Resetting the Course of Indonesia’s Anti-Corruption Efforts
Indonesia’s efforts to combat corruption need continual evaluation and recalibration, particularly regarding the direction of law enforcement. The issue is not simply how to prove state financial losses or whether such losses should remain an element of a corruption offence, but how to build a legal system capable of addressing the many evolving forms of corrupt conduct.
At the same time, law enforcement must provide certainty and protection for legitimate business activities. In this context, a recent statement by National Economic Council (DEN) Chairman Luhut Binsar Pandjaitan on the need to change the focus of anti-corruption enforcement is worth examining.
As reported by Detik60.com on 21 October 2026, in an article titled “Luhut Proposes Changing the Definition of Corruption: Will State Losses No Longer Be the Focus?”, Luhut said a DEN study approved by President Prabowo Subianto proposed that the handling of corruption offences should refer more closely to international standards, particularly the United Nations Convention against Corruption (UNCAC), with bribery as one of its main areas of focus.
The proposal is partly motivated by concern that an approach centred too heavily on state financial losses could burden business activities, including those of enterprises such as Danantara, whose operations inevitably involve business risks.
The statement drew a response from Corruption Eradication Commission (KPK) Chairman Setyo Budiyanto. As reported by detiknews on 21 October 2026, in an article titled “KPK Responds to Luhut’s Proposal to Exclude State Losses from Corruption”, Setyo acknowledged differences in interpretation between UNCAC and Indonesia’s Corruption Eradication Law.
He said Indonesia had particular circumstances in handling corruption, especially in relation to the methods used by offenders. Therefore, if UNCAC is to serve as a reference, the changes should ideally be made through amendments to the Corruption Eradication Law, including the addition of types of corruption offences that are not adequately covered by national law.
The two positions show that the problem of combating corruption cannot be resolved simply by retaining or changing the focus on proving state financial losses.
The more fundamental question is how criminal law understands the nature of corruption, determines which conduct should be punishable, and proportionately distinguishes criminal wrongdoing from the risks inherent in legitimate business activities.
The question, therefore, is not only whether corruption must always be linked to state financial losses, but whether such losses can remain the principal measure for understanding the full range of corruption offences. This matters because corruption also involves the abuse of power, office and trust to obtain improper benefits.
Understanding corruption more broadly
Under UNCAC, which Indonesia ratified through Law No. 7 of 2006, corruption offences are not limited to acts that cause losses to state finances.
The convention covers various forms of corruption, including bribery of national and foreign public officials; embezzlement or misappropriation of assets by public officials; trading in influence; abuse of functions or office; illicit enrichment; and bribery and embezzlement in the private sector.
This scope shows that anti-corruption law protects not only state finances or assets, but also the integrity of public office, clean government, public trust and the private sector’s interests against corrupt practices.
This is clearer still in Article 3(2) of UNCAC, which states that, for the purposes of implementing the convention, it is not necessary for the offences established under it to cause damage or harm to state property, unless the convention provides otherwise.
In other words, state financial loss is not a universal prerequisite for classifying conduct as a corruption offence. Bribery, for example, can undermine the integrity of public office and the objectivity of decision-making even when it causes no economically measurable loss to the state.
Similarly, trading in influence and abuse of authority can damage governance and public trust without first producing a financial loss to the state.
However, it should be made clear that UNCAC does not define corruption solely as bribery. Rather, it provides a more comprehensive framework for different forms of corrupt conduct. If national law is adjusted to address bribery alone, without taking other forms of corruption into account, the objective of harmonising it with international standards will not have been fully achieved.
In this context, reform of anti-corruption law should expand the range of corrupt conduct that can attract criminal liability, while taking account of the principle of legality and the characteristics of the national legal system.
Distinguishing state losses from corruption offences
If state financial loss is not the only measure for understanding corruption, it is also important to recognise that not every loss to state finances can be classified as a corruption offence. Both issues must be considered proportionately to prevent law enforcement from becoming trapped in a narrow interpretation.
Losses are an inherent part of business and cannot always be avoided. Investment decisions, business expansion, financing and project development can generate profits, but they can also result in losses. Even decisions made on the basis of rational considerations, adequate information and proper procedures do not guarantee success.
A loss arising from a business decision therefore does not, by itself, prove that a corruption offence has occurred. It is necessary to examine how the decision was made, the motives and purpose behind it, the decision-maker’s state of mind, whether there was a conflict of interest, and whether there was an abuse of authority or other conduct meeting the elements of a criminal offence.
This is where the Business Judgment Rule (BJR) is relevant. The principle protects directors who make business decisions in good faith, with due care and in the interests of the company. Such protection is necessary so that company managers are not constantly afraid of legal liability whenever a business decision results in a loss.
According to Professor Andrew Keay and Joan Loughrey, the essence of the Business Judgment Rule is to protect companies from unmeritorious claims. It rests on the assumption that management acts in the interests of the company and its stakeholders unless the contrary is proven.
The principle also recognises that company managers cannot always make optimal business decisions. Courts should therefore generally refrain from interfering with or second-guessing directors’ business decisions, provided there is no proven breach of law or action contrary to the interests of the company and its stakeholders.
However, the BJR must not be understood as granting decision-makers immunity from the law. It cannot offer protection where a business decision is merely a cover for bribery, transaction manipulation, deliberate conflicts of interest, embezzlement or abuse of authority. The protection afforded by the BJR must remain conditional on good faith, compliance with the law and the absence of abuse of authority.
In the author’s view, a clear distinction must be drawn between legitimate business risk and conduct that is improper from the outset. Criminal law should not judge a business decision solely by its outcome, but neither should it allow abuse of authority to hide behind the rationale of business risk.
Resetting the anti-corruption framework
In light of these points, the debate over Luhut’s proposal should provide an opportunity to reassess the direction of anti-corruption law reform more broadly. Reform should not be confined to the question of retaining or removing state financial loss as an element of Articles 2 and 3 of the Corruption Eradication Law, which are now also linked to Articles 603 and 604 of the National Criminal Code.
If the government intends to align anti-corruption law with UNCAC, reform should also address forms of crime that are not yet fully covered by national law, such as bribery of foreign public officials, trading in influence, bribery in the private sector and illicit enrichment.
This is increasingly important because modern corruption has moved beyond the conventional pattern of directly taking state money. It can take place through business transactions, corporate networks, conflicts of interest, the misuse of company structures and various methods of concealing proceeds of crime.
Anti-corruption law reform must therefore be capable of addressing these evolving methods, including by determining the criminal liability of those involved behind corporate structures and transactions.
At the same time, legal reform must uphold the principle of culpability and proportionality. Not every administrative error, failed investment or loss incurred by a state-owned company should be brought into the criminal sphere. Conversely, conduct cannot escape liability merely because it is presented as a business decision if it is proven to involve a criminal offence.
In other words, resetting the course of anti-corruption efforts does not mean shifting all law-enforcement attention away from state financial losses and towards bribery. It should involve a broader understanding of the forms corruption can take, an expanded reach of criminal accountability, and clearer boundaries between legitimate business risk and the abuse of power. This approach is needed to ensure that criminal law can address evolving forms of corruption while being applied carefully and proportionately.
Ultimately, combating corruption requires a more comprehensive paradigm, both in understanding the nature of the conduct and in determining the limits of criminal liability. State financial loss must not be the sole measure for understanding corruption, just as the occurrence of a loss does not in itself prove that a corruption offence has taken place.
The law must protect business decisions made in good faith, with due care and on the basis of defensible considerations. At the same time, it must not allow the abuse of power, office and trust to hide behind claims of business risk.
This is the essence of resetting the course of anti-corruption efforts: extending law enforcement to cover the many forms of corrupt conduct while ensuring that criminal liability is imposed fairly and proportionately.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/resetting-the-course-of-indonesias-anti-corruption-efforts-1793685093)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/opini/20261103114204-14-781838/menata-ulang-arah-pemberantasan-korupsi-di-indonesia), translated from Indonesian