Press Council Responds to Hotman Paris's 'Do You Have a Brain?' Remark to Journalist
The Press Council has expressed regret over remarks made by senior advocate Hotman Paris Hutapea, who is now representing former Jampidsus Febri Ardiansyah, during a press conference at the Attorney General’s Office building in South Jakarta last weekend.
During the press conference, held after accompanying his client to questioning at the Attorney General’s Office, Hotman Paris, among other things, hurled the phrase “do you have a brain?” at a journalist who asked a question in the course of carrying out journalistic duties.
In response, Press Council Chairman Komaruddin Hidayat said Hotman’s remarks were demeaning towards journalists.
“We regret the attitude of advocate Hotman Paris, who responded to a journalist’s question with an expression that was demeaning,” Komaruddin said in a video uploaded to the Press Council’s official Instagram account on Monday (20/7).
In the video uploaded to the Press Council’s Instagram account, Komaruddin said that, based on their review of the press conference at the Attorney General’s Office building, a journalist had asked: ‘Does [Hotman’s client] Febrie Adriansyah feel criminalised in the case trapping him?’ In response to the journalist’s question, Hotman said at the time: ‘What do you think? Do you have a brain or not?’
According to Komaruddin, disagreement or displeasure with a journalist’s question should be expressed in a more rational and ethical manner.
The Press Council also emphasised that it asks all parties to respect journalists in carrying out journalistic work, which is protected by law, particularly Law No. 40 of 1999 on the Press.
Komaruddin stressed that journalists ask questions as part of their journalistic duty to gather information and obtain explanations from sources about an event.
“A journalist asks questions in order to dig for information and hear a source’s version of an event, which is part of the journalistic process protected by Article 4 paragraph 3 of Law Number 40 of 1999 on the Press,” he said.
The Press Council is not alone; previously, several journalists’ professional organisations in Indonesia had already issued their own strongly worded statements condemning Hotman’s actions. Among other things, Hotman was judged to be arrogant and to have degraded the dignity of journalists.
Meanwhile, on Monday afternoon, a crowd staged a demonstration in front of Hotman’s office, located in Kelapa Gading, North Jakarta.
“An unannounced protest action by masses from Aktivis Connection took place in front of the offices of the law firm HOTMAN PARIS & Partner,” said Chief of Public Relations at Metro Jaya Regional Police, Commissioner Budi Hermanto, told journalists on Monday.
The demonstration was attended by approximately 100 people. To keep the action orderly, Budi said police personnel were deployed to provide security.
“The security force comprises 17 personnel from the Kelapa Gading Police Station,” Budi said.
In their action, the demonstrators brought three demands: reject the public dumbing-down and deviant narratives of advocate Hotman Paris; the law must be based on evidence, not shows of wealth and sensationalism; and uphold the law and eradicate advocates who defend corruptors and undermine the Indonesian state.
Meanwhile, Hotman Paris has issued an apology to journalists and all journalists’ organisations for his remarks.
“An apology from me, Hotman Paris. In connection with the appeal from the Indonesian Journalists Association (PWI) and fellow journalists, I hereby express my deepest apology for my remarks during the press conference on the case of the former Jampidsus, in which I said ‘do you have a brain or not?’” Hotman said in a short video uploaded to the hotmanparisofficial Instagram account.
Hotman then explained the sequence of events leading up to the demeaning remark towards journalists.
According to him, he was emotional when the words came out because he was bombarded with two consecutive questions.
Hotman claimed the first question posed by the journalist concerned an alleged hidden agenda by an institution in the case involving the former Jampidsus. He said at the time he had already stated that he did not know or had no capacity to answer that question.
Hotman then admitted he became emotional because the second question came while he claims he had not finished answering the first.
“In the end I became emotional because I had repeatedly said I did not know. Eventually I replied, ‘do you have a brain or not?’ What I meant was, I had already answered that I did not know. Because I could not possibly answer what the hidden agenda of a law enforcement institution was,” he said.
In posts on his social media account, Hotman also apologised after dragging President Prabowo Subianto’s name into his defence of his client. On his personal Instagram account, he said he specifically apologised to the President, Attorney General Sanitiar Burhanuddin, National Police Chief General Listyo Sigit Prabowo, and Metro Jaya Regional Police Chief Commissioner General Asep Edi Suheri for his remarks at the press conference at the Attorney General’s Office.
At the press conference at the Adhyaksa building, after accompanying Febrie, he claimed the case trapping his client was criminalisation. He said he felt disheartened seeing Febrie’s current condition, whereas during his tenure as Jampidsus, Febrie was a high achiever of whom President Prabowo was proud, having succeeded in recovering state assets in a fantastic amount.
“Whatever I said was purely from a legal advocacy standpoint; there was no political motivation or involvement whatsoever. It was purely speech as a lawyer whose duty is to try to protect his client legally,” he said in his apology post, quoted on Monday afternoon.
“Once again, Mr President of the Republic of Indonesia, Mr Attorney General, Mr National Police Chief, and Mr Metro Jaya Regional Police Chief, once again Hotman apologises. That is all and thank you,” he added.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/press-council-responds-to-hotman-pariss-do-you-have-a-brain-remark-to-journalist-1784555645)
Originally published by CNN Indonesia (https://www.cnnindonesia.com/nasional/20260720193234-12-1382877/dewan-pers-respons-pernyataan-hotman-paris-lu-punya-otak-enggak), translated from Indonesian