Quality of teachers: LPTK graduates vs non-LPTK graduates
If LPTKs can guarantee all of that, then LPTK graduates should be the primary choice. If not, the status of being an LPTK graduate must not be used as a reason to claim quality automatically.
Jakarta (ANTARA) - The debate about teacher quality is often directed at one question: must teachers come from an educational personnel training institution (LPTK)?
This question becomes increasingly relevant as the need for teachers grows, while graduates of education study programmes have not always been able to meet the need quantitatively or qualitatively.
What is meant by LPTK? An educational personnel training institution is a higher education institution, or part of one, that organises education to prepare education personnel, particularly teachers.
In the historical development of higher education in Indonesia, LPTKs can take the form of former IKIP (teacher training institute) universities, universities with a Faculty of Teacher Training and Education (FKIP), or other higher education institutions that organise teacher-candidate education programmes.
Therefore, LPTKs and study programmes need to be distinguished. An LPTK is the institution, while a study programme is the academic unit that organises education in a particular field.
For example, an English Language Education study programme prepares future English teachers, Mathematics Education prepares future Mathematics teachers, and Physics Education prepares future Physics teachers.
Thus, the term “LPTK graduate” mainly refers to graduates of education study programmes who are indeed prepared to become teachers. Conversely, non-LPTK graduates are graduates of academic or professional study programmes outside the field of education who then enter the teaching profession through pathways that allow them to acquire teaching competencies.
LPTKs have potential advantages. Conceptually, the main advantage of LPTK graduates lies in pedagogical readiness. A prospective teacher cannot merely master mathematics, English, physics, history, or another field of knowledge. They must be able to transform that knowledge into learning experiences that enable students to understand, apply, and reflect on what they learn.
This is the difference between mastering a subject and being able to teach it. LPTKs should be the place where prospective teachers acquire a blend of both. Prospective teachers do not only learn what to teach, but also how to teach, how students learn, and how to assess learning.
Furthermore, they need to understand how to build relationships that honour the teacher, the student, and knowledge in the learning process.
Nevertheless, that advantage does not automatically attach itself to every LPTK graduate. The quality of LPTKs varies greatly. Weak education study programmes, overly theoretical learning, limited field experience, and lecturers who fail to keep up with developments in schools can produce graduates who meet the requirements administratively but are not necessarily ready to become quality teachers. In other words, graduating from an LPTK is not an automatic guarantee of a teacher’s quality.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/quality-of-teachers-lptk-graduates-vs-non-lptk-graduates-1788843261)
Originally published by Antara (Indonesian) (https://www.antaranews.com/berita/5730913/mutu-guru-lulusan-lptk-vs-non-lptk), translated from Indonesian