Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Proposed Ban on Tobacco Additives Deemed a Threat to Industry

| | Source: Media Indonesia Translated from Indonesian | Economy
Proposed Ban on Tobacco Additives Deemed a Threat to Industry
Image: Media Indonesia

The discourse on banning additives in tobacco products under a draft Minister of Health regulation has met with rejection from industry players, associations, trade unions, and even local governments. The rule is considered a potential threat to the sustainability of the legal tobacco industry, especially for small and medium-sized businesses in tobacco-producing regions.

Opposition primarily arises because additives such as menthol, sweeteners, fruit extracts, and proprietary sauce blends are considered essential elements that distinguish the flavour and aroma character of each brand. For industry players, these elements are part of the product’s identity and a key competitive factor in the market.

Henry Wardana, Chairman of the Federation of Cigarette, Tobacco, Food and Beverage Workers Unions (FSP RTMM-SPSI), stated that overly strict regulations on legal tobacco products could inadvertently expand the market for illegal cigarettes. “Consumers will still seek cigarettes that match their taste preferences. If legal cigarettes are prohibited from having flavours, they will turn to illegal ones,” Henry said on Friday (12/6). He urged the government to balance public health objectives with the protection of workers’ livelihoods, warning that millions of workers could lose their jobs.

Benny Wachjudi, Chairman of the Indonesian White Cigarette Manufacturers Association (Gaprindo), echoed these concerns. He noted that each manufacturer has a specific formulation to create aromas and tastes that appeal to consumers, and a total ban on additives would severely disrupt the industry, including the e-cigarette sector. Wachjudi also pointed out that Government Regulation No. 28/2024 still permits the use of additives if they are scientifically proven to be safe. “If safe ingredients like menthol, which have international scientific backing, are banned, then this draft regulation would contradict higher legislation,” he argued.

Local governments in tobacco-producing regions also expressed concern. Iwan, Head of the Industry and Trade Office of East Java Province, highlighted that the province hosts approximately 1,797 tobacco product companies employing over 287,000 workers. He noted that local governments have been actively encouraging small and medium-sized enterprises to develop their blending skills using food-grade additives to build product identity and competitiveness. Iwan called for a more proportional approach, advocating for restrictions based on scientific studies rather than a blanket ban.

Henry Najoan, Chairman of the Indonesian Cigarette Manufacturers Association (GAPPRI), raised an additional issue regarding the lack of accredited laboratory infrastructure in Indonesia to verify additives as stipulated by the regulation. He warned that without an independent, internationally recognized testing facility, verification results could be subjective and lead to discrimination between products. The industry is urging the government not to rush the regulation and to open dialogue with stakeholders to find a balanced solution between public health protection and the viability of the legal industry.

More from 12 June 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/proposed-ban-on-tobacco-additives-deemed-a-threat-to-industry-1781265077)
Originally published by Media Indonesia (https://mediaindonesia.com/humaniora/899895/larangan-bahan-tambahan-produk-tembakau-dinilai-ancaman), translated from Indonesian
Print