Prosecutor Says Bangun Paulus’s Testimony Is Inconsistent
Jakarta (ANTARA) — The public prosecutor has said that several statements made by defendant Bangun Paulus Tudungta during his trial on alleged threats and extortion at the Central Jakarta District Court conflicted with testimony from witnesses who had appeared in court.
“When considered alongside the facts presented at trial, they are clearly contradictory and differ from the witnesses’ statements. We will draw everything together in our sentencing submission,” prosecutor Andri Saputra said after the hearing in Jakarta on Wednesday evening.
He said one point of concern was the defendant’s denial of allegations that he had used violence against the victim.
At an earlier hearing, the victim said they had suffered violence that caused trauma and fear.
Andri said a witness named Ari had heard a request for Rp50 million, later reduced to Rp30 million. Meanwhile, Philip, a witness who was sitting behind them, had heard figures of Rp300 million and Rp200 million.
“There is something rather odd here, essentially. Someone is denying it,” Andri said.
Nevertheless, he said the defendant had the right to give evidence in accordance with his own beliefs, including denying some of the facts raised in court. The assessment of the conflicting accounts was entirely a matter for the panel of judges.
Andri said these facts had also emerged during the trial proceedings.
Regarding the defendant’s return of Rp50 million to the victim, Andri said the money was still in the defendant’s possession when the trial was under way. No attempt to return it had been made during the inquiry or investigation.
“Under the rules, ideally it should have been confiscated during the investigation. But the defendant may also have the right to return it. The victim has the right to refuse,” he said.
The indictment charged Bangun Paulus under Article 482(1)(a) and Article 483(a) of Law No. 1 of 2023 on the Criminal Code, carrying maximum prison sentences of nine years and four years respectively.
The prosecutors are scheduled to present their sentencing demand at the next hearing on 12 November 2026.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/prosecutor-says-bangun-pauluss-testimony-is-inconsistent-1793836272)
Originally published by Antara (Indonesian) (https://www.antaranews.com/berita/5832823/jpu-nilai-keterangan-terdakwa-bangun-paulus-janggal), translated from Indonesian