Reasons Why KPU Accepted Gibran's Equivalence Certificate: The Presumption of Validity
The General Elections Commission (KPU) has stated that the equivalence statement letter served as a valid administrative document for Gibran Rakabuming Raka’s candidacy for Vice President in the 2024 Election. The documents in question include Equivalence Statement Letter Number 9149/D.D1/KS/2019, dated 6 August 2019, and the Decision of the Director General of Learning and Student Affairs Number 2296/Belmawa/Kep/IJLN/2019, dated 8 August 2019.
“During the examination, the KPU treated the letter as a valid document based on the principle of presumption of validity (presumptio iustae causa), which holds that an administrative decision is considered valid unless overturned by the authorised party,” said the Chairman of the KPU RI, Mochammad Afiffudin, in an official statement on Wednesday (7/10).
The KPU explained three reasons why the document examination was declared valid. First, it was issued by an authorised institution. “The KPU’s basis for examination at that time considered two circumstances. First, the equivalence letter was issued by the ministry that holds the authority to equate overseas education,” said Afiffundin.
Second, the equivalence statement letter was the same document used in the requirements for Gibran’s candidacy in the 2020 Surakarta mayoral election. The document was not invalidated when Gibran proceeded with his candidacy for the 2024 Election. “The same document was used and accepted during the verification of candidacy requirements for the 2020 Surakarta Mayoral Election, and had not been revoked or cancelled when the 2024 Presidential Election document verification was conducted,” he continued.
Third, no institution or agency had proposed the cancellation of the statement letter. “The three documents are valid and in effect because no institution and/or agency has cancelled them,” said Afiffudin.
When verifying Gibran’s documents, the KPU referred to Article 42, paragraph (2) of KPU Regulation (PKPU) Number 19 of 2023. This article stipulates that if there is doubt regarding a document, the KPU may conduct verification with the nominating political party and/or the authorised institution. However, in 2023, the KPU found no situation that gave rise to such doubt.
“During the 2023 examination, the KPU found no circumstances that raised doubt regarding the equivalence letter, based on considerations regarding the issuing institution, validity, and the history of the document’s use,” he said. The KPU also did not receive any public complaints questioning the document, either directly or through the Election Supervisory Body (Bawaslu).
Consequently, the KPU assessed that there were no conditions requiring clarification as intended under Article 42, paragraph (2). The decision was an application of clarification provisions based on the results of the examination and the information available at that time. Afiffudin explained that the KPU maintained the principle of due diligence by considering the authority of the issuing institution.
“The KPU considered the authority of the issuing institution, the validity, and the history of the document’s use as the basis for the administrative examination,” he said. The KPU concluded that based on the documents received and the results of the verification at that time, Gibran’s educational requirements were deemed met.
In the verification process of all educational requirement documents, the KPU took into account the Constitutional Court’s considerations, using the principle of ‘presumptio iustae causa’ as a basis. “The KPU used the principle of presumptio iustae causa, which serves as the basis for the truth of a legal product remaining valid as long as it is not declared otherwise by a court,” said Afiffudin.
However, in its application, the Court noted that this must be strengthened with the principles of precision and prudence as a multi-layered effort to maintain the validity, accuracy, and truth of every submitted piece of data, such as the educational evidence underlying the equivalence letter.
In response, the KPU respects all considerations aimed at improving future election administration. Previously, the Constitutional Court stated it found no documents showing that Vice President Gibran possesses a certificate or diploma as evidence of completing overseas education equivalent to high school level. This statement was made by Constitutional Court Judge Arsul Sani during the reading of the judicial considerations on Tuesday (6/10) night regarding the case of Gibran’s diploma requirements for the 2024 Presidential Election.
“The Court has studied all evidence submitted by the parties and the facts in court; the Court found no documents showing Gibran Rakabuming Raka possesses a certificate or diploma as evidence of completing overseas education equivalent to high school or its equivalent, as intended by Article 169 letter r and Article 227 Letter I of the Election Law,” said Judge Arsul in the Constitutional Courtroom, Jakarta.
Furthermore, the Court stated that other documents, such as the ‘certificate of attendance’ held by Gibran, do not constitute proof of graduation but rather proof of attendance in the learning process. While the Court’s legal considerations in the Gibran case considered the reasons referring to the principle of ‘presumptio iustae causa’ in examining the requirements, the Court stated that the application of this principle must be reinforced by the principles of precision and prudence, given that a presidential election is a major political event for filling the highest office in government.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/reasons-why-kpu-accepted-gibrans-equivalence-certificate-the-presumption-of-validity-1791381473)
Originally published by CNN Indonesia (https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20261007182456-32-1412830/alasan-kpu-terima-suket-penyetaraan-gibran-asas-praduga-keabsahan), translated from Indonesian