Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Pros and Cons of Prabowo's Idea to Make Village Cooperatives Distributors of Subsidised Goods

| Source: Tempo Bisnis Translated from Indonesian | Economy

President Prabowo Subianto plans to make the Merah Putih Village Cooperatives (KDMP, or Kopdes Merah Putih) the distributors of subsidised goods. The move would change the distribution chain for nationally subsidised goods.

The head of state made the announcement in his speech at the peak of the 79th National Cooperatives Day commemoration at Indonesia Arena, Gelora Bung Karno, Jakarta, on Sunday, 12 July 2026. “I have made the decision: all subsidised goods must be distributed to the people through the Merah Putih Village Cooperatives. The people’s subsidised goods must not be traded, so that those in need are the ones who receive them,” Prabowo said, as quoted by Antara.

To date, subsidised goods such as 3-kilogram LPG, fertiliser and certain foodstuffs have been distributed through networks of official distributors down to retailers, before reaching the public. Under the new arrangement, all distribution would be carried out through Kopdes.

Achmad Nur Hidayat, an economist and public policy expert from Universitas Pembangunan Nasional Veteran Jakarta, considers the idea attractive on paper. The distribution chain would be shortened, prices contained, middlemen weakened, and villagers would gain closer access to subsidised goods.

However, Achmad believes public policy cannot rest on good intentions alone. “When the state shifts the distribution channel for subsidies to one dominant channel, the main question is not only who distributes, but whether that channel is ready, fair, transparent and supervised,” he said in an official statement on Monday, 13 July 2026.

According to him, the distribution of subsidised goods has so far been too long, often opaque, and open to rent-seeking. If the cooperatives are managed democratically, professionally and openly, the move could serve as a correction to village markets that have long been dominated by big traders, middlemen or closed distribution networks.

Nevertheless, Achmad views making Kopdes Merah Putih the main gateway — let alone the sole gateway — as carrying serious risks. If Kopdes as a single gateway is strong, it can plug leakages. “However, a weak single gateway instead creates queues, scarcity, quota games and new dependencies,” he said.

Moreover, Kopdes does not yet have adequate warehouses, orderly stock systems, professional managers, accurate recipient data or public complaint mechanisms; public access to subsidies could become even more difficult. If that happens, he said, the transfer of distribution would merely shift one distribution problem to another.

Leakages occur because recipient data is inaccurate, oversight is weak, price disparities are high, rent-seeking incentives remain open, and central-regional coordination is often out of sync. “If these problems are not fixed, Kopdes Merah Putih could turn into a new layer of bureaucracy, not a solution,” he said.

The fiscal burden is also substantial. In the 2026 state budget, the government allocated Rp 210.1 trillion for energy subsidies, including fuel, electricity and 3-kilogram LPG. For food, the government allocated Rp 164.4 trillion, including Rp 46.9 trillion for fertiliser subsidies totalling 9.62 million tonnes.

With sums of this magnitude, subsidy distribution is not merely a matter for village cashiers, but fiscal governance worth hundreds of trillions of rupiah. Achmad argues that good policy should start from beneficiary data, not from the distributing institution.

Achmad recommends that the government position Kopdes Merah Putih as part of a subsidy reform, not as the sole answer. The distribution of subsidised goods through Kopdes should be carried out gradually, based on a readiness audit.

More from 13 July 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/pros-and-cons-of-prabowos-idea-to-make-village-cooperatives-distributors-of-subsidised-goods-1783940316)
Originally published by Tempo Bisnis (https://bisnis.tempo.co/read/2113435/untung-rugi-ide-prabowo-jadikan-kdmp-penyalur-barang-subsidi), translated from Indonesian
Print