Restoring Elections to Their Mandate of Public Welfare
Electoral democracy in Indonesia is suffering from a chronic illness: technical instrumentalism. Every five years, the nation’s political energy and resources are drained by procedural matters, logistics, thresholds, disputes over figures at the Constitutional Court (MK), and candidates’ image-making tactics. Elections have been reduced to costly, noisy five-yearly administrative events that validate popular sovereignty at the ballot box. Yet this electoral process has become increasingly detached from its ultimate purpose: achieving the common good (bonum commune).
Crucial issues that determine people’s prospects and futures — including structural economic inequality, the climate crisis, agrarian reform, and the quality of education and health guarantees — are drowned out by the din of shallow electoral politics. The fundamental question we should reflect on together is this: why has our democratic system failed to connect people’s votes at polling stations with tangible improvements in their quality of life?
The proceduralist trap
The roots of this problem lie in the design of the electoral system and legal institutions, which create a misguided structure of incentives. On one hand, the Election Law and Political Parties Law have created a destructive competitive environment. A fully open-list proportional system prompts legislative candidates from the same party to cannibalise one another politically. Instead of competing with ideas and policy blueprints, candidates become caught up in money politics, personal popularity and political transactions. Political parties, meanwhile, have seen their role decay; rather than serving as crucibles for policy thinking, they have become mere ‘vehicle providers’ or agents renting out electoral platforms.
On the other hand, Constitutional Court jurisprudence has reinforced this narrow proceduralist perspective. In various rulings on challenges to the Election Law and disputes over election results (PHPU), the Court has tended to interpret the doctrine of ‘popular sovereignty’ solely in terms of procedural purity, formal legal certainty and the right to vote or stand for election. Constitutional Court judges rarely connect the constitutionality of election rules with Article 33 of the 1945 Constitution, which concerns the national economy and social welfare. Even the politicisation of social assistance and the use of state resources in the run-up to elections are often treated merely as matters of administrative budgetary authority, rather than as manipulation of people’s welfare entitlements for political gain.
The result of this proceduralist trap is a fundamental disconnect between elections and long-term development planning. Presidential and regional candidates’ visions and missions are often drawn up simply to meet the KPU’s technical and administrative registration requirements — a formality frequently prepared by campaign teams without serious technocratic analysis. Consequently, elections produce policy oscillation: each change of leadership brings the dismantling of the previous administration’s policies, while fundamental public welfare problems remain unresolved over time.
From personalities to programmes
To escape this technical-administrative grip, we cannot rely solely on moral appeals for politicians to repent. What is needed is a systemic effort to restructure legal incentives through a radical redesign of the Election Law and Political Parties Law. Elections must be shifted away from shallow personality-driven politics towards programme-based politics.
First, institutionalise political parties’ policy capacity. The Political Parties Law should require that state funding for parties from the state and regional budgets (APBN/APBD) be earmarked, with at least 40 per cent allocated specifically to operating research units, think tanks and official party public-policy development. Parties should be required to prepare long-term policy blueprints as a key condition of eligibility to contest elections, ensuring they compete on data and technocratic arguments rather than empty rhetoric and the manipulation of public emotions.
Second, reform debate formats and programme transparency. The KPU should overhaul electoral debates, which have tended to be ceremonial and rigid, dominated by exchanges of slogans lasting two or three minutes. Debates should become longer cross-examination forums focused on in-depth sectoral issues, with expert panellists required to scrutinise the budget rationale and implementation frameworks behind candidates’ promises. The KPU should also prepare and publish comparative matrices of candidates’ policy programmes, including targets, funding sources and projected effects on the public.
Third, reorganise the electoral system and institutions. Adopting a Mixed-Member Proportional (MMP) system or strengthening party-list proportional representation could curb the infighting between personalities within parties. Such a system would give voters more scope to choose a party’s collective agenda and platform, rather than merely an individual candidate’s popularity. In addition, the presidential nomination threshold, which has been shown to encourage political cartelisation and the trading of power-sharing arrangements, needs a full review so that a wider range of ideas can compete.
Fourth, require development compatibility assessments. Each candidate’s vision and mission should be assessed rationally by an independent institution, such as Bappenas or BRIN, to determine its alignment with the National Long-Term Development Plan Law (UU RPJPN). Elections must no longer be an exercise in speculation about the nation’s direction; they should serve as a means of delivering measurable and sustainable stages of public welfare.
Restoring democracy’s dignity
A democracy that delivers prosperity will never emerge from an electoral system preoccupied solely with counting ballot papers, managing ballot-box logistics and arguing over numerical differences in court disputes. Popular sovereignty must not end at the moment a ballot is placed in a box at a polling station.
It is time for civil society, academics and lawmakers to press for a comprehensive reconceptualisation of elections. We must end elections as mere festivals of procedure and restore them to their proper purpose: the highest instrument for achieving the common good and social justice for all Indonesians. Wallahu a’lam bi al-sawab.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/restoring-elections-to-their-mandate-of-public-welfare-1793591472)
Originally published by Republika (https://rejogja.republika.co.id/berita/tnut3p291/mengembalikan-pemilu-ke-mandat-kesejahteraan), translated from Indonesian