Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Regional autonomy not as easy as it sounds

| Source: The Jakarta Post

Regional autonomy not as easy as it sounds

Ridwan Max Sijabat, The Jakarta Post, Jakarta

Despite some progress, four years of regional autonomy has
triggered a war among local elites fighting for new political
positions, a critical situation that must be overcome to develop
democracy and accelerate the development of rural areas.

The beacon of democracy has begun shining as, unlike the past,
the people have indirectly elected their leaders through
elections from national to municipal level. However, in many if
not most cases, particularly from the election of governors down,
elections involve money politics and intimidation.

Almost all gubernatorial and regental elections held this year
sparked opposition and criticism from numerous parties, including
non-governmental organizations, regarding money politics and the
mobilization of large crowds of hired demonstrators.

The inauguration of the Lampung governor elect was suspended
because of alleged corruption and several regents and mayors were
dismissed for abusing their powers.

The director general of Public Administration and Regional
Autonomy at the home affairs ministry, Oentarto Sindung Muwardi,
said that like nine-month-old babies who are learning to walk,
most regions have yet to fully understand regional autonomy and
have made many mistakes in its implementation.

"Regions and mayoralties have already received authority
decentralized from the central government through Law No. 22/1999
on regional autonomy and Law No. 25/1999 on fiscal balance in
dealing with their own home affairs in certain fields but most
have implemented it as a means to seek power and political jobs,"
he said.

However, he conceded that the implementation of autonomy in
Papua had raised problems due to conflicting interests between
the government and the country's easternmost province while it
had slowed down in Aceh because of the extended military
operation to crush the Free Aceh Movement (GAM).

"The nuance of reform euphoria, the replacement of old
officials appointed by former president Soeharto's militaristic-
style New Order regime and the political war among the emerging
local elites under the multi-party system, has also contributed
to the slow implementation of autonomy," he said.

He underlined that the frequently contentious power succession
was an inevitable phase in the long transition to develop a true
democracy.

"The mass mobilization and the use of money politics will
gradually stop since new local leaders will be elected by the
people under the planned direct election and their legitimacy
will be determined by their performance in running a clean and
good government," he said.

Unlike gubernatorial and regency elections in the past,
governors, regents and mayors under regional autonomy are elected
by provincial and regency legislative councils while the
president has the authority to approve the election results.

Asked to comment on Megawati's preference to extend the
tenures of many of the existing governors, Oentarto said the
President was exercising her statesmanship for the country's
political stability ahead of the general election. Many political
analysts have criticized Megawati's policy, saying it could kill
democracy.

Megawati turned down the nomination of gubernatorial
candidates proposed by the Indonesian Democratic Party of
Struggle she chairs and, instead, supported the extension of
governor Sutiyoso's tenure in Jakarta, governor Soewardi's in
East Kalimantan and Mardiyanto's in Central Java.

The party's elite figures were alleged to have used the
governors' reelection as sources to raise funds.

The corrupt bureaucracy inherited from the former New Order
regime and emergence of new regional leaders who mostly did not
understand comprehensively regional autonomy have been also a
serious obstacle to the development of a good and clean
government and to providing a better service to the public, as
final objectives of regional autonomy.

"Corruption is now worse than before because, despite the
reform agenda and regional autonomy, the bureaucracy has remained
unchanged while many new local leaders from numerous new
political parties have abused their power to enrich themselves as
well as to raise funds for their parties for the upcoming general
election," Oentarto said.

"The common people have yet to see changes in their social and
economic livelihood because the implementation of regional
autonomy has gained more emphasis on power succession and
political wars among local elites."

He also said the home affairs ministry was still reviewing
thousands of controversial rulings issued by regions in
implementing autonomy.

According to him, political figures occupying official jobs in
the executive and legislative bodies should put out their
political "uniforms" and attributes "and this can be effective
only if national leaders gave good examples."

"President Megawati Soekarnoputri and Vice President Hamzah
Haz should leave political positions in their own party to allow
them to focus on their state tasks as well as to give good
examples to regional heads," he said, adding he was not afraid of
being dismissed from his current position for this statement.

He said many new regencies and mayoralties had been formed not
to cover the wide gap in the provision of government services to
the public but predominantly to create new political positions in
the local legislative and executive bodies.

Tanjungbalai Karimun regent Huzrin Hood has been jailed for
embezzling the regency's development program funds, which were
allegedly used to finance the formation of Riau Islands province
from the Riau mainland.

Many regions have issued contentious and duplicating rulings
to obtain income as high as possible due to the
misinterpretations of authority decentralization.

The regional autonomy is in the hands of regencies and
mayoralties but they are completely autonomous because certain
fields and national policies of the decentralized fields are
still in the hands of the central government.

To be consistent with the Indonesian unitary state as stipu
lated by the law, security and defense, foreign and religious
affairs, monetary and the courts are not decentralized while the
central government still has the authority to make national
policies in the fields of forestry, mining and energy, manpower,
agriculture, trade and industry, environment, social affairs,
public works and many other areas.

Under such a hierarchy, a minister has the authority to take
action against local officials and officers violating the
national policies.

"For example, regents could not give forest concessions to
timber businesspeople in national parks and are obliged to comply
with the national policy on environmental conservation," he said,
referring to the recent devastating Bahorok (North Sumatra) flash
flood caused by rampant illegal logging in Gunung Leuser National
Park in Aceh and North Sumatra.

The political war among the local political elite has shielded
new regional heads to implement regional autonomy at the
grassroots level in villages.

Oentarto said that most villages were yet to implement
regional autonomy partly because most regents did not understand
yet its final objectives and partly because many informal leaders
in villages declined to be appointed as village heads.

"According to the law and a government regulation, regents and
mayors are obliged to issue regulations to return villages'
autonomy, which was taken over by the foreign affairs ministry
under Law No. 5/1974 and public administration," he said.

Villages and village heads have an important role implementing
regional autonomy. Villages have the authority to regulate their
own socio-cultural life, determine their own borders, elect their
own heads directly and obtain funds from regencies to carry out
their own programs.

Village heads serve ten-year terms of office and are allowed
to contest another decade-long period.

"Many informal and religious leaders in urban areas have
declined to be elected to lead their villages where they are
living because they do not understand regional autonomy and its
implications," Oentarto said.

Besides proposing a direct election of regional heads and
tight requirements for the development of new provinces,
regencies and mayoralties, the central government should place
more emphasis on the implementation of autonomy in rural areas or
villages in the ongoing review of the regional autonomy law, he
said.

More from 30 December 2003 โ†’

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/regional-autonomy-not-as-easy-as-it-sounds-1447893297-1331445)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post
Print