Researchers Create Human Brain Computers, Raising Ethical Concerns Over Donor Consent
Technological developments have led many people to compare the way the human brain works with computers. Some research has even carried out testing and attempted to build computers containing cultures of lab-grown brain cells.
Research has now progressed towards brain networks that combine memory and computation within the same substrate. The potential is indeed great, but on the other hand it also raises problems.
In an article published in Nature, Nada Salem of Harvard Medical School and her team said that one aspect absent from the debate over the use of brain tissue for computing is the lack of explicit consent for the use of human neural tissue in biological computation.
For context, those who donate their tissue for biomedical research usually consent to specific studies. They may also be asked whether leftover specimens can be stored and used in future research (known as broad consent).
However, most of them usually do not know. The study published in Nature stated that consent forms most likely do not ask what types of research are permitted using their tissue.
“Consent forms do not ask donors what kind of research they would like their cells to be used for in the future, or more importantly, all the possible unwanted ways in which those cells could be used,” the study stated, as quoted on Tuesday (28/7/2026).
The team of authors further stressed the need for more explicit donor consent for research using lab-grown brain tissue. Researchers should also avoid using cell lines that have only been approved for ordinary biomedical research.
The authors also acknowledged that some researchers and ethicists may dismiss the ethical concerns raised in the article. This is because it is almost impossible to obtain permission in advance for scientific developments that cannot always be predicted.
Nevertheless, broad consent can also be harmful if used carelessly. Moreover, the use of broad consent is usually only considered ethical if it remains within the biomedical sphere.
A number of donors have already expressed concerns about the use of their samples for commercial purposes. Some even want to know the specific purpose of research when their cells are made into brain organoids. Some of them even want the right to withdraw their consent if they disagree with future research using their tissue.
Therefore, the authors reiterated that research into brain-based biological computers requires strict ethical oversight, given donors’ concerns and the possibility that research outcomes could become non-biomedical commercial products in the future, such as voice and facial recognition technology.
“An approach using unlimited consent is not a good ethical solution in this case,” the team wrote.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/researchers-create-human-brain-computers-raising-ethical-concerns-over-donor-consent-1785232383)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/tech/20260728135005-37-754423/peneliti-ciptakan-komputer-otak-manusia-hasilnya-tak-terduga), translated from Indonesian