Regarding Gibran's Diploma, Constitutional Court Judge Arsul Sani Shares Experience Studying at UTS
Constitutional Court (MK) Judge Arsul Sani shared that he once underwent an English language course at the Insearch Language Centre, which has since been renamed the University of Technology Sydney (UTS) College.
This was stated by Arsul during the hearing for the dispute over the general election results (PHPU), which challenges the high school education requirements of Gibran Rakabuming Raka as a vice-presidential candidate in the 2024 Presidential Election. Arsul initially questioned the process by which the General Elections Commission (KPU), as the respondent in the MK trial, verified Gibran’s educational documents.
Arsul interrogated the KPU regarding the extent to which they investigated the validity of Gibrante’s diplomas obtained during his studies in Singapore and Australia. This moment arose when Arsul referred to evidence P20, specifically KPU Minutes Number 1859/2023. In that document, the KPU stated that all requirements for the candidate pair of Prabowo Subianto and Gibran Rakabuming Raka had been verified and declared eligible.
Arsul subsequently requested the KPU to explain in detail the verification stages behind that conclusion. “Please explain further what you verified. What documents did you verify? Was it only the equivalence certificate issued by the Ministry of Education… or did you also verify the entirety of the documents, whatever they may be, whether it be diplomas, certificate awards, or diplomas from schools in Singapore?” Arsul pressed.
The judge, who has a political background, emphasised the importance of transparency regarding Gibran’s secondary education documents in Singapore. He questioned whether those graduation documents are equivalent to the General Certificate of Education (GCE) at the O-Level or N-Level.
Attention continued to focus on Gibran’s educational history at the Insearch Language Centre—now known as UTS College—in Australia. Arsul then shared his personal track record, noting that he had also studied at the institution. “I happened to take a three-week English course there. I understand what Insearch UTS is, because I am also an alumnus of UTS,” Arsul revealed.
Drawing on his experience, Arsul urged the KPU to clarify the status of the university pathway programme undertaken by Gibran. He requested clarity on whether the programme held the status of matriculation, foundation, or a similar programme.
KPU Response
Responding to the series of questions from the Constitutional Court Panel, the KPU asserted that Gibran’s candidacy was not legally flawed and complied with existing regulations. The KPU referred to KPU Regulation (PKPU) Number 19 of 2023, Article 18, regarding graduation requirements for candidates who studied abroad.
The KPU stated that, based on Article 18, paragraph 3 of PKPU 19/2023, candidate pairs who are high school graduates from foreign schools abroad may use higher education graduation documents.
“The required documents have been verified for accuracy and have been legally declared eligible,” explained a representative for the KPU’s legal counsel during the trial.
According to the KPU, Gibrandum also possesses a valid equivalence certificate for high school level that has undergone verification. Therefore, the KPU is confident that the examination process conducted met the standards for completeness and validity of documents as mandated by law.
This hearing is part of the agenda to examine the 2024 Presidential Election PHPU petition filed by former Deputy Minister of Law and Human Rights, Denny Indrayana, along with 11 other petitioners. The case was officially registered by the MK on 17 September 2024.
In their petition, Denny Indrayana and the petitioners requested the MK to disqualify Gibran Rakabuming Raka, alleging legal flaws in his appointment as Vice President. They challenged the validity of Gibran’s educational documents, including the certificate of equivalence from Insearch UTS Australia, and alleged a structured, systematic, and planned (TST) process in facilitating Gibran’s eligibility.
The petitioners also demanded that the MK annul KPU Decision Number 504 of 2024 regarding the Determination of the Elected Presidential and Vice-Presidential Candidate Pairs, and requested that the MPR convene a session to elect a new Vice President within 60 days after the verdict is read.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/regarding-gibrans-diploma-constitutional-court-judge-arsul-sani-shares-experience-studying-at-uts-1790225953)
Originally published by CNN Indonesia (https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20260924094138-12-1407584/soal-ijazah-gibran-hakim-mk-arsul-sani-cerita-pernah-kursus-di-uts), translated from Indonesian