Revision of Election Law Deemed Necessary to Regulate Small Party Coalitions to Reduce Wasted Votes
Discussions regarding the revision of the Election Law ahead of the 2029 General Election have reignited the debate over the parliamentary threshold. Amidst these deliberations, academics argue for a new formulation capable of maintaining political system stability without sacrificing voter representation rights.
One proposal emerged from Rani Purwanti Kemalasari during her doctoral promotion session at the Faculty of Law, Trisakti University. Through her dissertation, titled ‘Reconstruction of Parliamentary Threshold Regulation in the Election Law Based on People’s Sovereignty and Justice’, Rani proposes a coalition mechanism for political parties that fail to meet the parliamentary threshold, ensuring that voter’s voices can still be converted into seats in the House of Representatives (DPR).
According to Rani, the implementation of the parliamentary threshold has historically served important purposes, such as simplifying the party system, strengthening the presidential system, and increasing the effectiveness of parliamentary work. However, on the other asid, this policy has also led to the phenomenon of ‘wasted votes’—where valid votes cannot be converted into seats because the chosen party failed to meet the threshold.
“Conceptually, the parliamentary threshold has a strategic function in supporting government stability, strengthening the presidential system, and increasing the effectiveness of parliamentary work,” said Rani.
She assessed that the issue of wasted votes has the potential to diminish the meaning of people’s sovereignty, as not all voters obtain political representation in parliament. This condition is also considered inconsistent with the principles of a proportional election system, which fundamentally aims to maintain a balance between vote acquisition and seat allocation.
Rani explained that the urgency for regulatory change has intensified following the Constitutional Court Decision Number 116/PUU-XXI/2023. In that ruling, the Court stated that the 4 per cent parliamentary threshold remains constitutional for the 2029 Election and beyond, but requested that lawmakers develop a new formulation before the next election is held.
As a point of comparison, Rani examined practices in the Philippines, Poland, and Turkey. These three countries continue to apply parliamentary thresholds to maintain political stability but provide space for small parties through electoral coalition mechanisms.
“The Philippines, Poland, and Turkey demonstrate that simplifying the party system does not have to sacrifice political representation. Coalition mechanisms can minimise wasted votes while maintaining the stability of the political system,” she said.
Based on her research findings, Rani proposes that the 4 per cent parliamentary threshold should be maintained in the revision of the Election Law. However, political parties that do not meet the threshold should be given the opportunity to form coalitions with other parties so that their accumulated votes can reach 4 per cent nationally.
In her proposal, the formation of such coalitions must be done in writing and registered with the General Elections Commission (KPU) at least seven days before polling day.
She believes this scheme could serve as a middle ground between the need to maintain government effectiveness and the protection of citizens’ political rights. Small parties would still have a chance to achieve political representation, while the goal of simplifying the party system remains intact.
“Small parties that do not reach the threshold can still combine their political strength so that voters’ voices are not simply lost and still have the opportunity to be converted into political representation,” she stated.
Rani hopes this new formulation can be considered during the revision of the Election Law. In addition to reducing the number of wasted votes, the coalition mechanism is also seen as having the potential to strengthen the constitutional resilience of election rules by providing a more inclusive solution to the ongoing debate over political representation.
She also urged the government and the House of Representatives (DPR) not to focus solely on abolishing the parliamentary threshold, but rather to refine its regulation through a clear pre-election coalition mechanism. Meanwhile, the KPU needs to prepare transparent and accountable technical regulations to ensure the scheme can be implemented effectively leading up to the 2029 General Election.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/revision-of-election-law-deemed-necessary-to-regulate-small-party-coalitions-to-reduce-wasted-votes-1781114014)
Originally published by Republika (https://news.republika.co.id/berita/tgfe3c522/revisi-uu-pemilu-dinilai-perlu-atur-koalisi-parpol-kecil-untuk-tekan-wasted-vote), translated from Indonesian