Press Council Regrets Hotman Paris's 'Do You Have a Brain?' Remark to Journalists
The Press Council has expressed regret over remarks made by Hotman Paris Hutapea, lawyer for former Special Prosecutor Febrie Adriansyah, which were deemed demeaning to the journalistic profession. The Press Council reminded that disagreement with a journalist’s question should be conveyed courteously.
“Disagreement or displeasure with a journalist’s question should be expressed in a more rational, courteous and ethical manner. Mutual respect is considered essential to maintaining a healthy relationship between sources and members of the press,” said Press Council Chairman Komaruddin Hidayat in a statement on Tuesday (21/7/2026).
Komaruddin Hidayat also reminded all parties to respect journalists in carrying out their journalistic duties, as a journalist’s questions form part of journalistic work protected by law.
“The questions posed by journalists are part of the effort to unearth information and obtain statements from sources, as part of the journalistic process protected under Article 4 paragraph (3) of Law Number 40 of 1999 on the Press,” he said.
Furthermore, Komaruddin Hidayat affirmed that journalistic work plays a strategic role as mandated by Article 6 of the Press Law, namely fulfilling the public’s right to information, upholding democratic values, promoting the rule of law and human rights, developing public opinion based on correct and accurate information, carrying out oversight, criticism and correction, and championing justice and truth.
In his statement, Komaruddin Hidayat also reminded journalists to continue adhering to the code of ethics, solely to safeguard public trust.
“Journalists should always comply with the Press Law and the Journalistic Code of Ethics in carrying out their profession so that public trust in the press is maintained,” he said.
Hotman Apologises After Drawing Criticism
As is known, Hotman Paris made statements that drew condemnation during a press conference at the Attorney General’s Office building in South Jakarta on Friday (17/7). An emotional Hotman uttered phrases such as ‘do you have a brain?’, ‘ask your grandfather’, ‘shut up’, and ‘if you had a brain you would know the answer’.
At that press conference, Hotman Paris sat as counsel for the former Special Prosecutor for Special Crimes (Jampidsus) at the Indonesian Attorney General’s Office, Febrie Adriansyah. During the press conference, Hotman also invoked the name of President Prabowo Subianto whilst defending Febrie.
Hotman subsequently apologised. His first apology concerned the remark ‘do you have a brain?’ directed at a journalist.
“A statement of apology from me, Hotman Paris. In connection with the appeal from the Indonesian Journalists Association (PWI) and fellow journalists, I hereby express my deepest apologies for my remarks at the press conference concerning the former Jampidsus case, in which I said ‘do you have a brain?’” said Hotman in a video uploaded to his official Instagram account.
Hotman then explained the reason behind his words. He claimed he had been asked the same question several times, and admitted the remark came about due to anger.
“In the end I lost my temper because I kept going back and forth saying I did not know, so I eventually replied, ‘Do you have a brain?’. What I meant was, I had already answered that I did not know,” he said.
He once again extended an apology to journalists, saying he had no ill intent.
PWI Files Report Against Hotman Paris
Meanwhile, the Indonesian Journalists Association (PWI) has taken legal action over the ‘do you have a brain?’ remark made by Hotman Paris Hutapea during the press conference. Hotman Paris has now been reported to Polda Metro Jaya for statements deemed demeaning to the journalistic profession.
Edison Siahaan, Director of the Anti-Violence Against Journalists division of PWI Central, assessed that Hotman Paris’s remarks not only caused hurt but also demeaned the journalistic profession.
“As we know, yesterday there was an incident that was genuinely hurtful and insulting to the journalistic profession. So, we from PWI Central want to report the person who suggested that a journalist might not have a brain. As we all know, journalists are intelligent people,” Edison told reporters at Polda Metro Jaya, Jakarta, on Monday (20/7/2026).
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/press-council-regrets-hotman-pariss-do-you-have-a-brain-remark-to-journalists-1784605983)
Originally published by detikcom (https://news.detik.com/berita/d-8583018/dewan-pers-sesalkan-ucapan-hotman-lu-punya-otak-nggak-yang-rendahkan-wartawan), translated from Indonesian