Prosecutor Questions Independence of Education Expert: Testimony Based on Opinion, Not Facts
Prosecutors have questioned the independence of an expert witness presented by the defendant, former Minister of Education, Culture, Research, and Technology Nadiem Makarim, in the continuation of the trial for alleged corruption in the Chromebook procurement at the Corruption Court in Central Jakarta on Tuesday, 21 April 2026. Nadiem’s legal team introduced Ina Liem, described as an Expert Consultant in Education and Career. Prosecutor Roy Riady raised concerns about the expert’s capacity, noting that investigations into her social media accounts revealed months of opinion-shaping regarding the Chromebook corruption case. “Thus, in the trial, we raised objections and questioned whether the expert is appearing as an independent expert or as a supporter of the defendant Nadiem Anwar Makarim, but wearing the guise of an education and career expert,” Roy stated in his comments, quoted on Thursday, 23 April 2026. Furthermore, Roy noted that during the trial, Ina Liem admitted to not knowing about the electronic data or technical studies that formed the basis of the Chromebook procurement. Therefore, he argued, what Liem conveyed was merely opinion without proper analytical foundation. “It turns out the expert said she never knew about that, so she was just steering opinions. This is what is very dangerous for parties trying to steer opinions outside the court,” he said. In addition, the prosecutor highlighted that the expert addressed all aspects of the case without focusing on her expertise as an Education and Career Consultant. “Answering about procurement, answering about state losses, answering about education. So, not focused, even though she was presented as an education and career expert,” he added. Meanwhile, Nadiem’s side also presented mitigating witnesses from teachers in the Sorong and Pamekasan regions. He stated that their presence in the trial actually revealed the fact that the utilisation of Chromebooks in the field remains very minimal. “They explained that the Chromebooks were indeed procured, but they confirmed that they are only used for AKM (Minimum Competency Assessment) once a year,” he added. According to him, this finding is supported by activation data from Pusdatin and Pusdekam for the 2020-2021 period, which shows the low usage of the devices in the teaching and learning process.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/prosecutor-questions-independence-of-education-expert-testimony-based-on-opinion-not-facts-1776988326)
Originally published by VIVA.co.id (https://www.viva.co.id/berita/nasional/1894128-pertanyakan-independensi-ahli-pendidikan-jaksa-keterangannya-berbasis-opini-bukan-fakta), translated from Indonesian