Recalibrating the Ministry of Human Rights: Between Expectations and Reality
The ceiling of the room appears still damaged. In the corners of the room, several construction tools are still stored. The sounds of renovation can be heard here and there. Some employees in neat uniforms are managing administrative files, while others are preparing dissemination agendas.
This room, currently undergoing tidying up, holds a story of a new beginning. According to local employees, the East Java Regional Office of the Ministry of Human Rights recently received a ‘helping hand’.
After coordinating with the East Java Provincial Government, the regional office was lent a previously unused building, namely the official residence of the Vice Governor. The building was subsequently renovated to be suitable as a workspace.
This official residence, transformed into an office, serves as a symbol of a transition phase. It represents one of the twenty Regional Offices of the Ministry of Human Rights formed after the ministry was established in late 2024.
With approximately 1,300 employees spread from the central to the regional levels, the Ministry of Human Rights appears ‘small’ when compared to other bureaucratic giants. The number of human resources at that level is also far from ideal for carrying out a human rights mandate that is cross-sectoral and touches all aspects of governance.
However, amidst these limitations, the Ministry of Human Rights is attempting to build its institutional foundation and strengthen regulations for the development of human rights civilisation in Indonesia.
Public expectations for this ministry are indeed very high. On the other hand, building a new, effective institution certainly requires time, resources, and a non-simple process of institutional strengthening.
This is where the dual challenge lies; this new ministry is required to be agile externally, while ensuring its domestic affairs are well-managed.
Interpreting the Existence of the Ministry of Human Rights
The domestic matters currently being organised are actually a miniature of a much larger concept. This is because, in the human rights regime, the state is always positioned as the primary actor bearing human rights obligations (duty bearer).
The question then arises: who exactly is meant by ‘the state’ in the context of fulfilling these obligations?
International law does not view the state as an abstract, floating concept, but rather as a legal entity represented by the government.
Therefore, when discussing the state’s obligations in the field of human rights, we are actually highlighting how government institutions work as the tangible representation of the state apparatus.
In Indonesia’s constitutional system, the Constitution stipulates that the President holds the power of government. Naturally, the President does not work alone in running the wheels of government but is assisted by state ministers who manage specific affairs.
It is in this context that the formation of the Ministry of Em Human Rights gains strong theoretical and constitutional justification. Through Presidential Regulation Number 156 of 2024, this new ministry is tasked with managing government affairs in the field of human rights.
This step is also in line with the mandate of Article 28I paragraph (4) of the 1945 Constitution of the Republic of Indonesia, which emphasises that the protection, promotion, enforcement, and fulfilment of human rights are the responsibility of the state, particularly the government.
It should be underlined that the phrase ‘particularly the government’ indicates that the government bears the primary responsibility. Consequently, many people ask: what is the actual difference between the Ministry of Human Rights and Komnas HAM?
This is where the beauty of our constitutional system lies. Although both operate in the field of human rights, these two agencies have different characters, functions, and bases of legitimacy.
The Ministry of Human Rights exists within the executive branch (government human rights focal point) to run the wheels of government, whereas Komnas HAM stands tall outside that structure as an independent state auxiliary body.
This is not a matter of which institution is more important, but rather about the relationship between complementary institutions.
The Work of the Ministry of Human Rights
Recently, many journalists have been asking for the Minister of Human Rights’ response to various alleged human rights violations that have drawn public attention.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/recalibrating-the-ministry-of-human-rights-between-expectations-and-reality-1782748417)
Originally published by Republika (https://analisis.republika.co.id/berita/thd85i377/menakar-ulang-kementerian-ham-antara-harapan-dan-kenyataan), translated from Indonesian