Questions Raised After Parhan the Cat Is Not Returned to Sency by Adopter
Parhan the cat will not be returned to his original habitat at Senayan City (Sency) in Central Jakarta. Animal welfare groups have questioned the decision to cancel his return to Sency.
Under the initial agreement, Parhan was due to be returned to Sency on Thursday (12 November). Several animal welfare advocates went to Sency to wait for the adopter to bring him back.
One of those who came to Sency was Doni Herdaru Tona, founder of Animal Defender Indonesia (ADI). Doni questioned whether the parties would honour their agreement to return Parhan to Sency.
“In my view, the most important thing now is to establish the actual basis for cancelling Parhan’s return to Senayan City, given that the parties had previously signed a mediation agreement on 9 November 2026, witnessed by the Jakarta Provincial Food Security, Marine and Agriculture Agency (Dinas KPKP),” Doni said.
Animal lovers expressed disappointment that Parhan’s adopter had not fulfilled the agreement. The controversy began when Parhan, a community cat, was taken away from Sency.
“We regret it if an agreement reached jointly is not carried out. For us, this is not simply about where Parhan will live, but also about respecting the process, the agreement and the responsibilities involved, as well as acting in Parhan’s best interests,” he said.
Doni also raised concerns about posts published by the adopter on social media. He said he hoped the information in the posts about Parhan’s condition would be explained.
“In some of the material published, we found several points requiring further clarification and verification, including a document whose authenticity we question, a change in information about Parhan’s FIV status from positive to negative, and an interpretation of his health that differs from the usual medical assessment,” he said.
Doni said the information needed to be clarified because it concerned Parhan’s health and medical records. The group called for openness and verification by competent, independent medical professionals to prevent confusion in the public sphere.
He said they would monitor developments and coordinate through the proper channels with the relevant parties, including the Jakarta Provincial Dinas KPKP.
“I do not want to speculate or set out further steps before everything is clear. What matters is that we hope this can be resolved responsibly and transparently, without disregarding Parhan’s rights and welfare,” he said.
Why Parhan Has Not Been Returned
The adopter consulted Jakarta Cat Lovers (JCL) after Parhan’s return to Sency was called off. JCL said Parhan needed to be hospitalised and therefore could not yet be returned.
“JCL has contacted a competent and independent veterinarian to examine Parhan. Based on the examination and medical recommendation, Parhan currently needs to be hospitalised and receive further intensive medical care,” a statement on the @jakarta.catlovers Instagram account said.
The woman who adopted Parhan was listed as a collaborator on the post, which also included photographs of Parhan and medical documents concerning the cat.
JCL said a written account of Parhan’s condition, accompanied by the veterinarian’s explanation, had been sent to the parties involved in the mediation agreement of 9 November 2026, including the Jakarta Provincial Dinas KPKP and the management of Senayan City.
“Plans for Parhan’s return will be communicated and discussed again with the relevant parties once his health allows him to leave hospital, in accordance with the veterinarian’s recommendation,” it said.
The group asked the public to pray for Parhan’s recovery, saying they shared the same goal: to see him healthy and safe, and receiving the care he deserves.
Agreement to Return Parhan
Parhan’s story previously became controversial after a woman posted about receiving permission to adopt him. Parhan was subsequently taken away from Sency.
The woman who adopted him frequently shared updates about his activities on her personal Instagram account. However, members of the public became angry after Parhan appeared to have lost weight since being adopted.
Social media was then filled with calls for Parhan to be returned to Sency.
Parhan was due to be returned to Sency two days later. The return was the result of mediation facilitated by the Jakarta Provincial Food Security, Marine and Agriculture Agency (Dinas KPKP) with the parties involved.
“During mediation facilitated by the Jakarta Provincial Dinas KPKP as a neutral party, both sides jointly signed and agreed that, in Parhan’s best interests, he would be returned to Senayan City on Thursday, 12 November 2026,” Francine Widjojo, a member of Commission B of the Jakarta Regional House of Representatives (DPRD) from the Indonesian Solidarity Party (PSI) faction, said at the Jakarta DPRD building on Tuesday (10 November).
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/questions-raised-after-parhan-the-cat-is-not-returned-to-sency-by-adopter-1794613850)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/berita/d-8752378/ramai-tanya-kucing-parhan-batal-dikembalikan-ke-sency-oleh-pengadopsi), translated from Indonesian