Profile: Subhan Palal, Who Challenged Gibran’s High School Equivalency Certificate at the Supreme Court
A resident named Subhan Palal has come under the spotlight after the Supreme Court granted his appeal in a lawsuit concerning the high school equivalency certificate held by Vice-President Gibran Rakabuming Raka.
In its ruling, the Supreme Court declared that Gibran’s education equivalency certificate, which was a requirement for his candidacy in the 2024 presidential election, was legally invalid.
The ruling was handed down on Friday (30 October) and was confirmed by Palal, the plaintiff, under appeal case number 742 K/TUN/2026.
“I received a notification through my e-court account from the Supreme Court. It was dated 30 October 2026. For case number 742/K/TUN/2026, the ruling was to grant the appeal,” Palal said.
According to the Supreme Court Registrar’s official website, the appeal in case number 742 K/TUN/2026 was decided on 30 October 2026 by a panel chaired by Yulius, with Maftuh Effendi and Hari Sugiharto as members.
“Granted. The appeal is granted; the judex facti ruling is set aside and the court adjudicates the case itself: the plaintiff’s claim is granted in its entirety,” reads the ruling in the case concerning Gibran’s education equivalency certificate, as quoted on the Supreme Court Registrar’s website.
The appeal was filed through the Jakarta State Administrative Court (PTUN), under court case number 62/G/2026/PTUN.JKT. It was classified as a state administrative case and received by the Supreme Court on 23 September 2026.
Palal made three requests in the case: that his claim be granted in full; that Gibran’s education equivalency certificate be declared invalid; and that the document be withdrawn from its holder, the Director-General of General and Special Education at the Ministry of Primary and Secondary Education.
Information from various sources identifies Muhammad Subhan Palal as a lawyer and owner of the H.M. Subhan Palal & Partners law firm, based in Kebon Jeruk, West Jakarta.
Palal graduated from the Faculty of Law at the University of Indonesia, earning both a Bachelor of Laws and a Master of Laws.
Before winning this appeal, he was recorded as having filed a civil lawsuit worth Rp125 trillion against Gibran in 2025.
The lawsuit argued that the absence of a high school diploma issued under Indonesian law could affect the validity of Gibran’s current position as vice-president.
Palal’s legal actions have not focused solely on Gibran. As a practising lawyer, he has also filed a judicial review of Article 2 of the Citizenship Law with the Constitutional Court, naming Anies Baswedan in the case.
“I am one of those activists who sue officials or candidates if they violate the law. Previously, I sued a presidential candidate,” Palal said at the Central Jakarta District Court on Monday, 8 September 2025.
“The presidential candidate at the time, who I believe did not have citizenship status,” he added.
Article 2 of the Citizenship Law provides that Indonesian citizens are people of Indonesian origin and people of other nations who have been recognised as citizens under the law.
Palal said Article 2 stipulates that a person officially becomes an Indonesian citizen after receiving formal recognition. He linked citizenship status to the right to hold public office.
He argued that public office should be held by Indonesian citizens of Indonesian origin or by citizens of other nations who have received formal recognition. In Palal’s view, the process of recognition had not been clearly established.
“I asked the Constitutional Court to rule that people without citizenship must not take part in government,” Palal said at the time, explaining his reasoning.
His case at the Constitutional Court was unsuccessful. In a ruling dated 14 May 2025, the court declared that it could not accept Palal’s judicial review application.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/profile-subhan-palal-who-challenged-gibrans-high-school-equivalency-certificate-at-the-supreme-court-1793411442)
Originally published by CNN Indonesia (https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20261031072241-12-1421680/profil-subhan-palal-penggugat-suket-ijazah-sma-gibran-ke-ma), translated from Indonesian