Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Requirement for Refined Sugar Factories to Own Sugarcane Plantations Could Disrupt Investment

| | Source: ekonomi.bisnis.com Translated from Indonesian | Economy
Requirement for Refined Sugar Factories to Own Sugarcane Plantations Could Disrupt Investment
Image: ekonomi.bisnis.com

The government’s discourse regarding the requirement for the refined sugar industry to possess sugarcane plantations has the potential to trigger investment uncertainty. Anthony Budiawan, Director of Political Economy and Policy Studies (PEPS), stated that the refined sugar industry was originally established as a refinery-based industry, rather than an integrated plantation industry involving sugarcane cultivation.

According to Budiawan, if refined sugar companies are mandated to own their own plantations, it will create a need for large-scale new investments, which could disrupt business certainty. “It will certainly [disrupt investment]. These are two very different things: one is a processing industry, and then they are asked to manage plantations,” he said in a written statement on Saturday (1/8/2026).

He further noted that such a regulation could lead to legal uncertainty. Budiawan argued that the provisions in Law Number 6 of 2023, which amends Law Number 39 of 2014 concerning Plantations, should not be applied abruptly to an industry that was established with a fundamentally different business model. He believes that if the industry is forced to own plantations, many aspects must be considered, including corporate capability, investment requirements, and the sources of land to be used. “Whether the land must be purchased or otherwise—these issues create uncertainty for the business world,” he added.

He suggested that the government should first ensure that the national sugar industry remains competitive. If domestic production costs become higher than those in other countries, the cost difference will ultimately be passed on to consumers.

Meanwhile, Khudori, an observer from the Indonesian Political Economy Association (AEPI), noted that the rules regarding the integration of the sugar industry and plantations have actually been regulated since the 2014 Plantation Law, without distinguishing between consumer sugar and refined sugar. However, following the issuance of Government Regulation 26 of 2021 as a derivative of the Job Creation Law, an exception for the refined sugar industry emerged through the explanatory notes of the article.

In the hierarchy of laws and regulations, if a lower-level regulation contradicts a higher law, that provision should not apply. Nevertheless, Khudori noted that the primary issue is not just legal, but also practical implementation. He explained that most of the 11 refined sugar factories in Indonesia were built near ports as stand-alone facilities without integration with plantations. Their raw materials are sourced from imported raw sugar, meaning their factory designs differ from those based on sugarcane. If required to have their own plantations, companies would have to undertake additional investments to change their processing systems from raw sugar to sugarcane-based processing.

More from 2 August 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/requirement-for-refined-sugar-factories-to-own-sugarcane-plantations-could-disrupt-investment-1785621044)
Originally published by ekonomi.bisnis.com (https://ekonomi.bisnis.com/read/20260802/12/1992874/kewajiban-pabrik-gula-rafinasi-punya-kebun-tebu-bisa-ganggu-investasi), translated from Indonesian
Print