Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Responding to Criticism Over Statistical Discrepancies and Economic Growth

| Source: detikcom Translated from Indonesian | Economy
Responding to Criticism Over Statistical Discrepancies and Economic Growth
Image: detikcom

Criticism of Indonesia’s economic growth has resurfaced after Anthony Budiawan posted a piece on social media on 7 November 2026 entitled “Over-estimation of 2026 Economic Growth”. The post questioned Statistics Indonesia (BPS) figures showing growth of 5.47 per cent in the third quarter of 2026 and 5.45 per cent in January–September 2026.

A Fajar report published on 8 November 2026, headlined “Not 5.47 Per Cent: Anthony Budiawan Simulates RI Economic Growth at Just 0.26 Per Cent”, drew further attention to the difference between official statistics and alternative growth simulations.

The central argument concerns the large statistical discrepancy between GDP measured using the production and expenditure approaches. The discrepancy was interpreted as excess production, leading to a simulated growth rate of just 0.26 per cent in the third quarter and a contraction of 0.4 per cent in January–September 2026.

Statistical discrepancies are not GDP errors

Under the System of National Accounts (SNA), GDP is calculated using three approaches: production, expenditure and income. In theory, all three produce the same value. In practice, however, differences in data sources, estimation methods, coverage and timing lead to different results. These differences are known as statistical discrepancies.

The paper “Discrepancies Between Quarterly GDP Estimates” (Bloem et al., 1997) explains that such discrepancies are commonplace in the compilation of quarterly GDP. Countries with advanced statistical systems—including the United States, the United Kingdom, Canada, Australia and New Zealand—as well as many emerging economies face similar issues.

Some countries publish these differences openly, while others reconcile them using balancing methods and supply and use tables.

A discrepancy therefore does not automatically indicate that production has gone unconsumed, much less that GDP has been manipulated. Unsold production, for example, may be recorded as a change in inventories.

Anthony Budiawan cited a discrepancy of Rp461.9 trillion, or 7.05 per cent of GDP, in the second quarter of 2026, and Rp333.2 trillion, or about 4.94 per cent of GDP, in the third quarter. For January–September, the discrepancy amounted to 5.56 per cent of GDP.

Possible causes include production being overestimated, expenditure being underestimated, or a combination of the two. Without examining the underlying data sources, there is no empirical basis for claiming that the entire discrepancy represents overestimated production.

Comparing the discrepancy with government consumption, producing a ratio of as much as 93 per cent, is also of limited relevance when assessing GDP accuracy. Government consumption is only one component of expenditure. A more appropriate measure would compare the discrepancy with total GDP, examine it against historical figures and investigate the sources of changes in the discrepancy.

The most fundamental problem lies in the method used for the alternative growth simulation. Budiawan states that the entire 2026 discrepancy represents overestimated production. He then deducts that discrepancy from 2026 GDP, while leaving 2025 GDP at the published figure, which also contains a discrepancy.

Economic growth is the change in real GDP between two periods. Therefore, if the definition or coverage of GDP in 2026 is adjusted, the same treatment must be applied to the comparison year, 2025.

By way of illustration, using the 2025 discrepancy of about 4.32 per cent of GDP cited in the analysis, applying the correction assumption consistently to both years while holding the deflator constant would result in third-quarter 2026 growth of about 4.8 per cent, not 0.26 per cent. Growth in January–September would be about 4.1 per cent, rather than a contraction of 0.4 per cent.

Furthermore, the cited discrepancy relates to GDP at current prices, whereas economic growth is calculated using constant prices.

A deduction from nominal GDP cannot be translated directly into a correction to real growth without taking account of changes in prices, volumes and the components involved.

Likewise, the assumption that a normal discrepancy should be 2 per cent of GDP has no universal methodological basis. Setting the discrepancy at zero, 2 per cent or half the published figure is a hypothetical simulation, not empirical proof of the extent of any GDP error.

Accordingly, growth of 0.26 per cent or a contraction of 0.4 per cent cannot be presented as actual economic growth on the basis of that simulation alone.

Global pressures do not automatically eliminate growth

The criticism also asks how the economy could continue growing by more than 5 per cent amid rising oil prices, rupiah depreciation and geopolitical turmoil. This is a valid question. External pressures can raise production costs, worsen inflation expectations, reduce purchasing power and weigh on investment.

However, their effects on growth are not mechanical. GDP growth reflects overall production, consumption, investment, international trade and policy responses.

Rupiah depreciation can increase import costs while also affecting the competitiveness of some exports. Higher commodity prices can put pressure on industries that use those commodities as inputs while increasing income for certain commodity-producing sectors.

Relatively strong aggregate growth certainly does not mean that every sector of the economy is performing well. Pressure on banking liquidity, businesses, investment, household consumption and employment must still be monitored.

These conditions should be assessed using supporting indicators, rather than assumed to prove that growth statistics are necessarily wrong. The credibility of statistics and the quality of Indonesia’s economic policy must continue to be strengthened.

More from 10 November 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/responding-to-criticism-over-statistical-discrepancies-and-economic-growth-1794275502)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/kolom/d-8745943/menjawab-kritik-diskrepansi-statistik-dan-pertumbuhan-ekonomi), translated from Indonesian
Print