Prosecutors Question Silmy Karim’s Surrender to KPK: ‘There Must Be a Story Behind It’
KPK prosecutors responded to a legal objection by former Deputy Minister for Immigration and Corrections Silmy Karim, who alleged that a supposed sting operation was fabricated to implicate him in an alleged gratification and extortion case involving limited-stay permits for foreign nationals. The prosecutors said Silmy should have openly explained where he was when his subordinates were detained.
“In his objection, the defendant should first have described where he was when KPK investigators detained his subordinates: where he was, who he was with, and why he concealed his whereabouts,” a prosecutor said while responding to Silmy Karim’s objection at the Central Jakarta Corruption Court on Tuesday (10 November 2026).
The prosecutor said Silmy should also have been candid about whether anyone had told him to come to the KPK. The prosecutor said there was a story behind his arrival at the agency.
“Did anyone tell the defendant to come to the KPK building? If so, who told him to come? These matters should have been explained fully, not in fragments, as though the defendant had gone to the KPK entirely of his own accord. There must be a story behind it,” the prosecutor said.
The prosecution argued that being caught in the act is not an element of the offences charged in either the first or second count. It said a corruption prosecution does not require a person to be caught while committing the alleged crime.
“Whether or not the circumstances amount to being caught in the act does not determine whether the elements of Article 12(e) or Article 12B of the Corruption Law have been met. If the legality of an arrest or other coercive measure is challenged, it must be assessed on the basis of the relevant documents and the review mechanisms provided for under procedural law,” the prosecutor said.
The prosecutor said the prosecution would prove the elements of the offences allegedly committed by Silmy during the evidentiary hearings. Whether an arrest took place, the prosecutor added, was a matter of procedural law.
“Questions about the defendant’s process of arriving at the KPK building, or whether an arrest took place, are procedural matters that must be assessed on the basis of the facts and documents relating to the relevant legal action,” the prosecutor said.
“Therefore, the defendant cannot conflate the question of whether he was caught in the act with the proof of the criminal elements underpinning the charges,” the prosecutor added.
Speaking after the hearing, Silmy Karim said he had gone to the KPK by himself on the evening of 3 June 2026. However, he said the impression that he had been caught in the act continued to follow him.
“There was never an operation, and that is not in accordance with the Corruption Eradication Law,” Silmy Karim said.
Silmy’s lawyer, Soleman B. Ponto, said the focus of the case had shifted. He said Silmy had initially been described as having been caught in a sting operation.
“From the outset, this case shifted from being about someone caught in the act to extortion. What will it shift to after extortion? We will see,” Soleman said.
Soleman said the defence was ready to prove at trial whether Silmy had committed extortion. He said the case had been framed as a sting operation.
“What is being disputed now is extortion. We will wait and see how we prove whether it happened or not. But from the beginning, our client was said to have been caught in the act. We have now said that he was not, and that point was not disputed. Instead, they said that not being caught in the act does not mean the case cannot proceed,” he said.
Another of Silmy’s lawyers, Abdul Gafur Sangaji, said the prosecution’s response to the objection merely repeated the indictment. He stressed that the alleged extortion and gratification could not yet be considered proven because the trial had not reached the stage of examining the merits of the case.
“I think the prosecutors are wavering. They have drawn Rp168 billion into one series of illegal levies allegedly carried out by other perpetrators, while the indictment against Mr Silmy refers to only Rp1.2 billion. By including Rp168 billion in Mr Silmy’s indictment, they have created the impression that he was part of that Rp168 billion,” Gafur said.
“The prosecutors acknowledged today that he was not part of the Rp168 billion, but only the Rp1.2 billion. How it was received, how it was handed over and how the extortion took place, they say, will be proved in court,” he added.
The charges against Silmy Karim
In this case, Silmy is accused of extorting applicants for immigration documents related to foreign nationals’ residence permits, involving a total of Rp168.9 billion. Prosecutors say Silmy received Rp1.2 billion.
Prosecutors allege that Silmy acted together with former acting Director-General of Immigration Saffar Muhammad Godam, who held the post in 2024–2025; former Director of Residence Permits and Immigration Status at the Directorate General of Immigration Jaya Saputra; former sub-director of changes to residence-permit status Tessar Bayu Setyaji; former sub-director at the Directorate of Residence Permits Bagus Bramantyo; former head of the ITAS status-change team Juniadi Sri Priambudi; and former staff member of the Residence Permits Sub-directorate Gusti Benardiansyah.
“The defendants forced people by making the issuance process difficult or slow, or by refusing to issue documents to applicants for immigration documents, including visit stay permits, emergency visit stay permits, limited-stay permits (ITAS), permanent-stay permits (ITAP), and changes to administrative status,” a KPK prosecutor said while reading the indictment at the Central Jakarta Corruption Court on Thursday (29 October).
The prosecution said the alleged scheme also enriched other people: Saffar Muhammad Godam by Rp500 million; Jaya Saputra by Rp6,532,584,769; Tessar Bayu Setyaji by Rp2,881,871,025; Bagus Bramantyo by Rp4,245,542,862; Juniadi Sri Priambudi by Rp16,307,366,374; and Gusti Benardiansyah by Rp50,965,111,560.
“And other applicants for immigration documents or changes of status were induced to provide something, make payments or accept deductions, or perform something for the perpetrators’ benefit against their will, by paying a total of Rp168,972,869,901,” the prosecutor said.
Silmy is also accused of receiving gratification worth Rp33,941,119,000 (Rp33.9 billion). Prosecutors said this comprised Rp2.5 billion in cash and shares in several securities companies registered in Silmy’s name, valued at Rp31.3 billion.
“The defendant, Silmy Karim, committed several separate criminal acts by receiving gratification, either directly or indirectly, in the form of money totalling Rp2,560,000,000 and shares in several securities companies registered in his name, valued at Rp31,381,119,000,” the prosecutor said.
Prosecutors charged Silmy under Article 12(e) or Article 12B, in conjunction with Article 18 of the Corruption Law, Article 20(c), and Article 127(1) of Law No. 1 of 2023 on the Criminal Code.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/prosecutors-question-silmy-karims-surrender-to-kpk-there-must-be-a-story-behind-it-1794329487)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/berita/d-8747421/jaksa-soroti-silmy-karim-serahkan-diri-ke-kpk-tentu-ada-cerita-di-baliknya), translated from Indonesian