Reading the Vigilante Phenomenon: Mob Justice in Bali to Morowali
Vigilante actions, or mob justice, have spread over the past week, occurring almost simultaneously in several regions of Indonesia.
In Bali, a man with the initials KD was beaten to death after being suspected of stealing a resident’s fighting cockerel. The incident occurred in the early hours of Friday (24 July) at around 01.30 WITA in Banjar Dinas Juwuk Legi, Batunya village, Baturiti district, Tabanan, Bali.
A day later, on Saturday (25 July), a 33-year-old man with the initials S in Morowali, Central Sulawesi, also died after being beaten by a mob on suspicion of attempting to steal a motorcycle at around 23.05 WITA.
A similar case occurred in Lamongan, East Java. MHS (30), a resident of Tiwet Kalitengah, and AP (29), a resident of Kemlagigede, Turi, were assaulted after being suspected of stealing scrap metal from a shop-house on Friday at around 14.00 WIB.
Although there were no fatalities, AP said one of the mob, who claimed to be the shop-house owner, threatened him with a firearm. He was also tied up, beaten and doused with salt water.
These cases do not even include the mobbing of a civil servant in Tanjung Balai over suspicions of sexual harassment by her husband, or the clash between residents in Matraman, Jakarta, which claimed one life.
Soeprapto, a criminologist and sociologist at Gadjah Mada University (UGM), described the recent acts of mob justice in Bali, Morowali and Lamongan as spontaneous actions. He said these cases indicate three things.
First, a low level of emotional control. As a result, Soeprapto said, people are unable to restrain themselves from venting their emotions through violent acts.
Second, large crowds give people the courage to ignore legal risks. This situation makes them feel as though they possess the power to carry out their actions.
Third, vigilante actions, Soeprapto continued, also indicate a low level of public intelligence. As a result, people no longer think rationally about the consequences.
Soeprapto argued that these vigilante cases do not indicate public distrust of law enforcement. Judging from several of the triggers, they are purely spontaneous.
“The third indication is that in a crowd, people’s rational thinking is diminished, so they have no time to consider the consequences of their actions, having committed assault against another person,” Soeprapto said.
Scrutiny of law enforcement and bounty schemes
Reza Indragiri, a criminologist at the University of Indonesia (UI), said the notion that the prevalence of vigilante actions reflects distrust of law enforcement is not a mistaken assumption. However, according to Reza, that assumption is not entirely correct either.
In his view, vigilantism is also driven by situational causes, namely situations where perpetrators escape legal sanctions. Vigilantism can also be triggered by bounty schemes, especially when offered by government authorities.
“Such actions are often judged as bad and dangerous. They can produce a brutalisation effect, marked by follow-on violence that continues to multiply,” Reza said when contacted on Tuesday (28 July).
Nevertheless, he argued that vigilante actions are not entirely negative. According to Reza, in certain circumstances vigilantism fills a legal vacuum, because legal certainty achieved through mob justice can be swifter.
Second, it builds solidarity between residents, and even between residents and the authorities. According to Reza, cooperation between the public and the police narrows the space for crime.
“A partnership between police and society, both equally vigilant, narrows opportunities for crime. Third, at a certain scale, vigilantism produces a deterrent effect,” he said.
Unfortunately, Reza continued, such a partnership can also cause both the public and the authorities to lose their vigilance, because the two sides may become mutually dependent.
“At that point, the situation turns 180 degrees and becomes a springtime for bandits. What can one do; when vigilantism is no longer the trend, bromocorah (repeat offenders or recidivists) relapse again,” he said.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/reading-the-vigilante-phenomenon-mob-justice-in-bali-to-morowali-1785228840)
Originally published by CNN Indonesia (https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20260728142601-12-1385753/membaca-fenomena-vigilante-main-hakim-sendiri-di-bali-hingga-morowali), translated from Indonesian