Range of Reactions Following Constitutional Court Ruling on Gibran's Diploma
The Constitutional Court (MK) has stated that it found no evidence to suggest that Vice President Gibrability Rakabuming Raka possessed a high school equivalent diploma when registering as a vice-presidential candidate in the 2024 Presidential Election. Nevertheless, the Court declared that it could not disqualify Gibran.
“The Court cannot annul or disqualify Gibran Rakabuming Raka from his position as Vice President as requested in the petitioners’ prayer,” stated MK judge Adies Kadir during the verdict session at the MK building, Central Jakarta, on Tuesday (6/10/2026).
He noted that the MK does not have the authority to assess the fulfilment of presidential and vice-presidential requirements, even though facts exist regarding the absence of Gibran’s diploma during his studies abroad. He stated that other institutions hold the relevant authority regarding this matter.
“Regarding the facts obtained by the Court concerning the absence of a diploma/certificate/diploma abroad used as a basis for equivalence with a minimum education of high school, madrasah aliyah, vocational high school, or equivalent, this substantially falls within the domain of institutions authorised to assess the validity and fulfilment of requirements for presidential and vice-presidential candidates as regulated in the 1945 Constitution,” said Adies.
Gibran on the MK Ruling
Vice President Gibran respects the MK’s decision regarding the lack of evidence for a high school equivalent diploma in the 2024 election result lawsuit. Gibran stated that he will now focus on ensuring the success of President Prabowo Subianto’s vision and programmes.
“We respect all the stages and processes within the MK. The most important thing now is that I will continue to focus on working for the people and ensuring the success of the vision, mission, and programmes of the President as our leader,” Gibrability said, as reported by Antara on Wednesday (7/10/2026).
Regarding the MK ruling that it cannot disqualify him as Vice President despite the lack of evidence for a diploma or educational equivalence document, Gibran emphasised that he continued his education to the undergraduate level after completing high school equivalent education.
“If I had not passed high school, it would have been impossible for me to attend university. I completed my undergraduate studies in Singapore,” he said.
Golkar Calls it a Lesson for Evaluation
The Deputy Chairman of the Golkar Party and member of Commission II of the DPR RI, Ahmad Doli Kurnability, assessed that the Constitutional Court’s ruling regarding Vice President Gibran’s diploma serves as a lesson for election organisers. He described the ruling as a blow and a subject for introspection.
“For election organisers, this MK ruling is not merely a lesson, but also a blow and a subject for self-introspection,” Doli told reporters on Wednesday (7/10/2026).
Nevertheless, Doli stated that his party respects the decision made by the MK. He also appreciated the MK for positioning itself as a legal institution and separating the realm of legal authority from the political realm.
“We also express our appreciation and thanks, as the MK has truly positioned itself as a legal institution, which is objectively able to separate what falls within its legal authority from the political realm, which is outside its jurisdiction,” he said.
Furthermore, Doli stated that the MK ruling would serve as material for drafting future election laws. He assessed that the requirements, recruitment processes, and selection of leaders and representatives need to be regulated more detailedly and transparently.
“In relation to the drafting of the upcoming Election Law, this MK ruling will be important material for the modification and improvement of our future election system,” he explained.
“The takeaway is that in the future, the requirements, recruitment processes, and selection of leaders and representatives, both at the central and regional levels, must be regulated more precisely and through more transparent mechanisms,” he added.
PDIP Mentions Right of Inquiry
Member of Commission II of the DPR and Chairman of the PDIP DPP, Deddy Yevri Sitorus, stated that the DPR could use the special committee (pansus) or right of inquiry (hak angket) mechanism to follow up on the ruling.
“Politically, it is very possible for the DPR to follow up on this MK ruling through available mechanisms, such as a special committee and/or a right of inquiry,” Deddy Sitorus said in a statement released to reporters on Wednesday (7/10/2026).
Deddy stated that the MK ruling provides a basis to re-examine the issue of Gibran’s candidacy administrative requirements. He noted that the most significant aspect of the ruling is the fact that Gibrability lacks a high school or equivalent diploma.
“This means that from the beginning, he did not meet the requirements to be a vice-presidential candidate. Therefore, it is suspected that the documents submitted as administrative requirements for candidacy are legally flawed,” he said.
He suggested that a violation of the law may have occurred. Deddy noted that since Gibran has been elected as Vice President, the issue could relate to the provisions in the 1945 Constitution regarding the dismissal of a President and/or Vice President.
PKS Calls it a Brave Step
PKS described the decision as brave and honest. “Bravo MK. A brave and honest decision,” said PKS Chairman Mardani Ali Sera to reporters, Wednesday.
Mardani praised the MK as a steadfast guardian of the constitution. When asked whether a special committee (pansus) is needed to investigate the diploma controversy, Mardani stated it depends entirely on the DPR.
“Is a Special Committee needed? It all depends on the process in the DPR. The core issue is: the requirements according to the MK decision were not met. However, Mr Gibran also has the right to respond,” said Mardani.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/range-of-reactions-following-constitutional-court-ruling-on-gibrans-diploma-1791424627)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/berita/d-8697316/deretan-komentar-buntut-putusan-mk-soal-ijazah-gibran), translated from Indonesian