Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Reviving Umer Chapra's Legacy Through KNEKS' 'Beyond Murabahah' Movement

| | Source: Republika Translated from Indonesian | Economy
Reviving Umer Chapra's Legacy Through KNEKS' 'Beyond Murabahah' Movement
Image: Republika

The world of Islamic economics has recently lost one of its greatest intellectual pillars. Prof. Umer Chapra, the thinker who wove the epistemological foundations of modern Islamic finance, passed away on 13 June 2026.

Remembering Chapra should not merely involve romanticising his biography or listing his monumental works. The best way to honour the master is to test the relevance of his thoughts amidst today’s industrial realities.

During his lifetime, one of Chapra’s greatest concerns was seeing the Islamic finance industry frequently choosing the ‘instant route’ of commercialisation. In Indonesia, this philosophical concern has found a moment of proof through the ‘Beyond Murabahah’ (BM) movement, which is now being aggressively campaigned by the National Committee for Islamic Economy and Finance (KNEKS).

The movement, initiated since a KNEKS strategic workshop in October 2025, is essentially a practical manifestation of Chapra’s theoretical idea regarding Value-Oriented Credit Allocation.

Value-Oriented Credit Allocation is a concept where fund allocation is not solely based on short-term profit considerations and the availability of collateral. Instead, this scheme must consider moral values, social justice, and true public interest (Maqashid al-Shari’ah). Funds are directed towards productive sectors to ensure equitable welfare (Umer Chapra, Towards a Just Monetary System, 1985).

While Chapra laid his philosophical foundations in the 1980s, KNEKS today is attempting to dismantle the structural bottlenecks within the Islamic Financial Institution (LKS) industry, which has become too comfortable in the ‘safe zone’ of easy commercial contracts.

KNEKS’s in-depth study of the industry’s posture shows a unique polarisation of issues between Islamic Rural Banks (BPRS) and Islamic Commercial Banks (BUS):

At the BPRS level: The dominance of the murabahah contract (sale with margin) is absolute.

At the BUS level: The landscape appears different at first glance because the portfolio is nominally dominated by the musyarakah (profit-sharing) contract. However, we must not be deceived by this numerical illusion.

Most contracts categorised as musyarakah in the BUS sector are actually Musyarakah Mutanaqisah (MMQ). In practice, the dominant MMQ currently is a hybrid contract paired with the Ijarah (leasing) contract.

The economic impact is the polar opposite of the essence of profit-sharing. Comparing the structures: Pure MMQ involves profit-sharing in the real sector and is fluctuant (risk-sharing), whereas MMQ-Ijarah (Hybrid) generates rental income (ujrah) and provides a fixed return.

Consequently, our Islamic banking portfolio still suffers from the same ailment: it is dominated by fixed-return contracts. MMQ-Ijarah dominates the top tier, followed by Murabahah in the next.

Why ‘Beyond Murabahah’?

In terms of regulation and formal compliance, murabahah and MMQ-Ijarah are 100% valid and halal. The problem is not the jurisprudence (fiqh), but the macro distortion and socio-economic impact caused when this portion of the portfolio becomes too dominant—often exceeding 60–70% in various banks.

When the majority of financing relies on these debt-like schemes, the general public finds it difficult to distinguish the behaviour of Islamic banks from conventional banks. This continues to trigger public scepticism that Islamic finance is ‘just the same’ as conventional finance.

Through the ‘Beyond Murabahah’ movement, KNEKS is striving to overhaul this habit. The strategy is to encourage the optimisation of pure profit-sharing contracts (mudharabah/musyarakah) and revive the salam contract (advance payment for goods to be delivered later). Although both salam and murabahah fall under the category of sale contracts, they have vastly different psychological and economic impacts on the real sector.

The BM campaign does not merely encourage product diversification, but directs Islamic Financial Institutions to:

Prioritise Productive Sectors: Directing liquidity to upstream sectors and MSMEs that require real working capital.

Engage in Empowerment: LKS should no longer be passive ‘liquidity sellers’, but partners involved in capacity building, market access facilitation, and technology adoption for customers.

An Autopsy of the Problem: Three Structural Traps

Dissecting the direct line between Umer Chapra’s critique and the KNEKS movement, we can identify three structural traps currently being addressed in Indonesia:

  1. Mimicry of Conventional Credit Characteristics: Because murabahah produces low-risk receivables, its economic behaviour resembles a fixed-rate loan. As a result, Islamic banks lose their unique differentiation and merely act as debt-based liquidity providers rather than strategic growth partners for customers.

  2. Reluctance to Finance Upstream Sectors: The Islamic banking industry tends to be reluctant to enter the agricultural, basic manufacturing, or innovative-collaborative project sectors. This is because murabahah requires certainty of the object at the start and a rigid periodic payment scheme. This is where the salam contract should act as a lifesaver for the agricultural sector. Unfortunately, this contract remains a ‘sleeping giant’ in regulation and practice.

  3. Neglect of Risk-Sharing: The core essence of Islamic economics—distributive justice through the sharing of risk and profit—has stagnated. In all his works, Chapra emphasised that an Islamic financial system will only stand justly if there is a balanced transfer of risk between the capital provider and the business manager.

More from 15 June 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/reviving-umer-chapras-legacy-through-kneks-beyond-murabahah-movement-1781491882)
Originally published by Republika (https://analisis.republika.co.id/berita/tgnczt393/menghidupkan-warisan-umer-chapra-lewat-gerakan-beyond-murabahah-kneks), translated from Indonesian
Print