if regulatory renewal continues to be delayed, law enforcement risks facing normative obstacles that could reduce the effectiveness of state asset management and efforts to recover state losses caused by criminal acts.
As a follow-up, Rieke put forward three recommendations to the government. First, to conduct a comprehensive evaluation of the implementation of the mandate of Presidential Regulation Number 155 of 2024, particularly in the areas of legislative drafting, general legal administration, development of national law, and legal policy strategy, so that these genuinely deliver legal certainty and protect citizens’ constitutional rights.
Second, to accelerate the harmonisation and renewal of various regulations that are no longer relevant to developments in national law, including rules on the management of confiscated state assets, so that normative disharmony can be eliminated and governance of assets derived from criminal offences becomes stronger.
Third, to set performance indicators for the Ministry of Law that place greater emphasis on the quality of legal services, expanded public access to justice, and the success of legal reform, rather than being based solely on the rate of budget absorption or PNBP achievement.
“A state based on law must not be trapped in purely administrative and fiscal measures. The main benchmarks must be the quality of legal services, access to justice for the public, and the effectiveness of legal reform that is genuinely felt by the people,” Rieke concluded.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/rieke-diah-pitaloka-legal-reform-success-cannot-be-measured-by-budget-absorption-alone-1784109054)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/politik-dan-hukum/911156/rieke-diah-pitaloka-hukum-bukan-soal-anggaran), translated from Indonesian