Regions know what to do to develop themselves
Regions know what to do to develop themselves
The following is the first of two articles on management,
written by Owen Podger, a management consultant who for the past
year has been team leader for an ADB-grant technical assistance
to support decentralization.
JAKARTA (JP): This newspaper published on March 13 an article
by Hans Vriens entitled "RI's chaotic decentralization", and I
feel impelled to paint a considerably different picture.
Decentralization is indeed long overdue, and that many aspects
of it are close to disastrous. But many of his statements just do
not match with what I have seen across the country over the past
year.
Vriens wrote that "municipalities have no clue how to govern".
Yet bureaucratic leaders in regions have generally had more
training in governing, Indonesian style, than civil servants in
most countries.
There are certainly areas in which they have no experience,
but in most new areas of responsibility most regions have
inherited people who are quite capable, to a mundane level, to
keep current processes of government running.
Concerning the areas where they have no experience, there are
considerable risks to good government. Few regional
administrations have any clue about regional economic development
management, environmental management, land-use planning, or
financial management -- as distinct from book-keeping.
Over 70 percent of representatives in the almost four hundred
local councils are new to their functions. Most of these people
are searching for how to govern, but this is very different to
saying they have no clue.
Vriens also says "nobody in Indonesia seems to know what to do
with the more than two million central government civil servants
who are based in the provinces". This is not true either. The
vast majority of these civil servants are teachers, nurses and
doctors, and they just continue to do what they were doing
before, changing the sign on the door and asking for funding from
a different source.
Regions do not know how to rationalize the bloated
administrations they have inherited. They have inherited
inefficiency, inappropriate appointments, overlapping functions,
and many officers known to be corrupt or unsympathetic who, in
the New Order, thrived in their higher status than the local
administrators.
This means that regions do not yet know how to overcome the
problems that already existed because of the centralist system.
But at least they are now aware of the problem that the
centralist system refused to see. Without doubt, there should be
many redundancies, and the first to go would be those central
government placements who have abused their central status and
abused the citizens in the regions where they work.
Officials in land management, forestry and mines are
particularly targeted by regional governments, often with very
good reason.
Vriens says "nobody in Indonesia seems to know what are the
responsibilities ... of the center, provinces and
municipalities". This is a sweeping statement, hiding the
positive aspects of how regions are coping, and the dangerous
risks of duplicity.
The process of defining "authorities" of each level of
government in legal terms has been an ongoing circus from the
moment the House of Representatives (DPR) passed the law on
regional autonomy in May 1999, that is, for almost two years.
But in fact, most of the responsibilities of regions are clear
in a managerial and operational sense, for the operations that
were previously managed by the centre in the regions just keep on
going on, under local administration.
Most of these operations are "business as usual", like running
schools and hospitals. Approval of mining investment is not
business as usual, and is therefore a matter facing greater
difficulty. Improvement of the level of services and of
efficiency is also not business as usual, and local amateur
endeavours to make improvements are causing considerable trauma.
Changes in the organization of central departments in response
to decentralization is not business as usual either, and almost
every department shows signs of serious dysfunction. These are
areas where there is very much chaos, but it is not the whole
process by any means.
It would take years for mining to be properly managed in the
regions, but where there are natural resources in the ground,
regions will want to negotiate to get them out, not just for
taxes, but more importantly for their economies.
They will start with pipe-dreams of how rich their governments
will become, but they will negotiate to a reality, and they will
go with mining executives to New York to expedite arrangements
and to enter treaties.
In five years time, mining may not have returned to level it
has been, but what is of more concern is that the mining sector,
after a brief period of decline, may become the engine of
reckless local development that destroys environment and again
enslaves the workers.
The circus of defining authorities over the past two years is
historically quite understandable. The New Order was notorious
for its various classification systems of what government did,
with sectors, programs and projects for the development budget,
activities for the routine budge, and tasks and functions for its
institutions.
The above law 22 1999 on regional autonomy attempted to
introduce a new concept for classifying government, the concept
of "authority". Authority was defined as the right to regulate
and arrange, but the classification of authority was not defined
in the law, except for mentioning a number of fields, that did
not suggest an overall system of classification.
Instead of putting effort into how government "authority"
should be classified, departments entered a drawn-out process of
looking at what parts of what they did would not be siphoned off
to the regions. To their merit, they did not make long lists of
the things they would siphon off, leaving room for regions to
consider their new authority.
Consideration of new authorities appropriately takes time, and
will sadly leave wakes of confusion. The framers of the above law
did not understand this, or allow for it.
The huge problem of preparing regulation is mind-boggling.
Last August, the People's Consultative Assembly, concerned at
delays in completing regulation for autonomy, passed a decision
that allows regions to make their own by-laws without waiting on
the center, as long as they adjust their by-laws when the centre
finally does prepare its regulations.
Few regions are likely to invest efforts to regulate without
an indication from the center as to what the future policy may
be, leaving uncertainly for all.
So now, the only way is to muddle through the legal process of
defining authorities and determining procedures, and meanwhile
keep on with the job of trying to assure that routine services,
like health and education, do not collapse.
It is interesting to see that most regions have clear ideas
(not necessarily commendable or legally defined) on most of what
they are now to do, because it is not significantly different
from what was being done before.
Again, the areas where the risks of uncertainty are the
highest are again the very same areas where the regions lack
experience, in regional development, investment, land, mining,
environment and financial management. The government must
understand the degree of danger from these risks.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/regions-know-what-to-do-to-develop-themselves-1447893297-1093417)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post