Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Questioning the Distribution of Humanitarian Aid to Palestine

| | Source: Republika Translated from Indonesian | Politics
Questioning the Distribution of Humanitarian Aid to Palestine
Image: Republika

In the midst of the protracted conflict in Palestine, particularly in Gaza, calls for concern over humanitarian issues continue to resound. Some time ago, a social media post circulated by a Palestinian living in Indonesia. He criticised the lack of clarity in the distribution of humanitarian aid, even indicating “misappropriation” by pointing to the interests of certain groups treating donations as a business opportunity rather than purely for humanitarian purposes.

This criticism prompted varied responses from aid activists who have opened donation channels, while also raising a major question: how exactly is aid distributed in Palestine, and what strategy and governance model should be built to optimise humanitarian distribution amid the complex situation in the Middle East region?

It must be underlined that poor governance will only deepen public distrust of aid institutions, both national and international. Yet aid is desperately needed given that the humanitarian suffering in Gaza, for instance, is worsening.

According to UN OCHA data as of 29 July 2026, the conflict in Gaza has killed more than 73,000 Palestinians and injured more than 173,000 people. Children and women bear the heaviest impact. Around 1.9 million people (90 per cent of the population) face acute food crises without international assistance. In the health sector, of 683 health facilities, only 23 (3–4%) are fully operational, while 43% operate partially and the rest are completely non-functional. This situation is deeply alarming.

Palestinian Humanitarian Aid: Between Global Principles and Geopolitical Reality

By definition, humanitarian aid is emergency support in the form of food, medicines, clean water, and health services provided to communities affected by disaster or conflict. The universal principles recognised by the UN — humanity, neutrality, impartiality, and independence — should serve as the moral foundation of aid distribution. However, in the case of Gaza, geopolitical reality presents enormous challenges. The blockade, territorial control, and competing interests among the actors involved complicate the optimisation of aid distribution.

From the perspective of international relations studies, the difficulty of distributing aid in Gaza shows that humanitarian aid is never entirely neutral. Donor states, multilateral organisations, and other entities often bring their own agendas. Aid can become an instrument of diplomacy, even a tool of political pressure. A fundamental question arises: “can humanitarian aid be free of interests?” Several existing studies (Barnett and Weiss, 2008; Rieff, 2002) show that humanitarian aid has considerable room to serve as a tool for advancing the interests of both state and non-state actors.

As we know, since 2023 Israel has tightened its control over most of Gaza’s borders. As the party controlling distribution routes, Israel holds the power to determine whether routes are opened or closed, when, who receives aid, and who does not. Israel even sets the quantity of aid and the types of goods permitted or barred from entry, without regard for humanitarian considerations (Al Jazeera, 9 February 2026).

Given these conditions, it can be said that humanitarian aid in Gaza has lost its neutrality due to the strong geopolitical context. Aid that should symbolise global solidarity is often perceived instead as a tool of control. On the part of donor states, the actors involved also have diverse motives and interests. If the criticism conveyed by the Palestinian on social media regarding business interests in aid distribution is true, then this combination of factors further underscores the complexity of humanitarian distribution.

Distribution Strategy and Governance of Humanitarian Aid

Indonesian public enthusiasm for donating to humanitarian aid in Gaza is very high. This has driven the emergence of various philanthropic institutions involved in managing and channelling that aid. Nevertheless, distributing aid to Gaza is no easy matter.

In a discussion organised by CIReS FISIP UI in collaboration with Human Initiative at the end of November 2025 under the title “The Dark Side of Humanitarian Aid Distribution in Gaza”, speakers from UN OCHA, various philanthropic institutions (Baznas, DT Peduli, BSMI, MER-C), as well as humanitarian activists and volunteers complained about the difficulty of channelling aid optimally so that it directly reaches Palestinians in need. This affirms the importance of formulating a careful distribution strategy and transparent governance.

Such a distribution strategy includes, first, mapping needs and key areas as a foundation. In Gaza, refugee camps, hospitals, and emergency schools are vital points that must be prioritised. Aid must not merely pile up in border warehouses but must move swiftly to the spaces where lives are at stake every day.

Second, the involvement of local actors, both individuals and institutions that understand the surrounding situation, including alternative distribution routes. Community figures, local volunteers, and humanitarian organisations long operating in Gaza, such as MER-C, have proven more trusted by residents and can reduce resistance towards international agencies.

Third, understanding and identifying the regional map, including countries that can serve as alternative aid distribution routes. Egypt, via the Rafah Crossing, for example, is the main entry point, though often restricted. Support from Global South countries, such as those in the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation (OIC) and the Non-Aligned Movement, is also important to open up broader access and support.

Fourth, strengthening humanitarian negotiation through various channels of diplomacy (multi-track diplomacy) involving states, NGOs, academics, and the Palestinian diaspora in Indonesia, so that negotiations over aid access carry more weight. In addition, civil society support through the presence of various philanthropic institutions and grassroots networks, local and international, must complement one another. However, the proliferation of institutions involved can also be seen as a form of institutional fragmentation.

It must also be emphasised that the distribution strategy above means nothing without good governance. Transparency is key, through open reporting on the quantity, type, and destination of aid. Support from advanced technology is also important to facilitate real-time public monitoring of distribution movements.

The aspect of accountability must be maintained through independent audits and real-time donation reporting so that there is no room for misuse, while also increasing public trust. Equally important, coordination and collaboration across actors must operate within a mutually agreed framework, without overlapping one another and without producing bureaucratisation that instead hinders aid.

In any case, humanitarian aid is a symbol of solidarity. Indonesia must stand at the forefront, consistently demonstrating in concrete terms its solidarity on humanitarian issues and the independence of Palestine. #FreePalestine

More from 5 August 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/questioning-the-distribution-of-humanitarian-aid-to-palestine-1785905519)
Originally published by Republika (https://analisis.republika.co.id/berita/tja3mi393/menyoal-distribusi-bantuan-kemanusiaan-untuk-palestina), translated from Indonesian
Print