Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Regional Bonds: Between Financing Innovation and Fiscal Discipline

| Source: CNBC Indonesia Translated from Indonesian | Economy
Regional Bonds: Between Financing Innovation and Fiscal Discipline
Image: CNBC Indonesia

Note: This article is the author’s personal opinion and does not reflect the views of the CNBCIndonesia.com editorial team.

The plan by the DKI Jakarta Provincial Government to issue regional bonds worth Rp3.5 trillion with a seven-year tenor is not merely introducing a new financing instrument. If realised, the move would mark a new milestone in regional financial management in Indonesia whilst paving the way for other regional governments with adequate fiscal capacity to enter the bond market.

Regional governments do indeed have the authority to issue bonds as an alternative means of financing development. In many countries, regional bonds have become a common instrument used to fund infrastructure projects with long-term economic benefits.

For Indonesia in particular, because this is a first experience, it is natural for the plan to spark various discussions about its benefits, risks, and implications for national fiscal management.

The question that then arises is whether debt-based financing has become a necessity. In public financial management, borrowing is one financing instrument when there is a mismatch between revenue and expenditure needs.

Government spending cannot simply be cut, especially when economic growth targets and development goals have been set. On the other hand, some strategic infrastructure projects have characteristics that do not allow them to be postponed or built gradually through multiyear schemes.

For Jakarta specifically, completing projects in stages risks prolonging traffic congestion, increasing economic costs, and worsening public stress caused by construction projects that drag on for too long. This is what gives the idea of creative financing its relevance.

Bond issuance allows the government to obtain large funds upfront so that projects can be completed faster and their economic benefits immediately felt by the public.

However, bond issuance is not an end in itself, but rather one financing instrument among others. Debt should only be used to fund projects capable of generating economic and social benefits that exceed the costs incurred.

Financing through bonds is certainly not without risk. In How to Manage Fiscal Risks from Subnational Governments, the IMF stresses that one important principle in maintaining fiscal discipline is that regional government debt must not be guaranteed by the central government. This principle stems from various international experiences in which regional governments faced financial difficulties due to excessive debt accumulation.

Interestingly, the IMF also acknowledges that, economically, central governments almost always provide an implicit guarantee for regional government borrowing. Legally there is no obligation to rescue a regional government, but in practice the central government often still intervenes to safeguard public services, economic stability, and financial system stability.

Such intervention can take the form of taking over regional government debt, restructuring loans, increasing transfers to the regions, or providing emergency loans. Put simply, the issuance of regional bonds not only creates obligations for the regional government but also has the potential to become a contingent fiscal risk for the central government.

Another noteworthy IMF observation is that central governments in many countries often focus more on controlling the amount of debt raised by regional governments rather than examining the quality of spending financed by that debt.

Yet the root of fiscal problems often lies not in the size of the loan but in the effectiveness of how the funds are used. Debt used to build productive infrastructure clearly has different characteristics from debt that merely funds routine spending.

Therefore, fiscal oversight should not stop at setting a maximum borrowing limit (debt ceiling), but should also ensure that every rupiah of debt enhances the region’s economic and fiscal capacity in the future.

The debate over regional bonds should not stop at whether regional governments may borrow, but rather how to ensure that such debt remains productive without increasing fiscal risks for the central government.

Beyond these ongoing discussions, the presence of regional bonds will also affect the dynamics of the national debt securities market. Regional bonds will most likely offer yields slightly higher than State Securities (SBN) as compensation for their relatively greater credit risk. That yield spread has the potential to attract some investors who have until now invested in central government bonds.

Admittedly, in the initial phase the value of regional bond issuance remains relatively small compared to the financing needs of the State Budget (APBN). However, if more regional governments follow DKI Jakarta’s lead, the domestic bond market will have a new investment instrument with low risk characteristics but more attractive coupon rates. This is one aspect the central government needs to take into account when formulating its APBN financing strategy.

On the other hand, the existence of a regional bond market can also serve as a catalyst for deepening the domestic financial market. Investors will have more investment choices, whilst regional governments gain access to more diverse financing. The challenge is ensuring that fiscal discipline is maintained so that competition for funds in the market does not drive excessive increases in regional debt.

Optimising development financing does not always have to be done through additional borrowing. Regional governments’ fiscal space can also be expanded by strengthening Locally Generated Revenue (PAD) and improving the quality of revenue management.

One alternative worth considering is giving motor vehicle taxpayers the option to pay their tax in advance for several years. Providing tax discounts or certain incentives could encourage the public to take up such a scheme.

For regional governments, upfront payments will improve cash flow so that financing needs through debt can be reduced. From a financial governance perspective, this scheme is also feasible because the government accounting system already uses an accrual basis, meaning revenue paid in advance can be recorded in accordance with prevailing regulations.

However, the additional revenue must not be viewed as new fiscal space for increased spending. Regional governments must manage it carefully so they do not face fiscal pressure in subsequent years when part of the tax revenue has already been received in advance.

In addition, regional governments also need to evaluate policies that could erode their revenue base. One of these is the provision of incentives in the form of Motor Vehicle Tax exemptions for electric vehicles.

This policy does have a worthy aim, namely accelerating the transition towards cleaner energy and reducing dependence on fossil fuels. From a regional fiscal perspective, however, sustained tax exemptions also erode one of the main sources of PAD. For regions with a steadily growing population of electric vehicles, such as DKI Jakarta, this clearly poses a threat.

Such incentives need not be abolished entirely. The government could consider a more proportionate design, for instance granting tax exemption only at the point of purchasing a new vehicle or for a certain period, then gradually reinstating the annual tax. With this approach, the goal of encouraging electric vehicle adoption is still achieved without permanently eliminating potential regional revenue.

The stronger a region’s fiscal capacity, the smaller its dependence on debt-based financing should be. Bond issuance should be a strategic choice to accelerate development, not a consequence of a weakening regional revenue base.

The issuance of regional bonds is a step forward in diversifying development financing. This instrument can accelerate the provision of infrastructure whilst reducing dependence on central government transfers. Its success, however, is determined not merely by the regional government’s ability to issue debt securities, but by the quality of its fiscal governance.

The benchmark for the success of regional bonds is not how much money is raised, but how much economic benefit is generated for the public. Infrastructure that improves mobility, lowers logistics costs, boosts productivity, and expands economic activity will strengthen a region’s fiscal capacity. That way, the debt raised can pay for itself through the economic growth it creates.

Conversely, if bonds merely become an instrument to cover deficits caused by poor spending quality and a narrow regional revenue base, then the debt will simply shift the fiscal burden onto the future. In such circumstances, the central government ultimately still risks bearing the consequences through various forms of implicit guarantee, as the IMF has long warned.

Financing innovation and fiscal discipline are not two mutually exclusive options, but rather two prerequisites that must go hand in hand for regional bonds to truly become a sustainable instrument of development.

More from 3 August 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/regional-bonds-between-financing-innovation-and-fiscal-discipline-1785743491)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/opini/20260803135208-14-756087/obligasi-daerah-antara-inovasi-pembiayaan-dan-disiplin-fiskal), translated from Indonesian
Print