Prosecutors Urge Judge to Reject Dr Tifa's Exception Plea, Push for Trial to Proceed to Evidence Stage
Public prosecutors (JPU) have asked the panel of judges at the East Jakarta District Court (PN Jaktim) to reject the objection note, or exception, filed by defendant Tifauzia Tyassuma, also known as dr Tifa. The prosecutors consider the indictment to have been drafted carefully and that PN Jaktim has the authority to hear the case.
“Reject in its entirety the exception filed by the defendant and her legal counsel team, dr Tifauzia Tyassuma,” the prosecutor said at the hearing held at PN Jaktim on Thursday (16/7/2026).
Regarding the court’s jurisdiction, the prosecutor affirmed that PN Jaktim has absolute relative authority to examine this case. This is based on Decree of the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court of the Republic of Indonesia Number: 114/KMA/SK.HK2.2/VI/2026, which rests on the mandate of Article 166 of Law Number 20 of 2025 (the new Criminal Procedure Code).
The prosecutor considered the argument put forward by dr Tifa’s legal team regarding a violation of the principle of speciality to be a fallacy.
“The argument of a violation of the principle of speciality and delegatus non potest delegare is a conceptual fallacy, because the Supreme Court exercised its original authority under statute for the sake of judicial efficiency,” the prosecutor said.
The prosecutor then responded to dr Tifa’s argument that the state’s right to prosecute had lapsed because reports against other reported parties, namely Eggi Sudjana and colleagues, had been withdrawn through the restorative justice mechanism. According to the prosecutor, the articles charged against dr Tifa are dominated by ordinary offences, not complaint-based offences.
“The indictment uses a combined structure dominated by ordinary offences, namely Article 32 and Article 35 of the ITE Law and Article 126 of Law Number 1 of 2023, so the principle of ondeelbaarheid van klacht (the indivisibility of a complaint) is paralysed by law and cannot be applied,” the prosecutor explained.
Regarding the legal standing of the reporting party, the prosecutor stated that the 7th President of the Republic of Indonesia, Joko Widodo (Jokowi), is a direct victim in this case. The prosecutor said Jokowi’s constitutional rights and personal data are inherently attached to the object of the diploma allegedly manipulated by dr Tifa.
“Because the violated provisions are Article 32 and Article 35 of the ITE Law, which are characterised as ordinary offences, the legal standing of the reporting party is non-restrictive in order to protect the integrity of public data,” the prosecutor explained.
Furthermore, the prosecutor considered that dr Tifa’s exception had entered into the merits of the case. Several points of dr Tifa’s objections, such as witness immunity, press freedom, and the rejection of screenshot evidence, were described by the prosecutor as premature arguments.
“Those objections must not be decided in an interlocutory ruling, but must be rejected and examined together at the evidentiary stage of the trial,” the prosecutor said.
The prosecutor emphasised that the indictment was drafted in accordance with both formal and material requirements. The prosecutor also requested that the judges reject dr Tifa’s exception in its entirety and that the trial proceed to the evidentiary stage.
“Reject in its entirety the exception filed by the defendant and her legal counsel team, dr Tifauzia Tyassuma,” the prosecutor said.
“Order that the examination of the criminal case in the name of the defendant dr Tifauzia Tyassuma be continued to the examination of the merits of the case by presenting evidence at trial,” the prosecutor concluded.
dr Tifa is charged with defamation and slander against Jokowi
As previously reported, Tifauzia Tyassuma, or dr Tifa, is charged with committing defamation and slander against the 7th President of the Republic of Indonesia, Joko Widodo (Jokowi), over allegations regarding a fake diploma. The charges were read out by the prosecutor at the first hearing at the East Jakarta District Court (PN Jaktim) today.
The case began on 26 March 2025, when a witness who is also Jokowi’s aide, Syarif Muhammad Fitriansyah, on Jalan HR Rasuna Said, Kuningan, South Jakarta, informed and showed the witness Jokowi the existence of three posts on social media attacking Jokowi’s honour or good name.
The prosecutor also said dr Tifa alleged there were a number of irregularities in Jokowi’s diploma. These included, among others, the cover text, the graduation photograph, the UGM alumni book, and Jokowi’s reference to the late professor Achmad Soemitro as his supervising lecturer.
Tifa is charged under the primary indictment with Article 434 paragraph 1 in conjunction with Article 441 paragraph 1 in conjunction with Article 126 paragraph 1 of the Criminal Code. Then, in the subsidiary indictment, Article 433 paragraph 1 in conjunction with Article 441 paragraph 1 in conjunction with Article 126 paragraph 1 of the Criminal Code.
Tifa is also charged under a second primary indictment with Article 434 paragraph 1 of the Criminal Code. Second subsidiary: Article 310 paragraph 1 of the Criminal Code or Article 35 in conjunction with Article 51 paragraph (1) and/or Article 32 paragraph (1) in conjunction with Article 48 paragraph (1) of Law Number 11 of 2008 on Electronic Information and Transactions (ITE) in conjunction with Article 126 paragraph (1) of the Criminal Code, or Article 32 in conjunction with Article 48 paragraph 1 of the ITE Law in conjunction with Article 126 paragraph (1) of the Criminal Code.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/prosecutors-urge-judge-to-reject-dr-tifas-exception-plea-push-for-trial-to-proceed-to-evidence-stage-1784199259)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/berita/d-8577092/jaksa-minta-hakim-tolak-eksepsi-dr-tifa-minta-sidang-lanjut-ke-pembuktian), translated from Indonesian