Proposal for Two Vice Presidents in Indonesia Once Debated
The restructuring of the position of the Vice President of the Republic of Indonesia was once a subject of serious debate among national figures. Leading up to Indonesia’s independence, an idea emerged for the President to be accompanied not by one, but by two Vice Presidents simultaneously.
This discourse arose during a meeting of the Investigating Committee for Preparatory Work for Independence (BPUPK) on 11 July 1945. Mohammad Yamin was the first figure to propose that the head of state be accompanied by two deputies.
According to Yamin, this idea was necessary to accommodate Indonesia’s vast territory, large population, and diverse range of ideologies. He believed that with two deputies, various community interests could be better represented.
“Surrounding the Head of State should not be one, but two Deputy Heads of State. By having one Head of State and two Deputy Heads of State, we intend to declare that the various ideologies present in our homeland are very large,” Yamin stated, as quoted in the Collection of BPUPKI and PPKI Session Minutes (1945).
Yamin further explained that the two deputies could have different functions. One would relate to the condition of the people and the vastness of Indonesia’s territory, while the other would represent the aspirations of the Muslim community.
“A Deputy Head of State is required to meet the existing conditions, namely relating to the will of the people, the vastness of the state’s territory, and the importance of occupation. And another, to illustrate the birth of the thoughts and will of the Muslim people,” Yamin added.
The idea did not remain merely a proposal during the meeting. The concept of having one or two Vice Presidents was even included in the draft Constitution (UUD).
The draft stated that the President could be assisted by one or two Vice Presidents. If there were two, they would be designated as Vice President I and Vice President II.
“(1) The President of the Republic of Indonesia holds the Government power. (2) In performing his duties, the President is assisted by one or two Vice Presidents. (3) If there are 2 Vice Presidents, the structure shall be Vice President I and Vice President II.”
In subsequent discussions, another member, Soepomo, also stated that at that time, the committee viewed the existence of two Vice Presidents as necessary. However, he argued that the constitution did not need to fix this number absolutely. The constitution should merely allow for the possibility of the President being assisted by one or two Vice Presidents.
“According to the committee’s belief at this time, it is necessary to have 2 Vice Presidents, but that is not included in the Constitution. Only the possibility of having 1 or 2 people to assist the President is provided,” Soepomo stated.
However, the idea received a different response from Mohammad Hatta. Instead of defending the two-Vice President model, Hatta proposed that one person would be sufficient.
His consideration was efficiency in running the government. Hatta requested that the provision be changed so that the President would only be assisted by one Vice President.
“In connection with the proposal, so that it can be more efficient, let there not be 2 Vice Presidents, but only one. Clause 2 can be changed to: ‘In performing his duties, the President is assisted by one Vice President,’” Hatta said.
The debate eventually led to the format known in Indonesia to this day. When Indonesia gained independence and the 1945 Constitution was ratified, the position of Vice President was filled by only one person.
Soekarno became the first President of the Republic of Indonesia, while Mohammad Hatta accompanied him as Vice President. Since then, the position of the Vice President of Indonesia has remained a single office accompanying the President.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/proposal-for-two-vice-presidents-in-indonesia-once-debated-1791370455)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/entrepreneur/20261007135316-25-774086/posisi-wakil-presiden-ri-diusulkan-ada-dua-orang), translated from Indonesian