Indonesian Political, Business & Finance News

Presidential Wiretapping, Treason and Abuse of Authority

| Source: CNBC Indonesia Translated from Indonesian | Legal
Presidential Wiretapping, Treason and Abuse of Authority
Image: CNBC Indonesia

Note: This article represents the author’s personal opinion and does not reflect the views of the CNBCIndonesia.com editorial team.

Several senior Indonesian National Police (Polri) officials, including former National Police Chief General Listyo Sigit Prabowo, are reportedly suspected of involvement in wiretapping President Prabowo Subianto, state officials, political figures, civil society activists and others. The allegations are shocking.

The wiretapping was, of course, not connected to law enforcement, but appears to have been unlawful interception. Fortunately, the police have exposed the alleged unlawful interception and arrested people suspected of being involved.

Wiretapping is an extraordinary measure used in law enforcement. It is needed to investigate highly complex cases and serious crimes, such as corruption, bribery, terrorism, narcotics offences and other serious criminal acts.

Wiretapping is lawful when conducted in accordance with legal procedures. If those procedures are not followed, however, it constitutes a violation of the law, or unlawful interception.

The alleged illegal wiretapping of numerous people, including the President, by the former National Police chief and several generals falls into the categories of treason, abuse of authority and human rights violations.

First, the alleged act of treason. Illegal surveillance of the President could be categorised as treason under the Criminal Code. The unlawful action may have been intended to prevent the President from governing or to overthrow him by illegitimate means.

The potential penalties are severe: life imprisonment or a maximum of 20 years in prison. The treason allegation must be investigated seriously by the National Police’s Criminal Investigation Department, which is currently examining the case, since treason is a serious crime, particularly when directed at the Head of State and Head of Government.

Second, abuse of authority, since the wiretapping was not carried out for law enforcement purposes and allegedly did not follow proper procedures. Article 258 of the Criminal Code states that “any person who unlawfully listens to, records, diverts, alters, obstructs and/or takes notes of the transmission of non-public Electronic Information and/or Electronic Documents, whether using a wired or wireless communications network, shall be punished by imprisonment for up to 10 years or a fine of up to category VI”.

Third, human rights violations. Wiretapping fundamentally infringes citizens’ right to privacy. Article 32 of Law No. 39 of 1999 on Human Rights provides that “the freedom and confidentiality of correspondence, including communications through electronic means, may not be interfered with, except by order of a judge or other lawful authority in accordance with the provisions of laws and regulations”.

From a human rights perspective, the alleged illegal interception by several police generals clearly violates the rights to privacy and communication guaranteed by Law No. 39/1999 on Human Rights. This unlawful interception threatens not only state officials but also the rights of citizens.

Beyond these three alleged legal violations, it is important to establish the motive for the wiretapping of the President and others. There has been much speculation, ranging from political motives to national security concerns. But among the various motives being discussed, none relates to law enforcement.

This further strengthens the suspicion that the illegal wiretapping was politically motivated. At this point, law enforcement officials need to uncover the motive behind the alleged unlawful surveillance of the President and others.

If the motive was indeed political, investigators should establish who ordered the wiretapping and who stood to gain politically from it. Those people must be identified by law enforcement and may form part of a group suspected of abuse of authority and treason.

To prevent future abuse, wiretapping should be comprehensively regulated through a dedicated law. In Constitutional Court ruling No. 006/PUU-I/2003, the Court stated: “To prevent the possible abuse of authority in wiretapping and recording, the Court considers it necessary to establish regulatory instruments governing the requirements and procedures for such wiretapping and recording.”

Constitutional Court ruling No. 5/PUU-VIII/2010 further affirmed that wiretapping must be regulated by law, since the subject matter concerns restrictions on human rights, which the Constitution requires to be addressed through legislation.

At present, wiretapping is not regulated in detail by a dedicated law. Instead, its rules are spread across several pieces of legislation, and the approach differs from one law to another.

There is no comprehensive regulation serving as a standard or reference for conducting wiretapping. This is a concern for the protection of human rights: the absence of detailed rules on surveillance risks human rights violations and is inconsistent with constitutional principles.

Regulation of wiretapping must accommodate two major interests. First, it must protect human rights, particularly the right to privacy. Second, it must support law enforcement, for which wiretapping can help authorities uncover certain crimes in order to protect the public interest. The rules must therefore be carefully drafted to prevent abuse.

More from 9 November 2026 →

Cite this article
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/presidential-wiretapping-treason-and-abuse-of-authority-1794210628)
Originally published by CNBC Indonesia (https://www.cnbcindonesia.com/opini/20261109132618-14-783558/penyadapan-presiden-makar-dan-penyalahgunaan-wewenang), translated from Indonesian
Print