Restorative Justice Possible in Yogyakarta Madura Shop Dispute
Police have said restorative justice (RJ) may be an option in handling a case raised by the Yogyakarta Madura Family Association (KMY) during a protest at Yogyakarta City Police Headquarters. The dispute concerns the distance between grocery shops owned by Madurese residents in Yogyakarta.
“RJ is very possible if both parties reach an agreement. So far, we have held mediation twice, but there has been no breakthrough. This takes time and requires a process,” said Ipda Hendra Dinata, head of Unit 5 of the Yogyakarta City Police Criminal Investigation Unit, at police headquarters on Monday (12 October 2026.
KMY’s account of the dispute
Members of the KMY association went to Yogyakarta City Police Headquarters yesterday afternoon. They asked police to stop investigating a case they described as an internal association conflict.
“We came here simply to demand justice. There are certain members of the grocery shop management who have betrayed the organisation,” said KMY General Coordinator Aan Hidayat during the protest on Monday (12 October 2026).
“In an organisation, there should be a code of conduct. Members must follow the rules, but this person reported the Yogyakarta Madura Family Association. This is a very serious matter for us,” he added.
Aan said the case began in June 2026. A former KMY member, identified only as S, 65, reopened a grocery shop, which the association considered a breach of its rule requiring a minimum distance of 300 metres between shops owned by Madurese residents.
According to Aan, S had helped initiate the rule. Its purpose was to prevent friction between Madurese residents in Yogyakarta who both ran grocery shops.
“The principle is that he opened a grocery shop in breach of the rules or agreement reached by the shops. If it is more than 300 metres away—even by one centimetre—we would never force him to leave,” Aan said.
KMY said it had asked S for an explanation and issued a formal demand, but the parties failed to reach agreement. The association then closed S’s shop and secured his merchandise.
“Following our organisational procedures, we explained the matter and sent a letter. We asked to settle it amicably, but he still went on to report the Yogyakarta Madura Family Association. That was a betrayal,” Aan said.
S subsequently reported KMY to Yogyakarta City Police on suspicion of theft. Aan denied that the association had stolen anything.
“The report was against the association itself. Yes, it alleges there was an indication of theft. There was no theft. The goods were to be moved, and [S said], ‘It’s fine to move them, as long as the goods are kept safe’,” Aan said.
“We secured the goods, and in reality none of them went missing. They are all still there,” he added.
Yogyakarta City Police’s account
Ipda Hendra Dinata confirmed that police had received a report from S, who filed it in person on 7 July 2026.
“The reported party is KMY, and Mr S is the complainant. Mr S feels he was a victim because goods were taken without his permission, as the owner of the shop,” Hendra said at police headquarters yesterday.
Hendra said S’s losses were estimated at around Rp60 million because almost all of his merchandise had been taken by the association.
“Approximately Rp60 million, because the goods included bottled water, a mini petrol pump, cigarettes, various snacks, rice, flour and cooking oil,” Hendra said.
“The shop’s roller shutter had previously been welded shut so it could not be opened. We have seized the welding equipment, and we have also seized two pick-up vehicles parked out front,” he added.
Hendra said the case remained under investigation. Police had summoned and questioned several people as witnesses, and had also tried to mediate between the two sides.
“At the first mediation, representatives of both sides attended and explained their grievances and demands,” Hendra said.
“But at the second mediation, the complainant’s side said he was ill and could not attend. We have contacted the complainant, who has asked for time to reschedule the mediation,” he added.
On KMY’s demand that the investigation be stopped, Hendra said police were simply following the legal process. However, he said restorative justice remained possible if both parties reached an agreement.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/restorative-justice-possible-in-yogyakarta-madura-shop-dispute-1791870624)
Originally published by detikJogja (https://www.detik.com/jogja/berita/d-8704606/peluang-restorative-justice-dalam-sengketa-warung-madura-jogja), translated from Indonesian