Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Restructuring power sector for the better

| Source: The Jakarta Post

Restructuring power sector for the better

By Meirios Moechtar

JAKARTA (JP) : The state-run electricity company, PT PLN,
announced losses of US$1.4 billion in the year ending Dec. 31,
1998. In its audit report, Pricewaterhouse Coopers found losses
amounting to $4.69 billion at the state-owned oil company
Pertamina during a coverage period from April 1996 to March 1998.
Something has to be done in the energy sector. The underlying
importance of the energy industry in this country is undeniable,
perhaps only surpassed by the banking sector.

Increased contributions from the oil, gas and power sectors
are highly expected in the near future as part of the overall
economic recovery. Improving the performance of the energy
industries is thus imperative through a restructuring program, in
particular the power sector due to its complexity and ambiguous
environment. Complications surrounding this issue have emerged in
the recent dispute between Paiton I, PLN and independent power
producers (IPP), led by PT Paiton Energy.

A comprehensive reform program is needed and the government
should propose related public organizations both at home and
abroad.

In the short-term, priorities should be the prompt settlement
of Independent Power Producer issues, progress of IPP
renegotiations on Power Purchase Agreements (PPAs), and arranging
indispensable investment for the restructuring. Prompt settlement
with IPPs are crucial, given the needs in Java and Bali. Without
a feasible solution with IPPs, the power sector structural reform
cannot be workable.

In the mid-term, the government should apply both soft and
hard approaches. A soft approach means that firstly the power
sector reform program should be adjusted in the transitional
process of the competitive market. Secondly, the policy of
electric rates to reflect costs should be reformed, and thirdly,
policy-making approaches including phasing-out fuel oil subsidies
should be introduced. A hard approach means that firstly
inefficient generation facilities should be enhanced; secondly,
conversion of power fuel should be promoted, and thirdly, the
generation, transmission and distribution network should be
constructed in the Java-Bali system.

Due to unavoidable conditions, PLN proposed the review of some
of the PPAs. One obvious reason was that the selling price of
IPPs' electricity became very high as a result of the rupiah's
depreciation, creating the possible worsening of PLN's financial
losses. But even without the rupiah's sharp fall, the price
levels agreed to in the PPAs, between $0.06 and $0.08 per kWH,
are still too high, especially when compared to those in other
developing countries or in Southeast Asia. The acceptable price
of electricity is lower than US$ 0.04 per kWH.

There are some critical factors and solutions for troubled
IPPs, especially those in the Java-Bali system, which should be
considered by all parties involved. At least two measures can be
implemented to ease some disagreements. Firstly, international
public lenders should reschedule to defer principal repayments
during a certain period through which the IPP project company
could ease PLN's payment obligation to a lesser level.

Secondly, the Indonesian government should be involved
directly in supporting and funding PLN through budgetary
appropriation to respond to the minimum payments of IPPs. This
should cover, at least, interest payments and operation and
maintenance expenses. This is a logical reason since the
government is committed to honor all the terms in the contracts,
such as the one for the Paiton I. In this conjunction,
international parties should support the government's financial
requirement for IPP issues through an international framework
such as the Consultative Group on Indonesia.

The next imperative mid-to-long-term step deals with the
adjustment policy in the transitional process of the competitive
power market. Prior to the targeted new market by the year 2003,
at least five years are needed to work out the framework of the
unbundling of PLN and the competition process.

A mechanism to ensure that rates reflects costs should be
established, as one way out of PLN's huge deficits. This can be
achieved by increasing the number of subscriber categories, and
adjusting the rates level periodically and automatically. The
unreasonable subsidy system should be corrected, and a reasonable
rates system to reflect costs should be established as soon as
possible. In many cases, artificial lower rates does not improve
an industry's competitiveness, but leads to inefficiency due to
the imprudent use of energy.

The social requirements for the electric power industry should
be maintained for the benefits of utilizing domestic energy,
subsidizing low income earners and funding the development of
frontier regions. These social requirements could be implemented
through the Social Electricity Development Fund, due in two to
three years. The fund could be used to subsidize eligible
customers, not PLN, and is hence some sort of targeted subsidy.

The weakened value of the rupiah against foreign currencies,
notably the U.S. dollar, has directly led to soaring costs of
electricity production. While PLN's retail rates for customers is
in rupiah, power equipment, goods and materials of electricity
production are procured with dollars. Furthermore, domestically
produced petroleum and natural gas which are supplied by
Pertamina for PLN are mostly sold in dollars.

In view of substantial changing rates, domestically produced
power equipment, goods and materials, including power fuel,
should be switched to the rupiah from the dollar. At the given
current exchange rate of the dollar, the cost of electricity
production now averages $0.06 per kWH, while formerly the
electricity rate was only $0.02 per kWH.

The writer is a researcher on energy affairs at the Agency for
the Assessment and Application of Technology and is a member of
the Tokyo-based Asia Pacific Energy Forum.

More from 5 January 2000 โ†’

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/restructuring-power-sector-for-the-better-1447893297-1296178)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post
Print