Prabowo Rejects Neoliberal Theory, Says Indonesia Is on the Right Path
INDOPOLITIKA – President Prabowo Subianto has affirmed that Indonesia must not entrust its economic development entirely to neoliberal theory and free-market mechanisms. He made the statement while inaugurating 80,081 Red and White Village/Neighbourhood Cooperatives in Klaten, Central Java, on Monday, 21 July 2025.
In Prabowo’s view, it is not enough for the state to simply generate economic growth and then wait for the benefits to “trickle down” from the wealthy and capital owners to the lower classes. He considers that process far too slow, while the people need improvements in welfare, employment, affordable food, healthcare services and access to capital much more quickly.
Prabowo therefore promotes an economic approach that gives a greater role to the state, cooperatives, state-owned enterprises and national business players. The establishment of the Red and White Village Cooperatives is positioned as a form of direct intervention so that economic activity, the distribution of goods, financing and profits can reach village communities. The government describes the programme as part of an effort to build a more inclusive economy from the village level upwards.
What is Neoliberalism?
Neoliberalism is an economic and political school of thought that places markets, competition, private ownership and freedom of enterprise as the primary drivers of the economy.
Under this approach, government remains necessary, but its role tends to be limited to that of rule-maker, guarantor of stability, protector of property rights and enforcer of fair competition. Production and distribution activities are generally left to private companies and market price mechanisms.
Policies often associated with neoliberalism include:
Privatisation of state-owned companies or services.
Deregulation and simplification of business rules.
Free trade and the lowering of import barriers.
The opening of investment flows and foreign capital.
Reduction of government subsidies.
Limits on deficits and state spending.
Leaving prices to market mechanisms.
Reduced direct government involvement in production.
Neoliberalism does not necessarily mean the state disappears entirely. In practice, governments still play a strong role in shaping the rules and institutions that support the functioning of markets.
The term itself is also frequently debated. Not all figures or administrations that carry out privatisation and deregulation call themselves neoliberal. The term is more often used by academics and critics to describe a set of market-oriented policies.
What is the Link with Trickle-Down Theory?
Prabowo’s critique of neoliberalism is often connected to trickle-down economics.
The basic idea is that if the government gives ample room to investment, companies and high-income groups, economic activity will flourish. Companies will open businesses, build factories, purchase goods, invest and create jobs.
Ultimately, growth at the top is expected to benefit those at the bottom in the form of employment, rising incomes, tax revenue and increased economic activity.
The problem is that economic growth does not automatically produce equality. Wealth can become concentrated among capital owners when workers’ bargaining positions are weak, competition is unhealthy, education is unevenly distributed, and the state lacks adequate redistribution policies.
The IMF itself has acknowledged that some policies often associated with neoliberalism, particularly capital account liberalisation and overly tight fiscal austerity, can increase inequality. Such inequality can ultimately undermine the strength and sustainability of economic growth.
Thus, the question is not merely whether growth occurs, but who receives the greatest benefits from that growth.
How is Neoliberalism Applied?
The application of neoliberalism usually involves several policies at once.
First, governments sell or hand over the management of state companies to private parties. The aim is to improve efficiency, as private companies are assumed to have stronger incentives to cut costs and pursue profit.
Second, the government reduces regulation. Licensing, labour rules, investment restrictions and trade regulations are loosened so businesses can move faster.
Third, import tariffs are lowered so goods from various countries can enter and compete in the domestic market. Competition is expected to make prices cheaper and local companies more efficient.
Fourth, subsidies for energy, food, transport or public services are cut. Supporters argue subsidies are often poorly targeted and burden the state budget.
Fifth, the government maintains fiscal discipline by limiting debt, deficits and state spending. However, overly aggressive austerity can reduce healthcare, education, social protection and infrastructure development.
Which Countries Have Implemented It?
No country applies neoliberalism in its pure form. Most combine market mechanisms with subsidies, social protection, regulation and government intervention.
However, several countries are often cited as examples of neoliberal policy implementation.
- Britain under Margaret Thatcher
The Thatcher government in the 1980s privatised numerous state companies, weakened trade unions, loosened regulation and gave wider room to the private sector. These policies helped transform Britain’s economic structure and spurred the services and finance sectors. Yet they were also criticised for industrial closures, rising unemployment in industrial regions and widening inter-regional inequality.
- The United States under Ronald Reagan
The Reagan administration pursued tax cuts, deregulation, cuts to various government programmes and business-friendly policies. Supporters credit these policies with boosting investment and economic activity; critics argue the greatest benefits went to the rich while income inequality widened.
- Chile under Augusto Pinochet
Chile is often described as one of the early laboratories of free-market economic reform. The government privatised companies, opened trade, reduced subsidies and overhauled the pension system. The reforms helped control several economic problems and produced growth in certain periods, but they were implemented under an authoritarian government and left enduring debates over inequality, pensions, public services and access to education and healthcare.
- New Zealand in the 1980s
New Zealand carried out major reforms through the abolition of subsidies, trade liberalisation, tax reform and the restructuring of state-owned enterprises. These reforms made the economy more open and competitive, but the adjustment process also caused unemployment and pressure on sectors previously protected by the government.
- Latin American countries
In the 1980s and 1990s, a number of Latin American countries pursued privatisation, trade liberalisation, subsidy cuts and fiscal austerity. Some policies succeeded in lowering inflation and stabilising economies. However, outcomes varied. In several countries, reform was accompanied by inequality, unemployment, rising costs of public services and social discontent.
Has Indonesia Ever Pursued Neoliberal Policies?
Indonesia has never officially adopted neoliberalism as a state economic ideology. However, several market-oriented policies have been implemented, particularly through deregulation, the privatisation of some state assets, trade liberalisation, the opening of foreign investment and subsidy reductions.
Economic reform intensified after the 1997–1998 Asian financial crisis. During that period, Indonesia carried out banking restructuring, closed a number of banks, reduced various forms of protection and implemented economic reforms as part of a programme with the IMF.
Some reforms were necessary to restore confidence and stabilise the economy. However, the crisis experience also prompted criticism that financial liberalisation and dependence on foreign capital can leave developing countries vulnerable to global shocks.
To this day, Indonesia in fact operates a mixed economic system. Markets and private companies play a large role, but the government also controls state-owned enterprises, provides subsidies, implements social protection programmes, builds infrastructure and regulates strategic sectors.
Why is Indonesia Considered Unsuitable for Pure Neoliberalism?
According to the line of thinking articulated by Prabowo, there are several reasons why neoliberalism is not suitable for Indonesia in its pure form.
First, the constitutional mandate gives the state an important role.
Article 33 of the 1945 Constitution affirms that the economy is organised as a common endeavour based on the principle of kinship. Branches of production vital to the state and affecting the livelihood of the many must also be controlled by the state.
Therefore, the state cannot entirely hand over the management of food, energy, water, minerals, transport and other strategic sectors to market mechanisms.
State control does not necessarily mean all activities must be carried out directly by the government. But the state must retain the ability to regulate, supervise, manage and ensure that resource benefits are used for the prosperity of the people.
Second, levels of inequality and societal capacity vary widely.
In a fully free market, those who possess capital, technology, information and networks will hold a stronger position.
Meanwhile, smallholder farmers, fishers, market traders, informal workers and micro-enterprises often face constraints in capital, access to financing, technology, storage and marketing.
If the state does not intervene, weaker groups can lose out in competition not because they are unproductive, but because their starting points and access differ.
Third, Indonesia is a vast archipelagic nation.
The costs of distributing goods and building public services are not uniform across regions. Market mechanisms tend to concentrate investment in densely populated and profitable areas.
Remote regions, small islands, border areas and regions with low purchasing power risk being left behind if development follows only profit considerations.
The state needs to be present because building schools, hospitals, roads, ports, electricity networks and telecommunications in remote areas is not always immediately commercially profitable.
Fourth, Indonesia possesses abundant natural resources.
Prabowo believes natural wealth must be processed domestically and deliver added value to the Indonesian people.
If economic activity is entirely left to the free market, raw materials can more easily be exported without processing. The greatest profits then accrue to companies that own the capital and processing technology.
Therefore, the government promotes mineral downstreaming and the development of processing industries. This policy is a form of state intervention and not fully consistent with free-market principles.
Fifth, food and energy security cannot be measured by profit alone.
Markets prioritise goods that are most profitable to produce or import. But the state must consider supply security.
Excessive dependence on food and energy imports can become a problem in the event of war, global crises, trade disruptions, price changes or disasters.
In Prabowo’s view, the state must safeguard food production, national reserves, fertiliser distribution, energy supply and strategic industrial capacity, even if short-term costs are not always the cheapest.
Sixth, growth does not automatically produce equality.
Prabowo rejects the assumption that the profits of large groups will automatically flow to the whole population.
Without fair taxation, worker protection, support for MSMEs, cooperatives, education, healthcare services and regional development, growth can become concentrated in a handful of companies and regions.
Therefore, the government has chosen direct programmes such as free nutritious meals, village cooperatives, subsidies, housing development, food security, downstreaming and social protection as instruments of equalisation.
Cooperatives as an Alternative
Cooperatives occupy an important position in Prabowo’s economic vision because they combine business activity with shared ownership.
In ordinary companies, profits belong primarily to shareholders according to the amount of capital they hold. In cooperatives, members act as both owners and users of services. Profits or remaining business results can be distributed to members according to the cooperative’s rules.
Through the Red and White Village Cooperatives, the government intends to build an economic network at village level capable of managing the sale of staple goods, warehousing, fertiliser distribution, healthcare services, savings and loans, and the marketing of community produce.
The concept is intended to shorten distribution chains and reduce the dependence of farmers and small traders on middlemen or intermediaries.
However, cooperative success still depends on governance. Cooperatives can fail if managed unprofessionally, influenced by political interests, overly dependent on government assistance, or lacking a sound business model.
Is Prabowo Entirely Rejecting the Market?
Prabowo’s rejection of neoliberalism should not be read as a rejection of all market mechanisms, private investment or international trade.
The government still needs private companies to create jobs, bring in capital, develop technology and increase production. Indonesia also continues to need investment and trade relations with other countries.
What is rejected is the notion that markets can always solve every problem and that the state can simply stand by as a spectator.
Thus, the direction being offered is more accurately described as a mixed economy or a people’s economy: markets continue to function, but the state helps steer development, protects vulnerable communities and controls sectors deemed strategic.
State Intervention Also Carries Risks
Although neoliberalism has weaknesses, state intervention is not without risk either.
Poorly managed state-owned enterprises can produce losses, inefficiency, monopolies, corruption and burdens on the budget. Poorly targeted subsidies may largely benefit the well-off. Excessive protection can also render domestic companies uncompetitive.
Therefore, Indonesia’s economic choice is not simply “market versus state”. The core issue is how to build a healthy market alongside a competent and accountable government.
The state needs to be present in strategic sectors and to protect the people, but its intervention must be transparent, measurable and accountable.
Conclusion
Neoliberalism emphasises free markets, privatisation, deregulation, open trade and a reduced direct role for government. The approach can encourage competition, investment, efficiency and innovation.
However, its application can also increase inequality, weaken public services and leave small groups behind.
Source: jawawa.id (https://jawawa.id/newsitem/prabowo-rejects-neoliberal-theory-says-indonesia-is-on-the-right-path-1783871420)
Originally published by indopolitika.com (https://indopolitika.com/prabowo-tolak-teori-neolib-sebut-indonesia-sudah-berjalan-ke-arah-yang-benar/?amp), translated from Indonesian