Regarding Gibran's High School Diploma, Expert Says Constitutional Court Has Passed the Hot Potato
The Constitutional Court (MK) has rejected the General Election Result Dispute (PHPU) lawsuit concerning the educational requirements of Vice President Gibran Rakabuming Raka during his 2024 Presidential Election registration. The Court is seen as passing a ‘hot potato’ to several related parties through this decision.
According to Bivitri Susanti, an expert representing the petitioners, the Court’s ruling regarding Gibran’s educational requirements does not necessarily mean the petitioners have lost the case. Bivitri believes the responsibility has now been shifted to several institutions, including the House of Representatives (DPR).
“The MK concluded that Gibran’s high school diploma indeed does not exist. However, the MK did not proceed to weigh the matters requested by the petitioners because the petitioners were deemed to have no basis to file this case (legal standing). In legal terms, it is inadmissible or NO (niet ontvankelijke verklaard),” Bivitri stated on her Threads account on Wednesday (7/10/2026).
Bivitri noted that the Constitutional Court judges declared the lawsuit inadmissible due to the lack of legal standing. Consequently, the MK is viewed as passing the ‘hot potato’ or responsibility to various institutions, such as those involved in impeachment processes.
“Lost? Not exactly. In my view, this appears to be the furthest political move the MK could make. They assessed the substance but blocked it themselves via legal standing,” said the constitutional law expert.
“The MK is passing the hot potato to the political parties in the DPR to initiate impeachment,” she added.
Furthermore, Bivitri assessed that the MK is passing the responsibility to law enforcement to immediately investigate allegations of manipulation related to the matter. She also stated that the MK is passing the responsibility to the DPR to hold the current members of the General Elections Commission (KPU) accountable.
“Law enforcement must investigate the manipulation discovered by the MK. The DPR should hold the current KPU accountable so they are no longer elected, or even dismissed,” Bivitri remarked.
“And it is passing a ‘half-hot’ potato to political parties so they do not nominate Gibran in 2029. And passing a ‘cold’ potato to Gibran to resign out of shame. Isn’t that cold?” she continued.
Previously, the Constitutional Court did not accept the PHPU lawsuit regarding Gibran’s educational requirements during the 2024 Presidential Election registration. The Court stated that the petitioners lacked the legal standing to file the lawsuit.
“In the exception, granting the petitioner’s exception regarding legal standing. Rejecting the respondent’s and related parties’ exceptions for the rest. Regarding the merits of the case, declaring the petitioners’ application inadmissible,” stated the Constitutional Court Judge.
The Court noted that the lawsuit was filed by parties who were not participants in the 2024 Presidential Election. In its ruling, the Court found no evidence showing that Gibran possessed a high school-equivalent diploma when registering as a vice-presidential candidate for the 2024 election. Nevertheless, the Court stated it could not disqualify Gibran.
“The Court cannot cancel or disqualify Gibran Rakabuming Raka from his position as Vice President as requested in the petitioners’ petitum,” said Constitutional Court Judge Adies Kadir during the ruling session at the MK building, Central Jakarta, on Tuesday (6/10).
The judge stated that the MK is not authorised to assess the fulfillment of presidential and vice-presidential requirements, despite the facts regarding the absence of Gibran’s diploma during his studies abroad. The judge emphasised that other institutions hold the authority regarding such matters.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/regarding-gibrans-high-school-diploma-expert-says-constitutional-court-has-passed-the-hot-potato-1791348692)
Originally published by detikBali (https://www.detik.com/bali/berita/d-8696002/soal-ijazah-sma-gibran-ahli-sebut-mk-lempar-bola-panas), translated from Indonesian