Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

RI foreign policy proves durable

| Source: The Jakarta Post

RI foreign policy proves durable

By Rizal Sukma

This is the second of two articles on Indonesia's foreign
policy which was first inducted on Sept. 2, 1948.

JAKARTA (JP): President Soeharto sees the use of foreign
policy as a function of domestic politics directed toward
achieving national interests which are largely defined in terms
of economic development.

As early as 1969, Soeharto stated: "We shall only be able to
play an effective role if we ourselves possess a great national
vitality."

While the New Order had no intention of moving Indonesia's
foreign policy beyond the framework of bebas-aktif (independent
and active), it set for itself the task of returning to the
"original" meaning of the policy.

President Soeharto also realized that before Indonesia could
pursue the independent-and-active policy, there was an inevitable
need for putting the house in order (i.e. national development).
It was this pragmatic logic that has guided and shaped
Indonesia's foreign policy ever since.

However, the New Order's foreign policy did not escape
criticism. For example, close economic relations with the West
and Japan were criticized as a violation of the true bebas-aktif
principle.

Moreover, the prolonged suspension of diplomatic ties with
China was seen as evidence that Indonesia had abandoned its
commitment to the non-aligned principle.

The New Order leadership was also criticized for being "too
low profile" and no longer active in foreign affairs. Its foreign
policy, however, has demonstrated a clear and concrete
manifestation of the bebas-aktif principle as originally defined
in terms of the policy of "no pact."

Criticism began to dissipate when, at the end of the 1980s,
Indonesia's government indicated its willingness to once again
play a more active role in international affairs. After devoting
more than two decades of its resources to economic development,
the New Order government felt that the time had come for
Indonesia to play a role commensurate with economic success at
home.

The New Order began to pursue the principle of bebas-aktif
more vigorously by restoring diplomatic ties with China in August
1990, becoming the chair of the Non-Aligned Movement for the
period of 1992-1995 and hosting the Asia-Pacific Economic
Cooperation (APEC) Summit in November 1994.

Moreover, the New Order's commitment to maintaining
Indonesia's independence was clearly displayed by its decision to
dissolve the Inter-Governmental Group on Indonesia. The
government recognized that economic aid had been used by donor
countries, especially the Netherlands, to interfere in
Indonesia's domestic affairs.

When Indonesia finalized a "security agreement" with Australia
in December 1995, however, questions arouse as to whether the act
was a sign that Indonesia had abandoned its bebas-aktif principle
altogether or whether it represented the a new interpretation of
the principle.

Even though the government did not attempt to justify the
decision to have a security agreement with Australia, in terms of
the bebas-aktif principle, it does not mean that the principle
has been abandoned.

On the contrary, it can be argued that the government
continues to hold the view that the meaning of bebas-aktif, to
which it has subscribed for the past three decades, remains as
relevant as ever.

The decision can also be seen as a display of how, in the
government's view, a truly bebas-aktif foreign policy should be
implemented in accordance with the changing international
environment.

The decision also registers the rejection by Indonesia to a
narrow interpretation of the bebas-aktif policy.

The 1950s interpretation that the policy was a commitment to
establishing a balance between the two opposing blocs is
obviously no longer relevant since their demise.

Nonetheless, the New Order government continues to subscribe
to the view of the early 1950s which urges Indonesia to stay out
of a military pact. It can also be said that the New Order tends
to invoke a broader meaning of bebas-aktif, pragmatic and
flexible enough to accommodate whatever actions suit the
interests of the state.

Indeed, bebas-aktif can also mean that Indonesia is free to
make its own decision as to how it can best meet its national
interests at any given time.

The government's position on this issue, which is no longer
constrained by domestic rivalry in making foreign policy, is also
assisted by how Indonesia's elite have come to view the place of
the bebas-aktif principle in foreign policy discourse.

The majority, if not all, of Indonesian leaders and elite
share the view that the principle of bebas-aktif constitutes one
of the principles which serves as a starting point.

And, there is a strong consensus among them about the never-
changing relevance of this principle. The New Order government,
political elite and critics do not consider a change in the
guiding principle as necessary, even though they are aware that
the international environment has undergone tremendous change
since the end of 1980s.

Indeed, so strong is the consensus, a deliberate deviation
from this principle seems unthinkable.

More importantly, security uncertainty in the region after the
Cold War requires a greater degree of "flexibility" in
Indonesia's foreign policy. And, such a flexibility can be
attained by making the principle of bebas-aktif itself more
flexible.

In this regard, the security arrangement with Australia can be
interpreted as one expression of Indonesia's attempt to loosen
the meaning of bebas-aktif. This opens up the possibility of
formalizing security cooperation with other countries.

In other words, the conceptual significance of bebas-aktif in
Indonesia's foreign policy has not changed. What has changed is
the way in which the principle is implemented.

The writer is a researcher at the Center for Strategic and
International Studies, Jakarta.

More from 3 September 1997 โ†’

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/ri-foreign-policy-proves-durable-1447893297-1511694)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post
Print