Prosecutors Appeal MXGP Land Corruption Ruling, Citing Rp50 Million Fine
Mataram (ANTARA) - The West Nusa Tenggara High Prosecutor’s Office (Kejati NTB) has filed an appeal to the Supreme Court against the appeals court ruling involving three defendants in a corruption case related to the acquisition of land for the MXGP circuit in the Samota area of Sumbawa Regency.
Kejati NTB spokesperson Harun Al Rasyid said in Mataram on Monday that prosecutors considered the West Nusa Tenggara High Court’s ruling to have fallen short of justice, particularly in the amount of the fines imposed on the defendants.
“What we feel still falls short of justice is apparent from the substance of the charges. The public prosecutors sought fines of around Rp500 million, but in the appeal ruling they were reduced to Rp50 million, with 50 days’ imprisonment in lieu,” he said.
The prosecutors registered the appeal on Monday (12 October), after the West Nusa Tenggara High Court delivered its appeal ruling on Tuesday (6 October).
Harun said prosecutors also objected to the ruling’s omission of a direction to investigate the possible involvement of other parties, as had been raised by the court of first instance.
One person whose role the first-instance judges had said should be examined was former East Lombok regent Ali Bin Dachlan, who sold the land for the project.
The investigation concerned the elements of criminal intent (mens rea) and criminal conduct (actus reus), based on facts disclosed during the trial.
During the proceedings, Ali was said to have received money related to an overpayment for the 70-hectare land acquisition by the Sumbawa Regency Government in 2022.
An audit by the West Nusa Tenggara representative office of the Financial and Development Supervisory Agency (BPKP) found that the Rp52 billion acquisition had caused state losses of about Rp6.7 billion.
Ali had previously handed Rp6.7 billion to prosecutors after the audit findings emerged during the investigation.
Nevertheless, Kejati NTB had earlier said it had found no evidence of Ali’s criminal intent in the facts established during the trial.
Harun said prosecutors would use the appeal process to resubmit all trial evidence they considered relevant to the case.
“The appeal memorandum will be our opportunity [as prosecutors] to set everything out. We will present all the facts in the memorandum,” he said.
The three defendants are former Sumbawa Regency National Land Agency (BPN) head Subhan and two public valuers from the Public Appraisal Services Office (KJPP), Pung Saifullah Zulkarnaen and Muhammad Jan.
In its ruling on Tuesday (6 October), a panel of West Nusa Tenggara High Court judges led by Hera Kartiningsih overturned the first-instance ruling, which had previously acquitted Pung Saifullah and Muhammad Jan by declaring that their conduct did not constitute a criminal offence (onslag).
The appeals panel found the two defendants guilty of participating in corruption and sentenced each to two years in prison and a Rp50 million fine, with 50 days’ imprisonment in lieu of payment.
This differed from the first-instance court’s ruling, which found that the two defendants’ actions had been established but did not amount to a criminal offence, and therefore released them from all legal charges.
Kejati NTB had previously enforced the first-instance ruling by releasing Pung Saifullah and Muhammad Jan from detention.
Although both were subsequently sentenced to prison on appeal, there was no information available on whether a new detention order had been issued after prosecutors filed their appeal.
“Since we have filed an appeal, we leave the Supreme Court to decide the status of Pung and Jan, who have been released from detention,” Harun said.
Meanwhile, the appeals panel increased Subhan’s sentence from one year and three months to two years and three months in prison.
The fine imposed on Subhan remained Rp50 million, with 50 days’ imprisonment in lieu of payment.
The appeals panel also found Subhan guilty under the prosecutors’ primary charge, unlike the first-instance court, which had found him guilty under the subsidiary charge.
The case concerns the acquisition of 70 hectares for the MXGP circuit in the Samota area of Sumbawa Regency. The land was acquired for Rp52 billion, and an audit put state losses at about Rp6.7 billion.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/prosecutors-appeal-mxgp-land-corruption-ruling-citing-rp50-million-fine-1792407099)
Originally published by Antara (Indonesian) (https://www.antaranews.com/berita/5796697/jaksa-kasasi-vonis-korupsi-lahan-mxgp-soroti-denda-rp50-juta), translated from Indonesian