Rationale of additional tax reform
Rationale of additional tax reform
Sofjan Wanandi, Chairman, Committee for National Economic Recovery
(KPEN), Jakarta
The issues concerning refunds is closely related to tax audits
because refunds, except in certain cases, are always subjected to
tax audits. To address the issue, two approaches should be taken
simultaneously, i.e. refunds given without prior audits,
particularly in respect of value added tax (VAT) and provisions
that give rise to refunds should be repealed. A number of
examples can be presented below.
Article 25 of the Income Tax Law ("pay as you go"), which
reflects the self-assessment system, must be based on actual data
rather than estimates. A newly established company will
definitely not make income during its first year of operations
and therefore it must not be subject to Article 25.
Refunds of VAT in business should be given automatically
without prior audit.
The VAT mechanism is better returned to the general principle
where no company nor industry will be appointed as withholding
agent for VAT purposes.
Interest income on delayed refunds has never been given even
though the law provides such provisions. This is also true in
case the tax court has decided in favor of taxpayer. This
treatment underlines the fact that the position of taxpayers and
tax administration are not equal in term of rights prescribed by
tax laws.
Under current provisions and practice, the submission of an
objection does not prevent tax administration from collection,
irrespective of the objection being legally strong. Moreover,
the treatment is not fair because the submission of an appeal is
considered legitimate only when it is accompanied with tax
payment of 50 percent of the disputed tax liability.
The objection must be dealt with within 12 months whilst
taxpayers are required to pay the disputed tax. From a taxpayer's
viewpoint, it will pose a cash flow problem. In addition, there
is a conflict of interest because the objection case is dealt
with by tax officials. It is better for such objections to be
dealt with by an independent party having no interest in the
case.
The sanctions imposed by law against taxpayers on one side and
tax officials on the other side are lopsided. Tax officials are
subject to sanction only if their conduct causes revenue losses
to the state, and the sanctions are stipulated in the different
regulations, which are not as harsh as sanctions against
taxpayers who do not comply with the law. To encourage tax
officials to do their job professionally there must be equal
treatment between taxpayers and tax officials in front of tax
laws.
The emphasis on revenue enhancement without giving appropriate
consideration to encourage investment would give an adverse
impact in terms of revenue in the long run. Therefore, the tax
policy should be set to achieve two main goals, namely to enhance
revenue and encourage investment.
The revenue enhancement should be focused on transactions or
business profits that have not been addressed in the law. From a
legal point of view, a favorable investment climate can be
established through the adoption of a "tax neutral" principle.
The principle is crucial in establishing a favorable investment
climate because it establishes "certainty".
In addition, emphasis should also be put in the area of
simplicity in terms of compliance. The onus of keeping books of
account is an excellent idea. However, given the level of
education and the cost associated therewith, it puts additional
burden on most taxpayers that fall under small and medium sized
enterprises. Therefore, it is appropriate to increase the level
of turn-over as prescribed under the present law as a benchmark
for an enterprise (sole proprietorship) obliged to keep books of
account.
Some of the issues that calls for amendment in relation to
the above-mentioned principles are set out below.
The amendment of tax laws can be used to enhance revenue by
adding provisions that govern certain types of transactions that
have not been addressed in the current law such as:
* The definition of royalty is added in line with the development
in technology, and should be defined in accordance with
internationally accepted standard. Under current definition some
royalty type of transactions have not been addressed such as
software, cable television etc. The added definition should be
drafted without overlooking the principle of neutrality.
* Transactions through e-commerce has not been stipulated in the
law, and such transactions have potential tax revenue.
* Gain on the transfer of mining rights needs to be clearly
stipulated, which in turn will provide certainty to the business
climate.
The tax neutral principle is crucial in an attempt to
establish a favorable investment climate because tax provisions
will not impede investment decisions. In the long run it will
enhance tax revenue because investment is encouraged. A lot of
tax provisions now in effect do not address tax neutrality and it
becomes more burdensome to do business. Tax neutrality is often
overlooked due to the inefficiency of the administration.
Some examples on tax neutral provisions are as follows:
* The tax treatment of exploration costs in oil and gas upstream
industry are recovered through cost recovery rather than
amortization.
* Automatic refund of VAT would not impede the business
transactions because by so doing there is not any additional cost
of money.
* Interest received by banks is not subject to withholding
because a bank's main revenue takes the form of interest.
* Loss carried forward for general mining under contract of work
is eight years.
Examples of provisions that do not contain neutrality, among
other things, are:
* Companies engaged in consumer financing are not allowed to
claim a reserve while the business also has risks similar to the
banking industry.
* The treatment of gold bars as non-VAT-able goods is not neutral
because it is not in accordance with VAT principle.
* Public transportation (inland and water transportation) is
originally (under the provisions in the law) not a VAT-able
service, but becomes VAT-able when certain conditions prevail.
* Newly established companies are not eased from the obligation
to pay monthly income tax (pay as you go system).
The reform measures recommended above will encourage taxpayers
to fully disclose their income or business profits.
However, bearing in mind the current practice and other
factors (such as the change in tax return forms), it is necessary
to make a clean break with the past. Taxpayers must be encouraged
to fully disclose their income, including the increment of their
wealth.
In most cases taxpayers are forced to evade tax because, even
if they are honest, they are treated like those who are not.
Bearing that in mind, it is deemed appropriate to introduce tax
amnesty to allow taxpayers to fully disclose their tax affairs to
start a new era.
KPEN is forum of the private sector to advise the government
on economic issues.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/rationale-of-additional-tax-reform-1447893297-1366157)
Originally published by The Jakarta Post