Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Reflections on Sharia Economic Law in the Whirlwind of Artificial Intelligence

| | Source: Republika Translated from Indonesian | Economy
Reflections on Sharia Economic Law in the Whirlwind of Artificial Intelligence
Image: Republika

Imagine applying for financing at an Islamic bank. Within seconds, an Artificial Intelligence (AI)-based system determines whether your application is accepted or rejected. It is fast, practical, and efficient. However, a crucial question arises: can an algorithm truly understand the value of justice that is the spirit of sharia economic law? This question is increasingly relevant amid the rapid digital transformation in the financial sector. AI is now present in almost every line, from financing risk analysis, fraud detection, and customer service via chatbots, to sharia compliance supervision. Technology indeed offers extraordinary efficiency, but behind its sophistication lie significant challenges that cannot be ignored. In sharia economic law, the success of a system is not only measured by speed and profit, but also by the extent to which the system is able to deliver justice, transparency, and benefit for all parties.

AI Opens Great Opportunities for the Islamic Economy

It is undeniable that AI brings many benefits to the development of the Islamic economy. In various countries, including Indonesia, a number of financial institutions have begun utilising AI to accelerate financing analysis, enhance the security of digital transactions, and help detect transactions that potentially violate sharia principles. This technology also has the potential to strengthen supervision against practices of riba, gharar (uncertainty), and maysir (speculation). In fact, the concept of Halal-as-a-Service is developing through the integration of AI, blockchain, and smart contracts, enabling the certification process and the halal product supply chain to become more transparent and easily monitored. For Micro, Small, and Medium Enterprises (MSMEs), AI can also help accelerate access to sharia financing through more accurate data analysis compared to conventional methods. Thus, technology not only increases efficiency but also has the potential to expand sharia financial inclusion.

AI Is Never Truly Neutral

Behind these various benefits, one thing is often forgotten: AI is never truly neutral. AI works based on the data it learns from. If the data used contains bias, then the resulting decisions are potentially biased. This means technology does not automatically produce justice. For example, an algorithm may give a different financing assessment to certain community groups simply because of past data patterns. Yet in fiqh muamalah, the principles of ’adl (justice) and bayān (clarity) are the main foundations of every economic transaction. Another problem is that many AI systems work like a black box. The user knows the final result but does not understand how the decision was reached. Such a condition has the potential to create a new form of gharar because the decision-making process becomes non-transparent.

Justice Cannot Be Entirely Handed Over to Machines

The next challenge is the risk of losing the human touch (dehumanisation). In Islam, justice is not only born from mathematical calculations but also from moral considerations, empathy, and responsibility. An algorithm may be able to calculate thousands of variables in seconds, but it has no conscience, intention (niyyah), nor the ability to understand a person’s social conditions. Therefore, AI must not replace the role of humans in making important decisions, especially those relating to a person’s rights and obligations. Technology should be a tool, not the primary decision-maker. The concept of ‘human in the loop’ becomes very important. In this model, AI provides recommendations, while the final decision remains in the hands of a human who bears moral and legal responsibility.

Who Is Responsible If AI Makes a Mistake?

Another issue that needs attention is legal responsibility. From the perspective of Islamic law, the legal subject (mukallaf) is a human, not a machine. Therefore, when AI produces a decision that harms a customer or contradicts sharia principles, the responsibility cannot be transferred to the algorithm. A fatwa from the Indonesian Ulema Council also affirms that AI is merely a wasilah (tool), while responsibility remains with the humans who design, operate, supervise, and use the technology. For this reason, Islamic financial institutions need to have a regular algorithm audit mechanism so that every AI system continues to operate according to sharia principles and does not cause discrimination.

Time for Regulation to Keep Pace with Technology

The development of AI is far faster than the regulations governing it. This condition is a major challenge for Indonesia, which is pushing for digital transformation in the financial sector. It is time for regulators such as the Financial Services Authority (OJK), Bank Indonesia, and the National Sharia Board of the Indonesian Ulema Council (DSN-MUI) to formulate guidelines for the use of AI in the Islamic finance industry. These audits are no longer sufficient if conducted only on contracts and products; they must also touch on the algorithmic logic used in the decision-making process. On the other hand, universities also have an important role in preparing human resources who master two fields at once, namely fiqh muamalah and digital technology. Collaboration between scholars, regulators, academics, and technology experts is key to ensuring that AI development remains within the sharia corridor.

Closing

AI development is an inevitability that cannot be stopped. Rejecting technology is not the solution. However, accepting technology without supervision is also not a wise choice. In the perspective of sharia economic law, technology must always be a means to realise public benefit, not merely to pursue efficiency. Therefore, AI must be positioned as a tool that helps humans, not replaces them.

More from 29 June 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/reflections-on-sharia-economic-law-in-the-whirlwind-of-artificial-intelligence-1782697866)
Originally published by Republika (https://retizen.republika.co.id/posts/767370/refleksi-hukum-ekonomi-syariah-dalam-pusaran-kecerdasan-buatan), translated from Indonesian
Print