Retail Investors Uneasy as the Jakarta Composite Index Plunges
The Jakarta Composite Index (JCI) fell by nearly 30 per cent over the year to the end of September 2026. Amid market volatility, retail investors are uncertain about what to do.
Investing in shares to grow her assets ended in frustration for Sri Mas Sari, 28. After seeing her portfolio turn positive in August 2026, the Surabaya resident faced a different reality a month later, when the value of her investments fell as the stock market became turbulent again.
“I initially wanted to invest to grow my money, but it ended up being frustrating. My portfolio was in the green last August, and I was happy because the investment seemed to be paying off. Then in September it fell again. It felt as though I had lost what I had gained,” Sri said.
Her uncertainty was tested again in mid-October. On Friday, 16 October 2026, the JCI plunged 11.57 per cent to 5,185.1 at the close of the week’s trading.
The Indonesia Stock Exchange (IDX) even temporarily halted trading for 30 minutes after the index fell by more than 8 per cent at the start of the session.
The sharp decline came after global index provider Morgan Stanley Capital International (MSCI) opened a consultation on a proposal to reclassify Indonesia’s stock market from an emerging market to a standalone market. MSCI cited concerns about the transparency of share ownership structures and alleged coordinated trading practices.
For retail investors, the volatility has made investment decisions increasingly difficult. Gains visible on an investment app can shrink within weeks, while uncertainty about the market’s direction raises a difficult question: should they hold on and wait for a recovery, or sell shares before losses deepen?
Lia Octavia, 31, from South Tangerang, Banten, has had a similar experience. Rather than selling all her shares, however, Lia has chosen to review her portfolio. She is trying to remove holdings she considers more speculative while retaining large-cap, or blue-chip, stocks that she still regards as suitable for long-term investment.
Portfolio records she showed Kompas indicate that the value of her investments fell by Rp 3,983,439 between 1 and 28 September 2026. The figure illustrates how a market correction can directly affect individual investors, rather than appearing only in index figures on trading screens.
For Lia, what makes the situation more confusing is that falling prices have not been limited to shares she initially considered speculative. Some stocks regarded as having sound fundamentals have also come under pressure.
“I’m now trying to tidy up my portfolio, especially stocks that I consider too speculative. I’m still trying to hold on to blue-chip shares. But what is confusing is that some stocks appear to have good fundamentals, assets, little debt, and solid revenue and profits, yet their prices have also plunged,” Lia said.
The situation means investors need to distinguish between price falls caused by changes in a company’s fundamentals and pressure stemming from broader market sentiment. Strong financial performance does not necessarily shield a share price from selling, shifts in capital flows or growing investor concerns about economic conditions.
Volatility this year has demonstrated how sharply the domestic stock market can change direction. The JCI closed at 8,748.13 on 2 January and reached a record closing high of 9,134.70 on 20 January. The index then went through a sharp correction before coming under renewed pressure in September and plunging further in October.
At the end of September, the JCI closed at 6,071.14, down about 7 per cent over the month. Foreign investors also weighed on the market, recording net sales of around Rp 10.2 trillion. By the close of the first trading session on 16 October, the JCI had fallen by around 40 per cent from its year-opening close and about 43 per cent from its January closing record.
Amid the JCI’s uncertainty, Faisal Adityandi, a laundry business owner in Padang, West Sumatra, has taken a different approach. He says he no longer worries too much about whether the index is in the red or the green. What matters to him is that the companies he has invested in continue operating and regularly pay dividends.
“For me, it no longer matters much whether the JCI is red or green. What matters is that the companies I own shares in keep doing business and pay dividends every year. The dividends go straight into my RDN [customer funds account],” he said.
Faisal says he is used to the stock market’s ups and downs. As long as the original reasons for buying a share remain valid and the company’s business prospects still look good, he chooses not to rush into selling simply because the index is correcting.
“If the issuer’s business is still running and it is still paying dividends, why be excessively afraid? What matters to me is knowing what I have bought and not panicking easily. I choose to hold on as long as the reasons still make sense,” he said.
Faisal’s approach illustrates one way investors can cope with volatility: focus on company performance and potential long-term returns. But the strategy still carries risks. Dividends are not guaranteed every year, and even companies with a strong track record can face changing business conditions.
At market level, the latest turbulence has again highlighted the importance of governance reform and transparency. Muhammad Wafi, head of research at KISI Sekuritas, previously said that broader disclosure of share ownership and oversight of ownership concentration should be accompanied by consistent enforcement of the rules.
“MSCI itself has said that what matters is consistent implementation and sustained effect, not merely an announcement,” Wafi said.
For retail investors, the issue is not simply waiting for the JCI to rise again. They also need a transparent market, adequate information and certainty that rules will be enforced consistently. Sri has faced disappointment as her portfolio turned negative; Lia is trying to sort through her holdings amid the correction; and Faisal has chosen to hold on, relying on dividends.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/retail-investors-uneasy-as-the-jakarta-composite-index-plunges-1792255815)
Originally published by kompas.id (https://www.kompas.id/artikel/gamang-investor-ritel-di-tengah-gejolak-ihsg?open_from=Tagar_Page), translated from Indonesian